Skip to content
Grochi · Neutral pet information from South Korea · English edition한국어
Grochi.English edition
Food & nutrition

How do you match the units of calorie numbers on pet food before comparing them?

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. This page is an English translation of the Korean edition as checked on 2026-11-19. If the two differ, the Korean edition is the reference. 한국어판 (Korean edition)

How do you match the units of calorie numbers on pet food before comparing them?
Short answer

Convert calories to the same basis (per kg, per 100 g, per cup or can) first, then compare. Numbers on different bases are easy to misread if you set them side by side as they are.

Key takeaways

  • Calorie numbers on pet food come on different bases such as per kg, per 100 g, per cup and per can, so they cannot be compared with each other until they are converted to the same basis.
  • The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) guides that calories be written as kilocalories per kilogram of food (as-fed basis) together with familiar units such as can, cup and biscuit, and explains that canned food has more moisture, so its calories per kg are often lower than dry food.
  • Metabolizable energy (ME) means the energy the body can use: the gross energy of the food eaten minus the energy lost in feces and urine.
  • Kilojoules (kJ) and kilocalories (kcal) convert to each other with one multiplication, and 1 kcal is about 4.184 kJ.
  • This time it could not be determined from the Korean sources checked whether calorie labeling is mandatory on Korean packaging, so if a product has no number, it is safer to ask the manufacturer directly, together with the basis.

What should you match first to compare calorie numbers?

Calorie numbers on pet food use a different reference amount from product to product, such as per kilogram, per 100 grams, per cup and per can, so before comparing you have to convert them all to the same reference amount. Some products write calories as kilocalories per kilogram, some per 100 grams, and some per cup or per can. Looking only at the numbers, 3,600, 360 and 85 appear to be entirely different sizes, but on different bases they can be the same food.

The order is simple. First, check what the unit next to the number is per. Second, choose one basis and convert all the numbers to it. Third, multiply the converted number by the amount you actually give (number of grams, cups or cans) and look at how much is eaten at one time. These three steps are all that "matching units" means in this article.

This article focuses only on how to convert units. How many kilocalories your pet needs per day, and therefore how many grams to give, is a separate matter that varies with body weight, age, activity and health condition, and it is something to decide in consultation with a veterinarian. This article does not cover that calculation, and only explains how to read the numbers on the package with the same ruler.

One more point to remember. You cannot say that a lower calorie number makes a better diet, or that a higher one makes a bad diet. Calories are information that only has meaning when converted to the same basis and read, and they are not the whole of the criteria for choosing a food. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) also guides against choosing a food on calorie content alone.

What do kcal, metabolizable energy (ME) and kJ each mean?

The kilocalorie (kcal) is the same size as the "calorie" we see on human food labels. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) explains that the kilocalorie means the same as the commonly said calorie, that is, the "large calorie" or "food calorie", and is the same as the meaning used on human food labels. It adds, however, that scientifically the kilocalorie is the more accurate term.

Metabolizable energy (ME) is the gross energy contained in the food eaten minus the energy lost in feces and urine. A study of the energy in pet food (a paper published in PLOS ONE) describes metabolizable energy as "the energy available to the animal for metabolism" and summarizes it as gross energy minus the energy lost in feces and urine. So even for the same food, the energy the body can use can differ depending on how well it is digested.

The paper explains that this metabolizable energy can be obtained most accurately by feeding the food and measuring, but that it is costly, so formulas that calculate it from nutrient content are widely used. Results can differ depending on the type of formula, so even for the same food the value written by the manufacturer and a value obtained by another method can differ slightly. The paper reported that the modified Atwater calculation underestimated by about 5% for average dry food and about 11% for average wet food. This is a result based on the data of one laboratory, so it cannot be applied as it is to every product.

The kilojoule (kJ) is the international unit of energy. The paper wrote the metabolizable energy of dry dog food side by side in two units, as "3897 kcal/kg (16305 kJ/kg)", and the ratio of the two numbers is about 4.184 kilojoules to 1 kilocalorie. Therefore, multiplying a kcal number by 4.184 gives kJ, and dividing a kJ number by 4.184 gives kcal. If the package gives only kJ, you can convert it to kcal with this calculation and compare.

Why does the calorie content of 1 cup differ between products, even for the same food?

A cup is volume, not weight. Even in the same cup, the weight that fits differs depending on the size, shape and density of the kibble and the air gaps between pieces. So the calories in 1 cup = the weight of 1 cup × calories per gram, a product of two numbers, and both numbers differ from product to product.

For example, a product with small, tightly packed kibble fits more in a cup, and a product with large, hollow kibble fits less in the same volume. This means that even if the calorie density (calories per gram) is the same, the calories per cup can differ between them. Conversely, even if the calories per cup are written the same, the combination of the weight of one cup and the calories per gram can be different.

The cup itself is also a variable. The measuring cup that comes with a product, a cup at home and a measuring spoon can have different capacities, and the weight also changes depending on whether the cup is heaped or leveled off. Even for the same 1 cup, the calories can differ depending on who fills it. For this reason, treat calories written per cup as a rough reference, and if you want an exact comparison, it is better to weigh the grams on a kitchen scale and calculate with calories per gram.

Cans, pouches and pieces (a biscuit, 1 treat) follow the same principle. The content of 1 can differs from product to product, so calories per can vary with the weight of the can, and calories per treat vary with the weight per piece. A number written per piece can be matched with another product only when you know the weight of that piece.

What happens if you convert hypothetical numbers to the same unit?

The numbers below are invented hypothetical values to show the calculation method, and they are not the values of any real product. Assume dry food A has 3,600 kcal per kilogram and 100 grams fit in 1 cup. Assume wet food B has 1,000 kcal per kilogram and the content of 1 can is 85 grams.

First, convert to per gram. Dividing the per-kilogram value by 1,000 gives the per-gram value. Food A is 3.6 kcal/g and food B is 1.0 kcal/g. To see it per 100 grams, divide the per-kilogram value by 10, giving 360 kcal for A and 100 kcal for B.

Next, convert to the package unit. 1 cup of A is 100 grams, so it is 360 kcal. If the same food were in a cup that holds only 80 grams, it would be 288 kcal. 1 can of B is 85 grams, so it is 1,000 × 0.085 = 85 kcal. Looking only at the numbers, 360 and 85 appear very different, but that is because the weights of the cup and can differ and the moisture content differs.

Now convert to kJ. A is 3,600 × 4.184 = 15,062 kJ/kg (rounded), and B is 1,000 × 4.184 = 4,184 kJ/kg. Conversely, if a package says 15,062 kJ/kg, dividing by 4.184 shows it is about 3,600 kcal/kg.

Finally, if you compare dry A and wet B only per kilogram, B looks much lower. This is because B has more moisture. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) also guides that canned food has more moisture, so its as-fed calories per kg are often lower than dry food, and to compare with care. A low per-kg calorie number only means fewer calories when the same amount is eaten, not that the nutrition is better or worse. When you mix two products or switch between them, it is meaningful only to multiply the grams eaten at one time by the calories per gram and add them up.

An example of hypothetical numbers (not real products) converted to the same basis
BasisDry A (hypothetical)Wet B (hypothetical)How to convert
kcal per 1 kg3,6001,000Value written on the package
kcal per 1 g3.61.0Per-kg value ÷ 1,000
kcal per 100 g360100Per-kg value ÷ 10
kcal per 1 package unit1 cup of 100 g = 3601 can of 85 g = 85Per-g value × weight of 1 unit (g)
kJ per 1 kgabout 15,0624,184kcal value × 4.184

How are calories shown on Korean packaging?

In the Korean sources opened directly this time, it could not be confirmed whether calorie labeling on pet food packaging is mandatory. So this article does not state that it is, or that it is not. What was confirmed is as follows.

According to the pet food labeling guidance page of the National Institute of Animal Science (국립축산과학원), under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) feed is required to show feed-related information on the container or packaging, such as the registered components and precautions for use. The labeling items listed on this page included the guaranteed analysis (registered), the names of the ingredients used and the actual weight, and no energy or calorie item was visible. However, this page only directs readers to the annexes of the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) for details and does not reproduce the content of those annexes, so whether calories are included in the annexes could not be confirmed this time. The text of the statutory provisions was not opened in this work.

The Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) announced a direction under which a product that meets the nutrient requirements by growth stage for dogs and cats may be labeled as "complete pet feed" (반려동물완전사료), and one that does not is classified as "other pet feed" (반려동물기타사료), and advised that the National Institute of Animal Science prepares the nutrition standard that serves as the criterion. This nutrition standard is related to calories, and a Dailyvet report (2024) said that the recommended nutrient contents for dog and cat complete feed are shown as "unit per 100 g dry matter" and "unit per 1,000 kcal metabolizable energy", and that the table of contents has an item on calculating metabolizable energy. That is, it means that per 1,000 kcal of metabolizable energy is used as the unit for explaining the nutrition standard, not that a product package must state it in any particular unit.

In conclusion, if calories are visible on the package, first read which basis it is (per kg, per 100 g, per cup or can), and if they are not visible, the practical method is to ask the manufacturer how many kcal/kg the metabolizable energy is and by what method the value was obtained.

How should you read this differently from overseas standards?

Among overseas materials, what was checked directly this time is the guidance of the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO). AAFCO shows calories as "kilocalories per kilogram of food on an as-fed basis" and guides that calories per familiar unit such as can, cup and biscuit also be written. It says the placement should be under the heading "Calorie Content". It also explains that a company that writes a calorie statement must state whether it did its own calculation or used AAFCO's testing procedure.

This approach is also a useful reference when reading Korean packaging. As-fed basis means the weight of the food with its moisture as it is, which connects to the guidance to take care not to compare dry and wet food, whose moisture differs, as they are. Conversely, the "100 g dry matter" basis reported in the Korean nutrition standard is a value for the weight with moisture removed, so even the same number means something different. Mixing as-fed and dry matter bases in a comparison easily leads to a wrong conclusion.

AAFCO's consumer guidance also explains that labels such as "light" have calorie standards, and gives as an example that dry dog food cannot exceed 3,100 kilocalories per kilogram. This standard varies with the type of food and dog or cat, and because it is a US system it does not apply as it is to Korean products.

In summary, the overseas method can be used as a reference as an example of requiring clear writing of "what basis the number is on", but it is safer not to carry it over as a labeling obligation or standard for Korean products. Labeling obligations and calculation methods can differ from country to country, and this time the labeling obligations outside the United States were not opened and checked.

What should owners check on the package?

Checking the following items in order lets you read the numbers with the same ruler.

  • What the basis next to the number is per (per kg, per 100 g, per cup, per can, per piece)
  • Whether the unit is kcal or kJ (if kJ, divide by 4.184 to convert to kcal)
  • Whether the number is metabolizable energy or a value written by some other method
  • Whether it is as-fed basis (with moisture) or dry matter basis (without moisture)
  • If it is a cup, how many grams one cup is and which cup is used
  • Whether the calories were obtained by testing or by a formula (when stated)
  • When there is no number, whether you asked the manufacturer, and whether the answer gives the basis as well

If you feed by the cup at home, it helps to weigh 1 cup on a scale at least once. If you record the grams when it is leveled off in the same cup, you can multiply by the calories per gram and know the calories of one cup directly. When the product changes, the weight differs even for the same cup, so weigh it again.

If you feed several products together, multiply the grams of each product by its calories per gram and add them up, and add treats and toppings in the same way. This turns numbers that were in all different units into a one-line total. How to interpret this total and how to adjust the amount fed is outside the scope of this article, and is a matter to discuss with a veterinarian.

What are common misconceptions about calorie units?

First is the misconception that "a food with a small number is a low-calorie food". A product with a small per-kg number can be a wet food with a lot of moisture, and then if the grams eaten at one time increase, the calories eaten can end up similar. Comparing only the size of the numbers without matching the basis is the most common mistake.

Second is the misconception that "1 cup always has the same calories". As explained above, the weight of 1 cup varies with the kibble and how it is filled, and the calories per cup also differ from product to product.

Third is the misconception that "kJ and kcal are different kinds of calories". They are the same energy written in different units, and they convert with the ratio of 1 kcal being about 4.184 kJ.

Fourth is the idea that "metabolizable energy is always written on the package". That cannot be said from the Korean sources checked this time. If it is not written, it can be approximated with a formula, but as the earlier paper showed, values can differ depending on the formula, and the same paper wrote that underestimating metabolizable energy is a concern because it can lead to overfeeding. So use an approximate value only as a reference and look at it together with the manufacturer's value.

Fifth is the misconception that "lower calories make a better diet". Calories are just one number, and the calories and nutrition needed differ with the pet's condition. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) also guides against choosing a food on calorie content alone.

In what cases should you consult a veterinarian?

Matching units is only a way of reading numbers, and it does not tell you the calories your pet needs. In the following cases, do not rely on calculation alone, and consult a veterinarian.

  • When body weight has recently increased or decreased noticeably
  • When appetite has suddenly changed, or weight does not rise even when the amount eaten is increased
  • During periods when the calories needed change, such as a young animal, a pregnant or nursing animal, or a senior animal
  • When the pet has a chronic illness or allergy and is eating a prescription or therapeutic diet
  • When you are changing food or feeding a mix of several products and are unsure how to set the total calories

The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) also guides that a veterinarian can help determine an individual animal's calorie requirement. When you consult, it speeds up the conversation to bring the name of the product you are feeding, the number of grams or cups given at one time (a value measured on a scale if possible), the number of times per day, and the type and amount of treats. If, as practiced in this article, you convert all the numbers to calories per gram, you can talk on the same basis when the veterinarian discusses the amount to feed.

If you asked the manufacturer and the basis is unclear or there is no answer, please tell the veterinarian that as well. The fact that the source of a calorie number is unclear is also important information when deciding the amount to feed.

Frequently asked questions

Q How do I convert a number written in kJ to kcal?

Dividing the kJ number by 4.184 gives kcal. Conversely, multiplying kcal by 4.184 gives kJ. You can also confirm this ratio from the values in the PLOS ONE paper, which wrote the metabolizable energy of dry dog food side by side in two units, as 3897 kcal/kg (16305 kJ/kg).

Q What is metabolizable energy (ME), and is it different from ordinary calories?

The PLOS ONE paper explains that metabolizable energy means the energy the body can use: the gross energy of the food eaten minus the energy lost in feces and urine. By what method the number called calories on a package was obtained can differ from product to product, so it needs to be checked.

Q If the calories per cup are written, can I compare with that?

The weight of 1 cup differs from product to product, so it is hard to compare as it is. If you know the weight of one cup you can convert it to calories per gram, and weighing it yourself on a scale is the most accurate.

Q Can I compare wet and dry food by calories per kg?

Comparing them as they are is easy to misunderstand. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) guides that canned food has more moisture, so its as-fed calories per kg are often lower than dry food, and to be careful. Compare using the grams eaten at one time multiplied by the calories per gram.

Q Is calorie labeling mandatory on Korean pet food packaging?

In the Korean sources opened this time (including the labeling guidance page of the National Institute of Animal Science), it could not be confirmed whether it is mandatory. No calorie item was visible in the list of labeling items on that page, but the content of the detailed annexes could not be confirmed, so the latest text of the law and notices needs to be checked.

Q What should I do if there are no calories on the package?

Ask the manufacturer how many kcal/kg the metabolizable energy is, and whether it was obtained by testing or by a formula. You can also approximate it with a formula from the nutrient content, but the value can differ depending on the formula, so it is safer to treat it as a reference only.

Limits and scope of this guide

This article covers only how to match units and does not calculate daily calorie needs or the amount to feed. Whether calorie labeling is mandatory on Korean pet food packaging could not be confirmed because the text of the statute (the annexes of the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격)) could not be opened, so it is not stated definitively, and labeling systems outside the United States could not be confirmed either. All example numbers are hypothetical. If a pet has an illness, or is a young animal, or is pregnant, nursing or senior, consult a veterinarian.

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.

Sources and check dates

  1. Calories ↗

    Used as the basis for the guidance to write calories as as-fed kcal per kg and in familiar units such as cup and can, for kcal and calorie meaning the same thing, and for the caution to compare with care because of the moisture in canned food.

  2. Reading Labels ↗

    Used as the basis for the placement of the calorie statement (Calorie Content) and the example of the 3,100 kcal/kg limit for dry dog food labeled light.

  3. Metabolisable energy content in canine and feline foods is best predicted by the NRC2006 equation ↗

    Used as the basis for the meaning of metabolizable energy, the differences in estimated values depending on the formula, and the values written side by side in kcal/kg and kJ/kg (a ratio of about 4.184).

  4. Pet food labeling guidance (반려동물 사료 표시 안내) ↗

    Used as the basis for the scope of the container and packaging labeling items under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) (guaranteed analysis, ingredient names, weight and so on), and for the point that this page alone cannot determine whether calorie labeling is mandatory.

  5. Press release on distinguishing complete and other pet feed (반려동물 완전사료·기타사료 구분 보도자료) ↗

    Used as the basis for the distinction between complete feed and other feed, and for the point that the National Institute of Animal Science prepares the nutrition standard.

  6. Pet food nutrition standard prepared: complete feed must meet the standard (반려동물 사료 영양표준 마련… 기준 충족해야 완전사료) ↗

    Used as the basis for the reported content that the recommended contents of the Korean nutrition standard are shown as unit per 100 g dry matter and unit per 1,000 kcal metabolizable energy.

Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.

This guide relies on 2 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.