What is the biggest difference among the three standards?
The biggest difference is not the nutrient numbers but who made the standard and how much legal force it has. AAFCO is an association of state and federal feed regulators in the United States, and FEDIAF is a federation of the European pet food manufacturing industry. South Korea's standards are the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법), made by the National Assembly, and an administrative rule notified by the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA), that is, national law.
So even when the same word, complete or balanced, appears on a label, the structure behind it differs. In the United States, the association creates model rules and nutrient profiles, and each state adopts them as its own law and enforces them. In Europe, the law sets the labeling method and feed types, and industry guidelines fill in the nutrient values. In South Korea, current law sets ingredient registration and labeling, and an amendment that would put nutrition standards for dogs and cats into the legal framework is scheduled to take effect in September 2028.
This article does not rank the three standards or judge which is superior. Its purpose is to separate whose each standard is, what it sets and what it does not set, so that pet owners reading a label can recognize which system a statement comes from. The meaning of the complete feed label itself, calorie labeling and reading the guaranteed analysis are covered in separate articles, so they are mentioned here only as far as needed for comparing the standards.
What kind of organization is AAFCO and what does it set?
The members of AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) are feed regulators responsible under state or federal law for regulating the manufacture, sale and distribution of feed. The AAFCO website says that AAFCO provides these regulators with ingredient definitions, label standards and laboratory standards.
The same page explains that AAFCO is a forum where regulators discuss enforcement issues, and that regulatory authority comes from the state or federal law that the member works under. One of AAFCO's early activities was drafting model rules, begun in 1909, with the aim of creating sample rules that state governments could adopt in their own language so that neighboring states would use similar rules.
AAFCO's consumer guidance page is more direct. It says that AAFCO does not regulate, test, approve or certify pet food, and that it creates model language that state governments or other bodies can adopt into law. It also says that many states build their feed laws on the AAFCO model bill and model regulations, and that the FDA and state governments enforce the law. The page also states that AAFCO members are feed regulators, not veterinarians, and do not give veterinary advice.
On nutrient standards, the FDA's page on complete and balanced pet food explains that AAFCO first created the dog nutrient profiles in 1991 and the cat profiles in 1992, and most recently updated them in 2016. The profiles have a minimum amount for each nutrient and, for some, a maximum amount. For each of dogs and cats there are two kinds, one for growth and reproduction and one for adult maintenance, and the FDA notes that the profiles are expressed on a dry matter basis (weight with the moisture removed), whereas the guaranteed analysis on a label is on an as-fed basis, which includes moisture.
What kind of organization is FEDIAF and how does it relate to EU law?
FEDIAF (European Pet Food Industry Federation) is a federation that represents the European pet food manufacturing industry. The FEDIAF website says that the federation created nutritional guidelines that its member companies follow. The guidelines are titled Nutritional Guidelines for Complete and Complementary Pet Food for Cats and Dogs, and the latest edition at the time it was opened was the 2025 edition.
The website describes the guidelines as a manual made easy for manufacturers to use by comprehensively reviewing material from the US National Research Council (NRC) and the existing scientific literature, and says they are reviewed by independent veterinary nutritionists across Europe. The purpose is to confirm the basic nutrient levels of dog and cat food and to help manufacturers assess the nutritional value of food for healthy animals, and they are also material that the EU and national authorities, consumer groups and experts consult. However, this page does not say that the guidelines are legally binding, only that member companies follow them.
The legal framework is separate. The EU regulation on the placing on the market and use of feed (Regulation (EC) No 767/2009) defines complete feed and complementary feed in Article 3, and the content of those definitions is explained in the article on complete feed labeling. Article 15 requires labeling of the feed type (complete or complementary), the name and address of the responsible business operator, the batch number, the net weight, additives, moisture content and so on, and Article 17 requires labeling of the target animal, directions for use, the minimum storage period, the composition (ingredients in descending order) and so on. Articles 25 and 26 provide for codes of good labeling practice approved by the Commission, but state that their use is voluntary. In the range read for this article, there was no provision in this regulation under the name of nutritional guidelines.
In summary, in the EU the law sets the framework for labeling and feed types, and industry guidelines fill in the nutrient values. Whether the guideline values are expressed per how many kcal, per how many MJ, or per how many g of dry matter could not be confirmed on the FEDIAF page opened for this article, and the body text of the original PDF could not be read even when opened.
What are South Korea's standards now, and what is scheduled to change?
In South Korea, pet food is subject to the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법). Article 12 of the Act has an ingredient registration system under which a manufacturer or importer registers with the city or provincial governor the type, ingredients and ingredient amounts of the feed it intends to manufacture or import. The detailed standards are in the MAFRA notice Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) (Notice No. 2024-27, in effect from April 1, 2024).
Annex 13 of this notice sets the ingredient registration items for compound feed; for feed for companion animals (애완용동물), the manufacturer sets the feed name and range of use by animal and growth stage, and the registered ingredients are crude protein, crude fat, calcium, phosphorus, crude fiber, crude ash and moisture (14% max.; if exceeded, the reason and supporting data must be submitted). Annex 3-3 provides that feed names are formed from the growth stage and the animal name, and that for companion (pet) animals they may be subdivided by breed, body weight and feeding purpose (complete (main) food or treat). In other words, what was confirmed in the current notice that relates to dogs and cats is naming, ingredient registration and labeling, and a nutrient standards table setting minimum amounts of essential amino acids or vitamins was not found in the text of the notice opened while writing this article.
A change is scheduled. A MAFRA press release of December 16, 2024 said that the amendment introduces nutritional standards for dog food and cat food. A product that meets the nutrient requirements by growth stage of dogs and cats may be labeled as complete pet feed (반려동물완전사료), products that do not meet them are classified as other pet feed (반려동물기타사료), and the nutrition standards, which are the basis for the nutrient requirements, are to be prepared by the National Institute of Animal Science. As an example, it wrote that dog food can be labeled as complete feed if it meets minimum-content standards for about 30 items such as essential amino acids, essential fatty acids, minerals and vitamins. A DailyVet article of December 2025 reported that the nutrition standards specify recommended nutrient contents of 38 to 43 kinds depending on the growth stage of dogs and cats, and that the notice includes a requirement that it must be possible to prove that a product was manufactured to the nutrition standards. This amendment was promulgated in September 2025 and is scheduled to take effect in September 2028, and DailyVet reported that the government is considering extending the grace period by about 1 more year. Since the effective date may change, it is safer to check it in a MAFRA announcement.
In this structure, South Korea does not use the AAFCO-style approach of taking an association's profiles as a model; instead, a national research institution creates the nutrition standards and the notice uses them. That the legal standard comes from the state is what differs from the two overseas standards.
How do the three standards compare at a glance?
The table below contains only what was opened and confirmed directly for this article. A cell that says it could not be confirmed does not mean it does not actually exist; it means this article could not confirm it, so it is better not to assume that anything missing from the table either exists or does not exist. The South Korea column separates the current standard from the one scheduled to take effect.
As the table shows, units and life stage divisions are used differently in each standard. Comparing the numbers with each other requires unit conversion, and conversion methods are covered in the articles on the dry matter basis and on calorie labeling. Also, the South Korea column of the table separates the current standard from the scheduled one because the current notice applies to products placed on the market before September 2028, and the content of the amended notice should not be read as a description of products on sale now.
| Item compared | AAFCO (United States) | FEDIAF (Europe) | South Korea (current · scheduled to take effect 2028.9) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who makes it | Association of state and federal feed regulators | European pet food industry federation | National Assembly (Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법)), MAFRA (notice), National Institute of Animal Science (nutrition standards, scheduled) |
| Nature of the standard | Model rules and nutrient profiles; become law only when a state adopts them | Voluntary industry nutritional guidelines that member companies follow | Law and administrative rules (state regulation) |
| Enforcement | AAFCO does not regulate, approve or certify; state governments and the FDA enforce | The guidelines themselves are not a means of law enforcement; labeling is under EU Regulation 767/2009 | Ingredient registration with city or provincial governors; under MAFRA jurisdiction |
| Nutrient standards | Dog and cat nutrient profiles (minimum amounts, maximum amounts for some) | Nutritional guidelines for complete and complementary food for dogs and cats (2025 edition) | Current: a table of minimum nutrient amounts for dogs and cats not found. Scheduled: nutrition standards of the National Institute of Animal Science |
| Units of values | Dry matter basis (guaranteed analysis on the label is as-fed basis) | Not confirmed in this article | Current registered ingredients are % of feed, moisture 14% max., etc. The unit of the nutrition standards could not be confirmed |
| Life stages | Growth and reproduction, adult maintenance (2 profiles) | Not confirmed in this article | Current: the manufacturer names products by growth stage. Scheduled: requirements by growth stage |
| Labeling terms | Nutritional adequacy statement (complete and balanced) | Complete feed and complementary feed distinction under EU regulation | Scheduled: complete pet feed (반려동물완전사료) and other pet feed (반려동물기타사료) |
What status does a statement of meeting a foreign standard have in South Korea?
A statement of meeting a foreign standard is an explanation used by that country or by the manufacturer, and this article could not confirm any provision in the current notice that recognizes such a statement as meeting a nutrition standard. For imported feed, South Korea's current notice provides that feed distributed in the exporting country must carry the labeling made in the exporting country, that a sticker printed in Korean may be attached so that it does not come off, and that the main label information on the original package, such as the product name, ingredient names and dates, must not be covered (Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격), Annex 15).
The same Annex 15 requires imported feed to show the exporting country and the manufacturer's name together, and provides that foreign certification marks that domestic law does not permit (HACCP feed factory, organic, eco-friendly, etc.) may not be shown. It also provides that if the registered ingredients labeled in the exporting country deviate, compared with the ingredient amounts on the Korean feed ingredient registration certificate, from the tolerance in Annex 4 of the feed inspection standards, they must be covered with a sticker or the like. This means that for imported feed sold in South Korea, the numbers registered in South Korea are the reference.
DailyVet reported that at a Korea Pet Feed Association forum, regarding the rule that using expressions such as food a person can eat requires proving that food-related law standards are met, a question was asked about whether, for overseas manufacture, meeting the food-related law of the exporting country is also recognized, and a MAFRA official answered that overseas food-related law is not recognized and Korean domestic food-related law must be met. This answer concerned the expression that a person can eat it, not a nutrition standard, and because it is a media report, the exact application should be checked in the text of the notice and MAFRA guidance.
In summary, a label saying AAFCO or FEDIAF is met can be read as information about the source of the standard. However, AAFCO says it does not certify feed itself, and the FEDIAF guidelines are a voluntary industry guideline, so neither is a label that the Korean notice has defined as a nutrition standard. What verification was used to write that statement is something the manufacturer must explain.
How to check an imported feed label
When looking at imported feed, you can check the following items, keeping in mind that the standards for comparison come from different systems. These are not a judgment about which product is better but items to read on the label.
- Check whether there is Korean-language labeling, and whether it includes the ingredient registration number registered in South Korea, the registered ingredient amounts, and the importer's company name and address.
- Check whether the exporting country and the manufacturer's name are also written in Korean.
- Check which standard a foreign-language nutrition statement is based on. Read whether there is a basis such as meeting an AAFCO profile or passing a feeding trial, and what the life stage is.
- The guaranteed analysis on a foreign label may be on an as-fed basis, and mixing it with dry matter basis values makes the comparison inaccurate, so check the moisture content first when comparing numbers.
- Check whether the Korean sticker shows an example of the order when the order of the date labeling (manufacture or import date, sell-by date) differs from the Korean style.
- Check whether foreign certification marks such as organic or HACCP remain as they are on the Korean package. The current notice prohibits showing foreign certification marks that domestic law does not permit.
If questions remain, you can ask the importer, using the phone number printed on the product package, about the standard it is based on and the analysis data. A diet related to a pet's illness or special condition cannot be decided by this article, so you must consult an animal hospital.
What are the common misconceptions, and when should you make an inquiry?
The first misconception is the idea that AAFCO approves or certifies feed. AAFCO says on its consumer guidance page that it does not regulate, test, approve or certify pet food. The second is the idea that the FEDIAF guidelines are EU law. The FEDIAF page that was opened describes them as guidelines that member companies follow, and they are a document separate from Regulation 767/2009, which is EU law. The third is the idea that nutrition standards are already in force in South Korea. As far as this article confirmed, the amended notice is scheduled to take effect in September 2028, and a nutrient standards table for dogs and cats is not found in the current notice.
The fourth misconception is that the numbers of these three standards can be compared as they are. Units and standards may differ, so even the same nutrient will not line up if compared without conversion. The fifth is the idea that a statement of meeting a foreign standard is a legal assurance in South Korea. As seen above, no provision recognizing such a statement as meeting a nutrition standard is found in the current notice, and showing foreign certification marks that domestic law does not permit is restricted.
In these cases an inquiry is needed. Ask the manufacturer or importer about a product's nutritional basis or analysis data, ask MAFRA or the competent city or province about the law and whether labeling is in violation, and ask an animal hospital if the pet shows vomiting, diarrhea, reduced appetite or weight change after a change of feed, or has a special condition such as pregnancy, growth stage, old age or a chronic disease. This article does not give a diagnosis or feeding instructions.
Frequently asked questions
Q Can I trust a label that says AAFCO-certified feed?
AAFCO says on its consumer guidance page that it does not regulate, test, approve or certify pet food. So the expression AAFCO-certified should be read not as meaning AAFCO certified it, but as meaning the manufacturer labeled it on the basis of AAFCO's nutrient profiles or feeding procedures. Check what the basis is from the label wording and the manufacturer's explanation.
Q Is the FEDIAF standard a legal obligation in Europe?
The FEDIAF website introduces these nutritional guidelines as guidelines that member companies follow and does not mention legal force. Feed type labeling and label items are set separately by EU Regulation 767/2009. To learn more about how the two documents relate, you need to check the original FEDIAF guidelines and the EU regulation directly, and this article could not confirm that far.
Q Does South Korea have no nutrition standards for dogs and cats?
In the current Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) (Notice No. 2024-27) confirmed while writing this article, a table of minimum nutrient amounts for dogs and cats was not found, and feed for companion animals (애완용동물) was handled by registering crude protein, crude fat, calcium, phosphorus, crude fiber, crude ash and moisture. The amended notice promulgated in September 2025 is scheduled to put complete feed labeling that uses the nutrition standards of the National Institute of Animal Science into effect from September 2028.
Q What review does a product go through now to be called complete feed in South Korea?
A separate review system for labeling dog and cat complete feed was not confirmed in the current notice. MAFRA has said that when the amended notice takes effect, products that meet the nutrition standards will be labeled complete pet feed (반려동물완전사료) and products that do not will be labeled other pet feed (반려동물기타사료). It is better to check the details of the system as of now in a MAFRA announcement.
Q Can I compare the foreign nutrient values of imported feed directly with Korean feed?
A direct comparison may not line up. The FDA explains that AAFCO profiles are on a dry matter basis, whereas the guaranteed analysis on a label is on an as-fed basis that includes moisture. For imported feed sold in South Korea, the ingredient amounts registered in South Korea are the reference, so check the registered ingredient amounts and the moisture content together in the Korean-language labeling.
Q Which is stricter, AAFCO or FEDIAF?
This article does not answer that comparison. The two standards differ in who makes them, legal force, units and life stage divisions, so strictness cannot be ranked by numbers alone, and the numerical system of the FEDIAF guidelines could not be confirmed in the materials opened. For detailed differences in nutrition standards, ask the original guidelines or a veterinary nutrition expert.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article is based on the AAFCO, FDA and FEDIAF web pages opened on 2026-11-19, the first 100,000 characters of the text of EU Regulation 767/2009, the text of the Korean notice saved from the Ministry of Government Legislation, a MAFRA press release and trade press reports. The body of the FEDIAF nutritional guidelines PDF could not be read, so the units of the FEDIAF values (per kcal, per MJ, whether dry matter basis) and the life stage divisions could not be confirmed. The original text of the nutrition standards of the National Institute of Animal Science was also not opened, and individual values of the AAFCO profiles are not covered. The effective date of the amended notice may change, and the interpretation of the current notice must be checked against the original text from the Ministry of Government Legislation and MAFRA guidance. A diet for a pet with an illness or special condition is outside the scope of this article and requires consultation with an animal hospital.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- About AAFCO ↗
Used as the basis for the explanation that AAFCO is an association of regulators that creates model rules and that regulatory authority comes from the members' state and federal law.
- Understanding Pet Food ↗
Used as the basis for the points that AAFCO does not regulate, test, approve or certify pet food, that states adopt its model language, and that the FDA and states enforce.
- "Complete and Balanced" Pet Food ↗
Used as the basis for explaining the years the AAFCO nutrient profiles were established and updated, the two kinds of profiles, and the difference between dry matter basis and as-fed basis.
- Nutritional Guidelines (FEDIAF) ↗
Used as the basis for the publisher and purpose of the FEDIAF nutritional guidelines, the 2025 edition, and their nature as guidelines that member companies follow.
- Regulation (EC) No 767/2009 on the placing on the market and use of feed ↗
Used as the basis for the EU definitions of complete feed and complementary feed, the mandatory labeling items, and the point that codes of good labeling practice are voluntary.
- Standards and Specifications for Feeds (MAFRA Notice No. 2024-27) (사료 등의 기준 및 규격 (농림축산식품부고시 제2024-27호)) ↗
Used as the basis for the current ingredient registration items for companion-animal feed (Annex 13), name subdivision (Annex 3-3) and the labeling method for imported feed (Annex 15).
- Pet food, with nutrition information at a glance! (press release 2024.12.16) (반려동물 사료, 영양 정보까지 한눈에 딱! (보도자료 2024.12.16)) ↗
Used as the basis for the gist of the amendment: the introduction of nutritional standards for dog and cat food, the distinction between complete pet feed and other feed, and the nutrition standards of the National Institute of Animal Science.
- Considering an extra 1-year grace period on top of the 3-year grace period (DailyVet article) (3년 유예기간에 추가 1년 유예 검토 (데일리벳 기사)) ↗
Used as the basis for the effective date scheduled for September 2028 and the consideration of a further grace period, the official's answer that overseas food-related law is not recognized for the expression that a person can eat it, and the report of 38 to 43 kinds in the nutrition standards.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 3 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
