Skip to content
Grochi · Neutral pet information from South Korea · English edition한국어
Grochi.English edition
Food & nutrition

What should you base your choice of dog food on? (The order of checks, in full)

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. This page is an English translation of the Korean edition as checked on 2026-11-19. If the two differ, the Korean edition is the reference. 한국어판 (Korean edition)

What should you base your choice of dog food on? (The order of checks, in full)
Short answer

Rather than advertising claims, check dog food in this order: the nutritional adequacy statement for the life stage, the manufacturer's answers on nutrition experts and quality control, Korean labeling, and your own dog's body condition.

Key takeaways

  • When choosing dog food, the starting point is to check, before ingredient promotion claims, whether the package has a nutritional adequacy statement matching your dog's life stage (growth, adult, all life stages).
  • The World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) advises asking the manufacturer whether it employs a nutrition expert, who formulates the diets, how quality control is done and whether research is done, and being cautious if there is no answer.
  • Dog food packages in Korea must show the ingredient registration number, the name and form of the feed, the registered ingredient amounts, the names of the raw materials, the manufacture (import) date and the manufacturer's contact details, and it is reasonable to be suspicious if these items are missing or there is no Korean-language labeling.
  • The guaranteed analysis gives minimum and maximum limits, not actual measured values, and foods with different moisture can be compared only after converting to a dry matter basis, with the moisture removed.
  • Even the same food suits dogs to different degrees depending on body weight, body shape, age and disease, so when first choosing or changing it, consult a veterinarian and adjust while watching the dog's body condition.

The conclusion first: in what order should you check?

The criterion for choosing dog food lies not in a single number or a single ingredient but in the order of checks. The order this article recommends has five steps.

  • Step 1: Check from the nutritional adequacy statement on the package whether the food suits your dog's life stage (growth, adult, pregnancy and lactation, senior).
  • Step 2: Distinguish whether that statement says it is a complete and balanced diet, and whether it is a treat or supplement.
  • Step 3: Ask whether the manufacturer has a nutrition expert, who formulates the diets, and how quality control is done.
  • Step 4: See whether the labeling items required under Korean law (ingredient registration number, registered ingredient amounts, raw material names, manufacture (import) date, company contact details) are all present.
  • Step 5: After reading the guaranteed analysis, look at whether the food suits your dog's body weight, body shape, activity level and health.

This order is used because the earlier the step, the more directly it relates to whether the food contains all the nutrients the dog needs, and the later the step, the more the individual dog's circumstances matter. The photos and promotional phrases on the front of the package are the information to consult last in this order.

This article does not recommend or compare specific products, and only summarizes what information to check and where. Topics that need deeper treatment, such as protein content, food transition, allergy and feeding amount, are covered in separate articles, so they are mentioned here in only one line each.

Why are the ingredient list and advertising claims not enough?

The reason it is hard to choose food from the ingredient list and advertising claims alone is that this information does not tell you whether the nutrition is adequate. WSAVA's guidance on selecting pet foods explains that a package contains necessary and useful information, but also images and phrases meant to promote sales. This guidance says that unregulated terms such as holistic or premium have little real value in assessing nutrition.

The label explanation in the MSD Veterinary Manual also points out the limits of the ingredient list. Ingredients are listed in order of the weight in which they went into the food, and this weight is on a basis that includes moisture, so an ingredient with a lot of moisture, such as fresh meat, may contribute less actual nutrition than a dry ingredient even if it comes first. It also says that when the same grain is split and listed in several forms, one ingredient can become less conspicuous. And because ingredient grade or quality cannot be written on the label, and what animals need is nutrients rather than ingredients, it explains that the ingredient list is a limited tool.

That does not mean the ingredient list is useless. The MSD Manual advises that the ingredient list can be useful for checking ingredients that may cause problems when a food allergy or intolerance is suspected. Allergy and elimination diets are covered in detail in a separate article; here it is enough to remember that the ingredient list is not information that guarantees the overall quality of a food.

Steps 1–2: How do you read the life stage and the nutritional adequacy statement?

The nutritional adequacy statement is the sentence that tells you for which life stage of dog the food was made to be a complete meal. The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) advises that if the nutritional adequacy statement contains the phrase complete and balanced, it means the food is intended to be the pet's sole diet. It explains that treats, snacks and supplements usually do not have this phrase, so they are not made to be used as a main food.

The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) states on its website that it does not regulate, test, approve or certify pet foods, that it is an organization that creates model regulations that states and other jurisdictions can adopt into law, and that the FDA enforces pet food laws. So the AAFCO phrase should be read knowing that it is content the manufacturer labels itself, not a certification mark.

According to the FDA and the MSD Manual, nutritional standards for dog food are broadly divided into growth and reproduction, and adult maintenance. The FDA explains that some nutrients are lower in adult formulas, and growth and reproduction is the standard for growing puppies and for pregnant and lactating dogs. So check whether the food for an adult dog is labeled for the adult maintenance stage, and whether the food for a puppy meets the growth stage. WSAVA explains that foods labeled for all life stages are formulated to meet the standards for reproduction and growth.

The MSD Manual summarizes AAFCO nutritional adequacy statements as four types.

  • A statement that it was formulated to meet a nutrient profile
  • A statement that it passed a feeding trial under AAFCO procedures
  • A statement that it is similar to a product family that went through feeding trials
  • A statement that it is for intermittent or supplemental feeding only

According to the MSD Manual, the last type is used for products that do not meet the requirements for a complete diet and are suitable only for intermittent or supplemental feeding. Because this type is not a complete diet, it is not for use as the sole food. WSAVA advises that foods labeled for short-term, intermittent or supplemental feeding should be given only in small amounts of 10 percent or less of the diet, or only under veterinary supervision.

Large-breed puppies sometimes need a separate growth standard. According to the MSD Manual, a statement of whether the food meets growth requirements for puppies expected to weigh 32 kilograms (70 pounds) or more as adults is sometimes given. The differences between growth-stage food and adult food, and nutrition for large-breed puppies, are each covered in detail in separate articles.

Step 3: What should you ask the manufacturer?

What to ask the manufacturer is set out in the guidance on selecting pet foods created by the WSAVA Global Nutrition Committee (updated March 10, 2021). This guidance is divided into four questions to check about the brand and four questions to check on the label. First, the questions about the brand.

  • Does it employ a nutrition expert: As suitable qualifications, the guidance names a PhD in animal nutrition or board certification from the American College of Veterinary Nutrition (ACVN) or the European College of Veterinary and Comparative Nutrition (ECVCN). It also says to ask for the name, qualifications and form of employment, and says that an outside consultant may have more limited influence than a full-time expert.
  • Who formulates the diets: Ask whether it is an experienced pet food formulator, a veterinarian, or an owner or breeder. The guidance explains that formulation development is a complex process that requires knowledge of nutrition, ingredients and processing.
  • How is quality control of ingredients and finished products done: When it is said to meet a nutrient profile, ask whether this was calculated from a nutrient database or whether the finished product was chemically analyzed. The guidance says there should be ingredient verification, nutritional analysis of the finished product, toxin and bacterial testing, and checks of packaging and expiry date.
  • What product research or nutrition research has it done, and has it been published in journals: The guidance explains that research is not mandatory, but if it is being done, it shows commitment to animal health.

WSAVA advises that if a manufacturer cannot or will not provide such information, you should be cautious about feeding that brand. These questions are not a list that approves specific brands but a tool to help owners and veterinarians compare the answers and make a judgment.

To make an inquiry, use the customer service contact or website on the food package. The guidance explains that manufacturers should make contact details such as a phone number or email easy to find, and should be able to provide average values for nutrients not on the label. It also lists whether the food was made by the company itself (Made by) or produced under contract (Made for, Distributed by) as an item to check. The answer is the manufacturer's own explanation and may carry a promotional element, so it is good to look at whether the answer is specific and whether it provides supporting material.

Step 4: What do you check on Korean food packages?

In Korea, pet food is subject to the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법). The Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) explains that under the Act, feed including pet food is divided into single ingredient feed, complementary feed and compound feed, and that when feed is made with raw materials specified in the law, its ingredients must be registered with the competent local government. The National Law Information Center (law.go.kr) of the Ministry of Government Legislation lists this Act as Act No. 19752 (partially amended October 24, 2023, in force April 25, 2024).

The items that must be shown on the package can be found in the National Agricultural Products Quality Management Service's 2024 inspection announcement. According to this announcement, the main display panel includes the ingredient registration number, the name and form of the feed, the registered ingredient amounts and the names of the raw materials used, and the other display panels include precautions and the name, address and phone number of the manufacturer (importer). In that year's inspection, 3,103 pieces of distributed feed were collected and examined, and 4 violations of mandatory labeling on the packaging were found, with cases of an omitted manufacture (import) date, misstated feed name and registered ingredient amounts, omitted company name, address and phone number, missing precautions, and missing Korean-language labeling. The National Agricultural Products Quality Management Service urged consumers also to check labeling items such as the manufacture date and sell-by date carefully.

Based on this, the items to look at on the package are as follows.

  • Ingredient registration number: a mark showing whether registration of the ingredients under the law was done.
  • The name and form of the feed, and the names of the raw materials used
  • Registered ingredient amounts: the amounts registered, not actual measured values.
  • Manufacture (import) date (the sell-by date is a labeling item that the National Agricultural Products Quality Management Service urged consumers to check)
  • The manufacturer's (importer's) name, address and phone number, and precautions

There is a point of caution. This article could not directly open and check the original text of the labeling annex of the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격), so the full list of items and detailed rules must be checked in the latest original text from the National Agricultural Products Quality Management Service or the Ministry of Government Legislation. Also, it could not confirm from this article's sources whether an AAFCO-style nutritional adequacy phrase is mandatory in current Korean labeling.

Planned changes to the system are also worth knowing. MAFRA stated that, based on the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) revised in September 2025, it plans to manage pet food from September 2028 by types such as pet complete feed and pet other feed. According to industry press reports, only products that meet the Pet Food Nutrition Standards (Dogs and Cats) of the National Institute of Animal Science will be able to be labeled as pet complete feed. Until implementation, current labeling and the questions to ask the manufacturer are more important.

How do overseas standards differ?

Overseas standards and Korean labeling differ in how they give information. In the United States, a nutritional adequacy statement goes on the label under AAFCO model regulations, with the life stage written alongside it, and this statement is used within the regulatory framework of the FDA and state authorities. In Europe, the European Pet Food Industry Federation (FEDIAF) provides recommended nutrient levels by life stage in its nutritional guidelines, and the WSAVA guidance also refers to AAFCO and FEDIAF together as the benchmarks for the recommended nutrient levels required of manufacturers.

In Korea, by contrast, the mandatory labeling that can currently be confirmed centers on items under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법), such as the ingredient registration number and registered ingredient amounts, and when the pet complete feed category planned to take effect in September 2028 is introduced, whether the nutrition standard is met is expected to be reflected in labeling. So whether you buy imported food or food made in Korea, what owners need to do is the same. Ask the manufacturer which nutritional standard it says it meets and by what method (formulation or feeding trial), and check that Korean-language labeling and contact details are present.

Calorie labeling also differs. The WSAVA guidance says the United States is the only place where calorie information is mandatory on the label, and advises that if it is not given, you should ask the manufacturer or calculate from the label's nutrient analysis values. Feeding amounts and calorie calculation are covered in detail in a separate article; here it is enough to note that calories may not be on the package.

How do you read the guaranteed analysis?

The guaranteed analysis is the item that gives the minimum or maximum limits of the nutrients in the food, and it is not a measured value as such. According to the MSD Manual, the guaranteed analysis table gives crude protein and crude fat as minimum values and moisture and crude fiber as maximum values, on an as-fed basis that includes moisture. Actual content is often higher than the guaranteed minimum, so it explains that if you can get the manufacturer's average analysis values, those are more useful.

When comparing foods with different moisture, convert to a dry matter basis. The calculation is to subtract the moisture percentage from 100 to get the dry matter proportion, divide the nutrient percentage by that dry matter proportion, and multiply by 100. In the MSD Manual's example, a dry food with a minimum of 24 percent protein and a maximum of 12 percent moisture is about 27 percent on a dry matter basis, and a canned food with a minimum of 8 percent protein and a maximum of 82 percent moisture is about 44 percent. Judging by the numbers alone the canned food looks much lower, but on a dry matter basis it is the reverse. Judgments about whether this number is high or low, and protein standards, are covered in a separate article.

Food packages in Korea show the registered ingredient amounts. This article could not confirm the detailed items and the meaning of the figures for registered ingredient amounts from the original text of the notice, so it does not assert that they can be read in the same way as the guaranteed analysis. When comparing, first check whether the same items are present and whether the moisture basis is the same.

Step 5: How do you tell whether it suits your dog?

Even food that passes nutritional standards and labeling does not suit every dog equally. The nutritional standards the WSAVA guidance refers to are recommended levels by life stage for healthy dogs, so a dog with a disease or one that needs weight management needs individual adjustment. The MSD Manual also explains that feeding guidelines are only a starting point, and that you should watch body weight and body shape to avoid overfeeding or underfeeding. For a choice that suits the individual, it is good to consult a veterinarian.

What you can check at home is as follows.

  • How body weight and body shape (how well the ribs can be felt, the waistline) change over time
  • Whether the shape and frequency of stools are stable
  • Whether the dog eats the food well, and whether vomiting or diarrhea after meals does not repeat
  • Whether there is no change in the skin, coat and ears
  • Whether you review the food stage again when the dog ages or when life changes, such as neutering

We only note that gradual transition is important when changing food. The transition method is covered in a separate article. Also, once decided it is not finished, and when the dog's age and body condition change, you need to check again in the same order.

Common misconceptions, and when to see a veterinarian

Here are the misconceptions that often come up in choosing food.

  • If meat is on the first line of the ingredient list, it is good food: Ingredients are in order of weight including moisture, so the first line alone cannot tell you nutritional contribution, and ingredient quality cannot be known from the label either.
  • If it says premium or holistic, the nutrition is superior: WSAVA regards such unregulated terms as expressions of almost no use in assessing nutrition.
  • If there is a certification mark or award label, the nutrition is guaranteed: The FDA advises that recommendations from other organizations or certification marks are not a guarantee of nutritional adequacy.
  • If there is a nutritional adequacy statement, it suits every dog: The statement is a life stage standard for healthy dogs, and an individual dog's disease and constitution must be looked at separately.
  • If there is an ingredient registration number, quality is guaranteed: The number indicates that legal procedures were completed, and it does not tell you about the taste of an individual food or whether it suits your dog.

In the following cases, it is better to consult a veterinarian rather than change the food yourself.

  • When vomiting or diarrhea continues for a day or more, or bloody stool is seen
  • When appetite drops noticeably, or weight rises or falls quickly
  • When skin itching or ear inflammation recurs
  • When the dog has or has been diagnosed with a chronic disease such as kidney, heart or digestive disease
  • At times when nutritional needs change, such as puppies, pregnant or lactating dogs, and senior dogs
  • When considering a prescription diet or a homemade diet

Frequently asked questions

Q What should I look at first when choosing dog food?

First look at whether the package has a nutritional adequacy statement matching your dog's life stage. The US FDA advises that food with the phrase complete and balanced is intended to be used as the sole diet, and treats and supplements usually do not have this phrase.

Q What is the WSAVA list of questions?

These are the questions presented in the guidance on selecting pet foods by the WSAVA Global Nutrition Committee. They ask the manufacturer whether it employs a nutrition expert, who formulates the diets, how quality control is done and whether research is done, and advise caution toward brands that cannot answer. It is not a list that approves specific brands.

Q What are the ingredient registration number and the registered ingredient amounts?

Under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법), the company that makes the feed must register its ingredients with the competent local government, and the National Agricultural Products Quality Management Service explains that the ingredient registration number, registered ingredient amounts and so on go on the main display panel of the package. This article could not confirm the detailed items of the registered ingredient amounts from the original text, so please check the original text of the notice.

Q Is it enough to compare only the protein figure in the guaranteed analysis?

No. According to the MSD Veterinary Manual, the guaranteed analysis gives minimum and maximum limits on an as-fed basis that includes moisture, so foods with different moisture must be converted to a dry matter basis to be compared. Judging protein content is covered in a separate article.

Q Can I trust the order of the ingredient list?

Treat it as a reference. According to the MSD Manual, ingredients are listed in order of weight including moisture and ingredient quality cannot be known from the label, so it is hard to judge a food's nutritional level from the list alone. It is more useful for finding problem ingredients when an allergy is suspected.

Q How will labeling in Korea change after 2028?

MAFRA stated that, under the revised Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격), it plans to manage pet food from September 2028 by types such as pet complete feed and pet other feed. The detailed labeling depending on whether the nutrition standard is met needs to be checked in the latest notice before implementation.

Q What should I do if the manufacturer does not answer the questions?

WSAVA advises being cautious about feeding brands that cannot or will not provide information such as nutrition experts, formulation and quality control. Compare with the answers for other foods, or consult a veterinarian to judge.

Limits and scope of this guide

This article is general guidance and does not judge the relative merits of specific products or an individual dog's food choice. The original text of the labeling annex of the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) and of the provisions of the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) could not be opened and checked directly, and the labeling items in Korea follow materials from MAFRA and the National Agricultural Products Quality Management Service. The system from 2028 onward is based on press reports and needs to be checked before implementation. Dogs with disease, growing large-breed dogs, and prescription or homemade diets should be discussed with a veterinarian.

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.

Sources and check dates

  1. Guidelines on Selecting Pet Foods (WSAVA Global Nutrition Toolkit, 2021) ↗

    Basis for the four questions to ask the manufacturer, the nutritional adequacy statement, calories, contact details, and the criteria for checking who makes the food.

  2. Complete and Balanced Pet Food ↗

    Basis for the meaning of the complete and balanced statement, the standards by life stage, and the guidance that certification marks are not a nutritional guarantee.

  3. Reading Dog and Cat Food Labels (Dog and Cat Foods) ↗

    Basis for the guaranteed analysis, conversion to a dry matter basis, the limits of the ingredient list, and the four types of nutritional adequacy statement.

  4. Understanding Pet Food ↗

    Basis for the explanation that AAFCO does not regulate, test, approve or certify pet foods, creates model regulations, and that enforcement is by the FDA.

  5. Be sure to check the labeling before buying pet food (2024-12-03) (반려동물 사료 표시사항 꼭 확인 후 구입하세요 (2024-12-03)) ↗

    Basis for the mandatory labeling items on the main and other display panels and the 2024 inspection results (3,103 pieces, 4 violations).

  6. We will further strengthen the distribution management of pet food (press explanatory material) (반려동물 사료 유통관리를 더욱 강화해 나가겠습니다 (보도설명자료)) ↗

    Basis for the classification under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법), ingredient registration, and the plan to manage types from September 2028.

  7. Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (Act No. 19752) (사료관리법 (법률 제19752호)) ↗

    Basis for confirming the promulgation and enforcement information of the law (amended October 24, 2023, in force April 25, 2024). The text of the provisions did not open.

  8. Two years until the pet complete feed labeling standard takes effect... pet food industry says "the burden is heavy" (반려동물 완전사료 표시기준 시행 D-2년…펫푸드 업계 "부담 크다") ↗

    Basis for the press report on the labeling distinction between pet complete feed and pet other feed from September 2028 and the criterion of meeting the nutrition standard.

Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.

This guide relies on 2 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.