Translated from the Korean edition. This English edition is an editorial draft and has not been professionally reviewed.
Review status to know first
Every article has the status: Editorial draft; veterinary expert review not completed. Grochi does not mark content as reviewed by a veterinarian or an organisation, and each article carries its sources, check date, limits and scope of application.
In what order are articles written?
- Choose one question readers actually ask and narrow the scope so it does not overlap with other articles.
- Open and read at least four sources directly, including at least one domestic public or professional body, and record the date each was opened.
- Begin with a direct answer to the question, then write in this order: the evidence, Korean rules and labelling, how overseas standards differ, what the guardian should check, common misunderstandings, and when to go to a professional.
- Put the basis inside the sentence, as in "organisation X states that ...", and separate opinion from fact.
- Publish after automated checks on character count, number of sources, inclusion of a domestic source, and exaggerated or purchase-inducing wording.
- If a sample review by an outside eye after publication finds an error, correct it and record it in the corrections log.
| First sample | In 8 of 24 articles (33%), sentences were found that mixed in statements not in the original or different figures; all 186 articles were cross-checked again |
|---|---|
| Second sample (a different 24 articles, after the full repair) | Discrepancies found in 6 of 24 articles (25%); those articles were repaired and checking continues |
A sample cross-check is not an exhaustive inspection. Some sentences remain uncompared (original PDFs, the text of laws and the like).
How are sources chosen?
- Domestic: public and professional bodies come first, such as the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, the Animal Protection Management System, the Rural Development Administration, the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety, the Korea Consumer Agency, the National Law Information Center of the Ministry of Government Legislation, local governments and veterinary associations.
- Overseas: materials from professional associations and public bodies are used, such as WSAVA, AAFCO, FEDIAF, FDA, AVMA, AAHA, university veterinary schools and the Merck Veterinary Manual. Overseas standards are not presented as if they were Korean legal standards.
- As a rule only materials that were opened and read directly are listed as sources; if a sample cross-check finds a discrepancy it is corrected and recorded in the corrections log. Original texts are not copied or translated wholesale; only newly written Korean explanations of verified facts and links to the originals are provided.
- Materials that may involve an interest, such as a pet food company's laboratory or an industry body, are being revised so that their nature is stated within the article.
What do AI and people each do?
AI tools help with researching, drafting and checking articles. AI opens and reads the sources, writes drafts and runs the automated checks, and a separate AI review picks samples and compares sources with sentences. The human operator decides what to write, how much to publish and the principles, and accepts the results.
Sentences written by AI can also say things that are not in the sources. That is why sources are shown on every article, errors found in sample reviews are recorded in the corrections log, and the fact that no expert review has been received is not hidden. If you tell us about a mistake, we will check and correct it.
Where and by what criteria is product data collected?
Product labelling confirmed on the homepages of official domestic sellers and manufacturers is carried over (9 sources: ACANA official site (Asia-Pacific, Korean-language), Harim Petfood (하림펫푸드), Hill's (힐스), Natural Balance (내추럴발란스), Natural Core (네츄럴코어), ORIJEN official site (Asia-Pacific, Korean-language), Pulmuone Amio (풀무원아미오), Royal Canin (로얄캐닌), Wooriwa (우리와)). The product and sales items now listed number 1,590; of these, 976 have food information such as ingredients, guaranteed analysis and energy confirmed, and 0 have completed independent nutrition verification. This is not a list of every product sold in Korea.
- Included: items whose product name and address were confirmed from an official source. Sales items by size or bundle are also counted separately, so the total must not be read as the number of different foods.
- Excluded: items with errors, such as an empty product title, are not published and collection from that source is stopped. Sites that block access are not circumvented.
- How it is carried over: ingredient names and units, "at least" or "at most" conditions and whether the figure is on a dry-matter basis are kept as in the original. Missing calories are not calculated and filled in, and no scores or recommendations are made.
- Collection method: the site's robots rules and its actual sitemap and links are followed, with one request at a time and at least three seconds apart. No automatic continuous collection is set up.
- Traceability: for each item of food information the original address, check date and a hash of the original (SHA-256) are kept.
Data collection status shows how much was actually obtained for each seller. Last checked: 2026.11.18
What has not been done yet
- Review of articles by veterinary or nutrition experts
- Exhaustive cross-checking of every sourced sentence (currently sample cross-checks)
- Independent nutrition verification of product labelling