What exactly does "by-product" mean in pet food?
By-product is a name for secondary products that come out alongside the main product when it is made. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) describes by-products as "secondary products produced in addition to the principal product". Put simply, it is a name for material that was not the original goal but comes out along the way when a food or ingredient is processed. AAFCO's consumer guidance states that more than one product can come out of a single process and that any primary food can produce by-products.
This term does not carry the meaning of "low quality" or "unsafe". It is only a classification name that indicates the material is not the product originally being made (the main product). In the same guidance, AAFCO also states that the name does not mean by-products are unsafe or lack nutrition. However, this explanation concerns the meaning of the term, so it does not tell you whether any one specific product on the market is good or bad.
So concluding that something is good or bad from the single word "by-product" is a judgment made with too little information. What is actually under the same name can differ depending on which materials are included and how those materials were handled. This article first sets out the meaning of the name, and then looks in turn at how the name is used overseas and in Korea, and what owners can check.
Why can't the name alone separate good from bad?
In its consumer guidance, AAFCO states that by-products can be used safely to supply nutrition to many animals, based on their nutrient content and the safety of the processing. It also explains that in commercially made pet food, appropriate heat treatment to prevent microbial contamination is commonly carried out. This explanation is a general position on the "by-product category", and it does not mean that every manufacturer and product is managed to the same level.
The nutrition guidelines page of the World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) gives a warning in a similar direction. This page states that many owners regard the ingredient list as the most important factor in choosing a food, but that the ingredient list gives no information about the quality of the ingredients and can create misunderstandings about the quality of the food as a whole. That is, an ingredient name only tells you "what went in"; it does not tell you "how good its condition was" or "whether the finished food is nutritionally appropriate".
In summary, ingredient name and quality are on different levels. Even with a good-sounding name (for example, a meat name familiar to people), poor storage or processing can cause problems, and even with an unfamiliar name, the nutritional design and manufacturing management may be well done. The reverse is equally possible. A name is a clue, not a conclusion, so it has to be checked separately on two grounds: nutritional adequacy and manufacturing management.
One distinction is needed, though. According to AAFCO's guidance, the meat and by-products of animals that were not slaughtered but died for other reasons are not suitable for direct use as animal feed. It also states that raw by-products that have not been heat treated are restricted from use in finished feed. In other words, even within the "by-product" category, overseas standards also contain a boundary between what can be used and what is difficult to use.
How is "by-product" labeled and used in Korea?
According to the pet food labeling guidance of the National Institute of Animal Science (국립축산과학원), the names of the ingredients used must be shown on the feed container or packaging, and it directs readers to Annex 15 of the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) for the specific labeling standards. The National Institute of Animal Science page that was checked for this article had no separate explanation of the word "by-product". Therefore this article could not confirm how Korean law defines by-products, and does not state it definitively.
What can be confirmed from South Korean news reports is as follows. According to a Segye Ilbo report (entered 2026-10-30), meat meal (육분) is an ingredient made by heating and drying the meat and by-products of animals into a powder, and a plan was presented to label it with an easy name such as "meat by-product powder". For meat and bone meal (육골분), an ingredient that is meat meal with bone included, a "meat bone powder" label was introduced, and for fish oil (어유), a plan to label it "fish oil" in plain terms was introduced. The report conveys the easy names as something that can be "shown together" with the ingredient name, and gives the time when the feed classification system and labeling standards change as September 2028. Because this is a news report, it is safer for owners to check the actual notice wording and effective date again in the relevant ministry's notice.
The background to this tidying of names can also be partly confirmed in Korean sources. According to a Korea Consumer Agency survey introduced on the Seoul Metropolitan Government's "Seoul in My Hands" (내 손안에 서울) (2022-03-11), 57.9% of 2,000 consumers who had bought pet food within the past year did not understand ingredient names accurately. It was also pointed out that the same ingredient is written under different names depending on the product, such as chicken meal (계육분), chicken powder (닭고기 분말) and chicken flour (닭고기 가루). That is, there is a problem that ingredient names in general, not just "by-product", are unfamiliar to owners, and the word by-product is one conspicuous example among them. A full explanation of ingredient names is covered in another article, and this article focuses on the word by-product.
How do overseas standards differ from Korea's?
AAFCO's frequently asked questions guidance explains "meat by-products" as "the non-rendered, clean parts, other than meat, derived from slaughtered mammals". Put simply, it explains that this refers to most parts of an animal other than muscle tissue, such as internal organs or bones. The same guidance also states that rendered ingredients such as meat and bone meal belong to by-products in a broad sense.
AAFCO's consumer guidance page explains that animal by-products can include meat that does not meet the appearance standards for human food, and organs and parts not normally used as human food. It also says that by-products are often labeled without the word "by-product" in the name, and that a rendered ingredient has a different label name from the raw one. This part connects with the fact that meat meal (육분) or meat and bone meal (육골분) in Korea can be by-product-type ingredients even without the word "by-product".
There are points of caution here. First, AAFCO is not a body that approves or guarantees feed. The association states that it does not itself approve, certify or guarantee feed, and explains that most state feed laws use AAFCO's official publication by referring to it. Second, this definition is the American terminology system, so it cannot be assumed that the ingredient names and scope in the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) in Korea are the same. Which parts correspond to which ingredient name in Korea has to be checked directly in the Korean notice, and this article could not open and check the text of the notice.
Third, the WSAVA guidance page introduces, as a separate tool, a way to choose a food using other important information on the label rather than the ingredient list. In other words, overseas professional bodies also recommend an approach that understands the food as a whole rather than a single name.
What questions can owners ask the manufacturer?
When the name by-product is unfamiliar, asking specific questions helps more than arguing over whether the name is good or bad. The questions below are examples based on the grounds set out in this article, and they are not a standard for which answer counts as a pass. Use them to see whether the manufacturer answers specifically and whether it provides documents or evidence.
- Which part of which animal are the by-products in this food? Is the animal species stated?
- Is this ingredient raw, or has it been heat treated? What are the heating conditions and how is contamination managed?
- Where are the ingredients received from, and what inspections are done on receipt?
- At which life stage (growth, adult, senior and so on) does the manufacturer consider the finished food to provide complete nutrition, and what is the basis for that?
- Who designs the food formulation? Are nutrition specialists involved?
- How are hygiene and quality managed in the manufacturing process, and are records kept by batch number?
- If allergies or digestive problems are a concern, can ingredient-by-ingredient composition information be provided?
- Where are the storage method, sell-by date and guidance on handling after opening?
| Item to check | Why check it | Where to check it |
|---|---|---|
| Ingredient type and part | Different materials can be included even under the same name by-product | Ingredient names on the package, asking the manufacturer |
| Whether it is heat treated | Overseas guidance says use of raw by-products in finished feed is restricted | Asking the manufacturer |
| Nutritional adequacy | What matters is whether the nutrition of the finished food, not the ingredient name, suits the pet | Package labeling, consulting a veterinarian |
| Manufacturing and quality management | The condition cannot be known from the ingredient name alone | Asking the manufacturer, public materials |
| How the ingredient name is written | The same ingredient can be written under different names on different products | Package label, Korean notice |
What are common misconceptions about "by-product"?
The first misconception is the idea that by-products mean waste or material that would be thrown away. By-product is a name that indicates a position of not being the main product, so the word does not mean waste. However, according to AAFCO guidance, by-products can also include meat and organs that do not meet the appearance standards for human food, and for this reason the impression can differ depending on the owner. AAFCO explains, in effect, that it does not regulate consumers' opinions about appearance, and that its goal is to provide definitions so that people can read the label and judge for themselves.
The second misconception is the opposite: that food is safe if it contains no by-products. A familiar ingredient name gives no assurance that storage, processing and nutritional design were done well. As the WSAVA guidance says, the ingredient list does not tell you the quality of the ingredients, so whether even a food with familiar names provides complete nutrition has to be looked at separately.
The third misconception is that if the word "by-product" is not written, it is not a by-product. AAFCO's consumer guidance explains that most by-products do not use the word "by-product" in their names. In Korea too, according to the Segye Ilbo report, meat meal (육분) is an ingredient made by heating and drying the meat and by-products of animals, yet the current name does not contain the word "by-product". So searching the label for a single word is not enough.
The fourth misconception is that the problem is solved if the name is changed to an easy one. An easy name helps understanding, but it does not carry information about the condition of the ingredient or the process. Even if the name becomes easier to read, the questions set out above are still needed.
When is it a good idea to consult a veterinarian?
If concerns about an ingredient name are connected to a pet's health problem, it is a good idea to consult a veterinarian. If vomiting or diarrhea continues after a change of food, the pet keeps scratching its skin, appetite drops noticeably, or body weight changes markedly, get an examination at an animal hospital before arguing over ingredient names. Whether the cause of these symptoms is the food or another illness is hard for an owner to sort out from names alone.
It is also safer to consult a veterinarian first if a food allergy is suspected, if the pet is eating a therapeutic diet for chronic digestive disease, kidney disease, heart disease and the like, or during periods when nutritional needs change, such as pregnancy and nursing, or in young and senior animals. This article is general information explaining the meaning of an ingredient name, and it is not an article that tells you to feed or avoid any particular food for a specific pet.
If you asked the manufacturer and the answer is vague, or different explanations are given for the same question, you can bring that content to a veterinarian and ask them to help interpret it together. When changing foods, it is usual to proceed slowly in the way a veterinarian advises rather than changing everything suddenly. If a pet suddenly shows urgent symptoms such as a sudden loss of energy or repeated vomiting, contact the nearest veterinary clinic right away, before checking ingredients.
Frequently asked questions
Q Should I avoid food that contains by-products?
It is hard to decide that it should be avoided on the name alone. AAFCO has stated its position that by-products can be used safely based on their nutrient content and the safety of processing, and the WSAVA guidance page explains that the ingredient list does not tell you the quality of ingredients. Look together at which part it is, how it is managed, and whether the food as a whole is nutritionally appropriate.
Q Are by-products and meat meal the same thing?
They are not the same. By-product is a broad name for secondary products that come out alongside the main product, and according to the report, meat meal (육분) is an ingredient made by heating and drying the meat and by-products of animals into a powder. You can understand meat meal as one ingredient name that can use by-products as material. The exact scope under the Korean notice has to be checked in the text of the notice.
Q If the label does not say "by-product", does that mean there are none?
That cannot be stated definitively. AAFCO's consumer guidance explains that most by-products do not use the word by-product in their names. If you are curious about an ingredient name itself, asking the manufacturer directly which material and part it is will be accurate.
Q How is the safety of by-product ingredients managed?
AAFCO explains that in commercially made pet food, heat treatment to prevent microbial contamination is commonly carried out, and advises that raw by-products are restricted from use in finished feed. However, the level of management by individual manufacturers can differ from product to product, so details such as heating conditions and receiving inspections have to be asked of the manufacturer.
Q Is the label "meat by-product powder" already used in Korea?
What this article checked was the 2026-10-30 Segye Ilbo report, which describes a plan to allow meat meal (육분) to be shown together with an easy name such as "meat by-product powder" and an effective date expected in September 2028. This article could not confirm the actual notice wording and effective date from the original text, so look directly at the relevant ministry's notice.
Q Do by-products cause allergies?
The materials checked for this article contain nothing saying that the by-product category causes allergies. Because the proteins a pet reacts to differ from animal to animal, if there are suspected symptoms, consult a veterinarian rather than guessing from ingredient names.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article is general information explaining the meaning of the name by-product, and it is not an evaluation of any specific product or guidance on choosing a food or on diagnosis. The text and annexes of the Korean Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) could not be opened and checked, and the Korean labeling plan relies on news reports and guidance from national institutions. The AAFCO definitions are US standards and cannot be regarded as the same as Korean law. For an individual pet's dietary problems, consult a veterinarian.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- Byproducts (Understanding Pet Food) ↗
Used as the basis for the definition of by-products, the parts that can be included, the restriction on raw by-products, and the explanation that the name does not mean by-products are unsafe or lack nutrition.
- Frequently Asked Questions ↗
Used as the basis for the definition of meat by-products, the point that meat and bone meal belongs to by-products in a broad sense, and the point that AAFCO does not approve or guarantee feed.
- Nutrition Guidelines (Global Nutrition Guidelines) ↗
Used as the basis for the guidance that the ingredient list does not tell you the quality of ingredients and can create misunderstandings about the quality of the food as a whole.
- Pet food labeling guidance (반려동물 사료 표시 안내) ↗
Used as the basis for the guidance that the names of ingredients used must be shown on Korean feed containers and packaging, and that detailed standards should be checked in Annex 15 of the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격).
- Chicken meal, fish oil? What do pet food ingredient names mean? (계육분, 어유? 반려동물 사료 원료 명칭 "뭔 말이지?") ↗
Used as the basis for the point that in a Korea Consumer Agency survey 57.9% of 2,000 consumers did not understand ingredient names accurately, and that the same ingredient is written under different names on different products.
- Tidying up confusing feed labels such as "meat and bone meal" and "human-edible" (‘육골분’·‘사람이 먹을 수 있는’… 헷갈리는 사료 표기 정비) ↗
Used as the basis for the reported plan to allow meat meal (육분) to be shown together with an easy name such as "meat by-product powder", and the reported effective date of September 2028.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 1 Korean law or notice. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
