Is a food with higher protein a better food?
In short, the fact that the protein number is high cannot by itself make a food better. There is a lower limit to the protein a healthy adult dog needs, and what comes first is whether the food clears that lower limit while also containing the essential nutrients in balance. The sources checked for this article contain no evidence that high protein far above the lower limit means better health.
Another point to note is that how you read the protein number on the package changes the result of a comparison. The crude protein % on the package is based on the weight as it is, with water mixed in, so wet food with a lot of water looks like it has a small number and dry food with little water looks like it has a large one. If this difference is not corrected, you can miss a product whose protein is actually more concentrated, or read it the other way around.
This article first explains how to read the number correctly (dry matter basis and per-kcal conversion), then covers in turn the minimum requirements given by AAFCO and FEDIAF, protein quality, how labeling works in Korea, common misconceptions, and when to see a veterinarian. It does not recommend or compare specific products and introduces only criteria that owners can check themselves.
What basis is the crude protein number on the package based on?
The guaranteed analysis on a food package (crude protein, crude fat, moisture and so on) is a ratio on an as-fed basis, that is, with the water included. The US FDA advises that the guaranteed analysis table is written on an as-fed basis while the AAFCO nutrient profiles are on a dry matter basis, and explains that to compare wet and dry food each must therefore be converted to a dry matter basis (FDA, Complete and Balanced Pet Food).
Dry matter (DM) means what is left of the food after the moisture is removed. The Merck Veterinary Manual summarizes that dry food generally has moisture of around 10%, while wet food such as canned food has moisture of about 68–78%. With a moisture difference this large, the as-fed percentage can differ greatly even for the same amount of protein.
The conversion formula has two steps. First, find the dry matter proportion: subtract the moisture percentage on the package from 100. Second, divide the as-fed protein percentage by that dry matter proportion and multiply by 100. As a formula, dry matter basis protein (%) = as-fed protein (%) ÷ (100 − moisture %) × 100. The Merck Veterinary Manual also gives a worked calculation in the same way.
There is one more thing to know. In the guaranteed analysis, protein and fat are stated as minimums and moisture and fiber as maximums, as legally required label values, so they can differ from the actual content. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that actual analyzed values commonly come out higher than the minimum guaranteed values, and advises that where possible it is better to use the average nutrient values supplied by the manufacturer.
How does comparing wet and dry food on a dry matter basis change things?
The worked example in the Merck Veterinary Manual shows this difference well. A dry food with a minimum of 24% protein and a maximum of 12% moisture has 88% dry matter, so 24 ÷ 88 × 100 gives about 27.3% on a dry matter basis. A wet food with a minimum of 8% protein and a maximum of 82% moisture has 18% dry matter, so 8 ÷ 18 × 100 gives about 44.4%. By the package number the dry food looks three times higher, but on a dry matter basis the wet food is more concentrated.
In the table below, the first two rows are the example figures from this Merck manual, and the last two rows are hypothetical numbers set arbitrarily in this article to practice the calculation. They are not values of actual products.
In this way, as-fed numbers can be compared directly only between products with similar moisture (dry with dry, wet with wet). The Merck Veterinary Manual also advises that direct comparison is valid only between products with similar moisture content. The FDA likewise explains that products with the same guaranteed moisture can be compared without conversion.
Even so, the dry matter basis is not a perfect comparison. Dry matter also contains fat, carbohydrate and fiber, and for foods with different energy density, even the same dry matter protein ratio gives a different protein intake depending on how much is eaten in a day. That is why the per-kcal comparison in the next section is considered more accurate.
| Food type | Crude protein on package (as-fed) | Moisture | Dry matter proportion | Dry matter basis protein |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dry food A (Merck example) | 24% | 12% | 88% | approx. 27.3% |
| Wet food B (Merck example) | 8% | 82% | 18% | approx. 44.4% |
| Dry food C (hypothetical) | 26% | 10% | 90% | approx. 28.9% |
| Wet food D (hypothetical) | 9% | 78% | 22% | approx. 40.9% |
Why is a per-kcal comparison more accurate?
How much a dog eats is set by energy (kcal), not by weight. In an article in Today's Veterinary Practice, Dr. Shmalberg, a veterinary nutrition specialist, recommended comparing nutrients per unit of energy, preferably as grams of protein and fat per 1,000 kcal, because foods contain different amounts of energy in the same weight depending on their moisture and fiber. It is a way of looking at how many grams of protein the dog gets when eating the same calories.
The calculation is simple. Work out the as-fed grams of protein in 1 kg of food, then divide again by the energy (kcal) of that 1 kg of food divided by 1,000. For example, if a hypothetical dry food has 26% protein and 3,800 kcal per kg, the protein is 260 g, and dividing by 3.8 gives about 68 g per 1,000 kcal. If a hypothetical wet food has 9% protein and 1,000 kcal per kg, 90 g divided by 1 gives about 90 g. These two numbers are assumed values for practicing the calculation and are not values of actual products.
Energy is sometimes printed on the package and in many cases has to be confirmed by asking the manufacturer. FEDIAF gives a conversion factor saying that multiplying the figure per 100 g of dry matter by 2.5 gives the figure per 1,000 kcal, and this value assumes a reference energy density of about 4,000 kcal per 1 kg of dry matter. If the energy density of the actual food differs from this, the result differs too.
In the end, comparing protein can be summarized in three steps. Between products of the same type, look roughly at the as-fed numbers; if the types differ, convert to a dry matter basis; and for a precise comparison, compare grams per 1,000 kcal. Even then, the daily amount fed is set by energy, so it is a good idea to discuss adjusting the amount with a veterinarian.
What minimum requirements do AAFCO and FEDIAF give?
The US AAFCO dog food nutrient profiles set the minimum crude protein on a dry matter basis at 18.0% for adult maintenance and 22.5% for growth and reproduction (the dry matter basis is calculated on the assumption that 1 kg of food is 4,000 kcal). The Merck Veterinary Manual also expresses this in grams per 1,000 kcal, giving 45 g for adults and 56.3 g for growth and reproduction. 18% divided by an energy density of 0.4 is 45 g.
The nutritional guidelines of FEDIAF, the European Pet Food Industry Federation (October 2021 edition), list the minimum recommended protein for dogs both in grams per 100 g of dry matter and in grams per 1,000 kcal. In the table, depending on the assumed daily energy requirement, adults are 21.0 g per 100 g of dry matter (52.1 g per 1,000 kcal) or 18.0 g (45.0 g), young puppies in early growth (under 14 weeks) and reproduction are 25.0 g (62.5 g), and late growth (14 weeks and over) is 20.0 g (50.0 g).
FEDIAF states that these values are based on the NRC 2006 recommendations but adjusted to reflect an assumed protein digestibility of 80%, the low energy intake of pet dogs living in homes, and the needs of older dogs. The guidelines also presuppose food made from ingredients with a protein digestibility of 80% or more, and recommend increasing the essential amino acids further if this cannot be assured.
These numbers are all minimum recommended levels. Neither body says that going above them is better; the intent is not to fall below this line. Reference values can be revised, so please check the latest edition of the original text for the detailed values. Sources express the dry matter basis lower limit in different ways, so when carrying numbers over, be sure to look at the unit as well (dry matter % or per 1,000 kcal).
Can protein quality be known from the number?
Crude protein is a value converted from the nitrogen measured in the food. So protein that is not digested and nitrogen components that are not protein can also be included in the number, and even at the same 25%, the amount the body actually uses can differ. The most important limit is that the number alone cannot tell you the quality.
The Merck Veterinary Manual describes protein quality in terms of digestibility and biological value (the essential amino acid composition and how well it is used). It classifies digestibility under 80% as low, 80–85% as average, 86–93% as high and over 93% as very high, and says that the higher the biological value of a protein, the less of it is needed to meet essential amino acid requirements. This manual gives the essential amino acids for dogs as 10: arginine, histidine, isoleucine, leucine, lysine, methionine, phenylalanine, threonine, tryptophan and valine.
The AAFCO profiles also set minimum amounts of these amino acids separately, alongside crude protein. A table in a paper by Canadian researchers (Burdett et al., Canadian Veterinary Journal, 2018) lists values on a dry matter basis such as arginine 0.51% and lysine 0.63% for adult maintenance. This means that even if total protein is the same, a food may fail to meet the standard if the amino acid balance is off.
It is hard for owners to obtain digestibility or amino acid analysis values themselves. Instead, the realistic approach is to check whether there is a statement that the food meets the AAFCO nutrient profiles (a complete and balanced nutrition statement) and whether the manufacturer answers inquiries with data such as digestibility. These checks do not guarantee quality; they are reference criteria.
How is protein stated on food labels in Korea?
In Korea, under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) and the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) notice Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격), the food package must state on the main display panel the ingredient registration number, the name and form of the feed, the registered guaranteed analysis, the names of the raw materials used, and so on. In a 2024 press release, the National Agricultural Products Quality Management Service, an agency under MAFRA, presented these labeling items as excerpted from Annex 15 of the same notice.
A Korea Consumer Agency survey of pet food introduces how labeling works in Korea as follows. In Korea, minimum and maximum amounts are stated for the registered components, while other countries sometimes state averages and the like. For example, the Korean label “crude protein 19% min.” can look different from an overseas label “Protein 21.0%”, and for 4 of the 10 products surveyed there was a concern that consumers could be confused by such differences in basis.
Therefore the crude protein number on the package is a minimum guaranteed value and the actual value can generally be higher than that, and it is also difficult to compare Korean labels directly with the overseas labels of imported food. This article could not confirm from the original text which provision among the Korean labeling items requires a dry matter basis statement.
When reading protein on a Korean food package, look together at the crude protein min. statement in the registered guaranteed analysis, the moisture max. statement, the manufacture date and sell-by date, and the ingredient list, and compare by converting to a dry matter basis or per 1,000 kcal in the way described earlier. If the labeling seems questionable, you can ask the seller, the manufacturer or the competent authority.
What should owners check, and what are common misconceptions?
Items owners can check on the package and in manufacturer materials are as follows.
- Check the crude protein (min.) and moisture (max.) numbers together with the food form (dry or wet).
- Convert as-fed protein to a dry matter basis and compare on the same basis.
- If the package gives energy (kcal/kg), calculate down to grams of protein per 1,000 kcal.
- Look for a statement of meeting the nutrient profiles suited to the life stage (growth, adult, all life stages).
- Check whether the manufacturer provides data on protein quality, such as digestibility or amino acid analysis values.
Common misconceptions can be summarized as follows.
- The idea that “the higher the number, the better” mistakes the minimum standard for an upper limit. The AAFCO and FEDIAF numbers are lower limits not to fall below.
- The misconception that “wet food is low in protein” arises from not correcting for moisture. On a dry matter basis, wet food can be higher.
- The idea that “for protein you only need to look at the order of ingredients” is also inaccurate. Ingredient order is only part of the information about amounts used and does not tell you about digestibility or amino acid balance.
- The idea that “high protein is better for every dog” overlooks that age, activity level, body type and disease status differ for each individual. The FEDIAF guidelines also give separate minimum recommended levels for young puppies, adult dogs and reproduction.
The daily amount fed and the choice of food vary with body weight, body type and activity level, so please use number comparisons only as a reference.
In these cases, talk with a veterinarian first
For a dog diagnosed with or suspected of having kidney disease, liver disease, pancreatitis, a food allergy or the like, the owner should not increase or reduce the amount of protein arbitrarily but should decide it with a veterinarian. Depending on the disease, the amount and type of protein are sometimes adjusted, but the criteria vary with test results and the individual's condition and cannot be given in a general article. This article does not give recommended protein amounts by disease, and does not diagnose or prescribe.
If any of the following changes occur, it is a good idea to contact an animal hospital before changing the food.
- When the amount of water drunk or the amount of urine has clearly increased or decreased
- When vomiting or diarrhea repeats or appetite suddenly drops
- When weight drops for no reason or rises greatly
- When skin itching or hair loss continues
- When the dog is at a stage with different nutritional needs, such as an older dog, a young puppy, or a pregnant or nursing dog
As a principle, a special diet is decided individually, in consultation with a veterinarian, to fit the individual's condition. Switching food gradually is generally recommended when changing foods, but the specific schedule is covered in another article, so it is omitted here.
Frequently asked questions
Q If the crude protein number is high, is the food also well digested?
No. Crude protein is a total converted from nitrogen and does not tell you digestibility. The Merck Veterinary Manual describes protein quality in terms of digestibility and essential amino acid composition, so even at the same number the amount the body uses can differ.
Q How is dry matter basis protein calculated?
Divide the crude protein (%) on the package by the dry matter proportion and multiply by 100. The dry matter proportion is 100 minus moisture (%). For example, with 8% protein and 82% moisture, 8 ÷ 18 × 100 gives about 44.4%. Moisture is a maximum guaranteed value, so the result is approximate.
Q What is the minimum protein for adult dogs according to AAFCO?
The AAFCO dog food nutrient profiles set adult maintenance crude protein at a minimum of 18% on a dry matter basis, and the Merck Veterinary Manual expresses this as 45 g per 1,000 kcal. For growth and reproduction it is 22.5% on a dry matter basis (56.3 g per 1,000 kcal). It is a lower limit, not a recommended target.
Q Is wet food a low-protein food?
By the package number alone it looks low, but that is only because it has a lot of moisture. Converted to a dry matter basis, it can come out higher than dry food. In the Merck manual example, a wet food at 8% as-fed was about 44.4% on a dry matter basis, higher than the dry food at 24%, which was about 27.3%.
Q Should senior dogs have less protein?
It cannot be said that it must be reduced across the board. FEDIAF states that it adjusted the adult protein standard to reflect the needs of older dogs, so reducing it just because a dog is older lacks support. If kidney or other disease is suspected, talk with a veterinarian.
Q Can I directly compare the protein labels of Korean food and imported food?
Caution is needed. According to the Korea Consumer Agency survey, Korea uses minimum guaranteed amounts such as “crude protein 19% min.”, while overseas labels sometimes use averages, so the numbers may not be comparable as they look. Check the labeling method first.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article is general information for healthy dogs and is not a diagnosis or prescription. The amount of protein for dogs with diseases such as kidney or liver disease, or that are pregnant or nursing, should be decided with a veterinarian. We could not directly confirm the original text of the Korean legal provision that sets how protein is labeled, and substituted a government press release and an introduction of a Korea Consumer Agency survey. We could not open the original AAFCO tables, so the figures were confirmed from the Merck Veterinary Manual and a paper's table.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- Complete and Balanced Pet Food ↗
Used as the basis for the guaranteed analysis table being on an as-fed basis, AAFCO standards being on a dry matter basis, and the dry matter conversion method.
- Dog and Cat Foods (Management and Nutrition) ↗
Used as the basis for the dry matter conversion formula, the moisture ranges of dry and wet food, the worked examples (27.3% and 44.4%), and the limits of the guaranteed analysis.
- Nutritional Requirements of Small Animals ↗
Used as the basis for the dry matter basis and per-1,000-kcal converted values of the AAFCO adult and growth minimum protein, the digestibility classes, and the 10 essential amino acids.
- FEDIAF Nutritional Guidelines for Complete and Complementary Pet Food for Cats and Dogs (October 2021) ↗
Used as the basis for the minimum recommended protein for dogs (per 100 g of dry matter and per 1,000 kcal), the conversion factor 2.5, and the assumed digestibility of 80%.
- Many Canadian dog and cat foods fail to comply with the guaranteed analyses reported on packages (Can Vet J 2018;59:1181-1186) ↗
Used as the basis for the dry matter basis values of crude protein and essential amino acids in the AAFCO dog nutrient profiles and the 4,000 kcal/kg assumption.
- Chicken meal, fish oil? Names of pet food ingredients (introduction of a Korea Consumer Agency survey) (계육분, 어유? 반려동물 사료 원료 명칭 (한국소비자원 조사 소개)) ↗
Used as the basis for minimum and maximum amounts being stated in Korea while averages are also stated overseas, and for the “crude protein 19% min.” example.
- Press release on inspection of pet food labeling, including an excerpt of Annex 15 of the Standards and Specifications for Feeds notice (반려동물 사료 표시사항 점검 보도자료(사료 등의 기준 및 규격 고시 별표 15 발췌 포함)) ↗
Used as the basis for the Korean labeling items requiring the ingredient registration number, name, registered guaranteed analysis, names of raw materials used and so on on the main display panel.
- Beyond the Guaranteed Analysis: Comparing Pet Foods (Shmalberg, 2013) ↗
Used as the basis for the recommendation that the guaranteed analysis is on an as-fed basis and so cannot be used to compare foods, and that foods should be compared in grams per 1,000 kcal.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 2 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
