The conclusion first: has grain-free food been confirmed as a cause of DCM?
It has not been confirmed. The US FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine (CVM) has investigated a possible link between certain diets and canine dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) since 2018, but says it has not identified a specific cause so far. The FDA describes this as a complex scientific problem in which genetics, underlying disease and diet may act together, and says there is no confirmed information that these foods are inherently unsafe and should be removed from the market.
However, the hypothesis did not arise without basis. What the FDA noticed in 2018 was that reports of DCM had increased in dogs of breeds in which DCM is uncommon, that is, dogs with no known genetic predisposition, and that many of those dogs had eaten food with no grain and with legumes or potatoes as main ingredients. This article explains, in separate parts, the course of that investigation, what the hypothesis says, the disagreements among researchers, and what owners can check.
One point first. This article does not judge any food as good or bad, and does not mention any specific product. It is also not a diagnosis of any individual dog's health. If heart disease is suspected, seeing a veterinarian comes before choosing a food.
When and how did the FDA investigation proceed?
The course the FDA has made public is in the table below. Only dates and content confirmed on FDA web pages are written.
To add below the table, on a question-and-answer page marked as of August 19, 2024, the FDA says there were 1,382 reports of DCM in dogs in total from January 1, 2014 to November 1, 2022. The FDA itself added the caveat that these numbers are voluntary reports, cannot all be verified, and may not reflect the actual incidence. The FDA also explains that reports have decreased since 2020 but are continuing.
The FDA repeatedly stresses that the number of reports alone does not establish causation with the products concerned. The FDA says it does not itself know the background rate at which dogs get DCM, that is, how much non-hereditary DCM occurs regardless of diet, so the lack of any baseline for judging whether reports are many or few is a major limitation of this discussion.
| Time | What the FDA made public |
|---|---|
| July 2018 | Announced the start of an investigation, saying there were reports of DCM in dogs that ate certain foods. The concern was foods with peas, lentils, other pulses or potatoes as main ingredients near the front of the ingredient list |
| February 2019 | A progress report on investigation activity through November 30, 2018 |
| June 27, 2019 | Third public report. Summarized reports received through April 30, 2019. Reports received from January 2014 to April 2019 numbered 524 (515 dogs, 9 cats) |
| November 3, 2020 | One of the public communication dates the FDA listed on its Q&A page |
| December 23, 2022 | Added the report count as of November 1, 2022 to the Q&A, and said it would not make further public updates until meaningful new scientific information emerges |
What are the legume and potato hypotheses, and how far can they be stated?
The core of the hypothesis is the link between DCM reports and foods in which peas, lentils, other pulses or potatoes appear high on the ingredient list (within the first 10 ingredients). In its 2019 report, the FDA analyzed the dog foods reported from January 2014 to April 2019 and explains that about 91 percent of the reported foods were grain-free, about 93 percent contained peas or lentils, and about 42 percent contained potatoes or sweet potatoes.
However, these numbers are only proportions within the reported cases and were not compared with the distribution of all the food dogs actually eat on the market, so they cannot be read as a degree of risk as they stand. In its Q&A updated in 2024, the FDA also says that foods with non-soy legumes and pulses near the front of the ingredient list were common in reports, but that these ingredients have long been used in pet food and there is no evidence that they are inherently dangerous. It also said it did not see a signal with soy.
Another important point is that there were reports with food that contains grain too. The FDA explains that reports of non-hereditary DCM are associated with both grain-free food and food containing grain, so the problem is not limited to grain-free food. What FDA materials suggest is that grain-free foods tend to contain pulses at a higher proportion. So an interpretation is possible that the more essential questions are which ingredients are in the food and in what amounts, and what the overall nutritional design is, rather than the label of whether grain is present.
What role does taurine play in this discussion?
Taurine is an amino-acid-like substance related to heart muscle function. The FDA explains that dogs can synthesize taurine from cysteine and methionine, so it is generally not regarded as an essential nutrient for dogs. Instead, a hypothesis arose that taurine can fall if the sulfur-containing amino acids in the diet (methionine and cysteine) are lacking or poorly available, and the starting point is that taurine deficiency was reported in some dogs with DCM. The FDA also mentions that DCM associated with taurine deficiency has traditionally been known in Cocker Spaniels.
The FDA's own test results, stated in its June 2019 report, are not simple. The FDA said that the average protein, taurine, cystine and methionine content on a dry matter basis was similar between grain-free products and products containing grain, and that in most grain-free products methionine-cystine exceeded the AAFCO minimum. Whether there is an effect on taurine at the absorption or excretion stage was, at that time, said to be under review.
Study results are also mixed. A study published in BMC Veterinary Research in 2022 divided 11 healthy adult Labrador Retrievers into a group fed a grain-free food using 60% peas and lentils for 30 days and a control group, and reported that in the test group red blood cell values and hematocrit decreased and plasma inorganic phosphate increased. Blood taurine rose temporarily on day 14 and then changed, and urine taurine fell sharply on days 28–30, and the authors wrote that further research is needed. In reading this study, one should also take into account that the number of animals was very small, that echocardiography was done in only 6 of the 11 dogs, and that the authors belong to the pet food industry.
In a prospective study published in JVIM in 2022, 60 dogs with DCM (mostly on non-traditional diets) and 16 dogs with subclinical cardiac abnormalities were followed for 9 months after a diet change, and none of the DCM dogs had low plasma or whole blood taurine at enrollment. That is, the question this study raises is that it is hard to regard taurine deficiency as the common cause of all diet-associated DCM.
How should breeds with a genetic predisposition be viewed?
DCM is a disease that also arises from heredity, regardless of diet. The FDA explains that DCM is recognized as a hereditary disease in large and giant breeds, for example the Doberman Pinscher, Great Dane and Irish Wolfhound, and is relatively uncommon in small and medium dogs. So when DCM is confirmed in these breeds, it cannot be immediately attributed to the food. The 2022 JVIM study also wrote as a limitation that some dogs on non-traditional diets may in fact have been of breeds predisposed to DCM and may have had primary DCM rather than diet-associated DCM.
Conversely, what the FDA paid attention to was reports in breeds with no previously known predisposition. As of the 2019 report, Golden Retrievers and mixed breeds were the most numerous, and the FDA added that for Golden Retrievers there may have been more reports because of breed-specific awareness activities, that is, there may be reporting bias. It also explains that the high proportion of males is consistent with a hereditary form.
Because genetic factors, dietary factors and reporting bias overlap in this way, interpreting this topic needs a veterinary examination that looks at breed, age, diet history and cardiac test results all together. An owner alone cannot sort out the cause by changing just one food.
Where do researchers disagree?
The points on which researchers disagree can be summarized in three broad groups.
- Where the cause lies: There is still no agreement on whether the problem is legumes themselves, the overall nutritional design of grain-free food, the availability of sulfur-containing amino acids, or whether an individual dog's genetic susceptibility is the key.
- Level of evidence: Report-based data cannot show causation, and small feeding trials have few animals. Long-term, large controlled studies are lacking.
- Taurine measurement: An article introduced on June 7, 2022 by the Korean outlet Dailyvet (데일리벳) relays a contribution published in Focus, the clinical journal of the pet food company Royal Canin (로얄캐닌). According to this article, the veterinary nutrition specialist in the contribution (Jennifer Larsen) saw the evidence as unclear although several studies have named grain-free food as a risk factor for DCM, and pointed out that ingredients such as peas and lentils appeared to be included in excess. The specialist also argued that whole blood and plasma taurine should be measured in all dogs with DCM. The gist is that taurine testing is not often done, which makes it hard to confirm a dietary link.
There is one more fact that helps in understanding the disagreement. Even among feeding trials, results differ from study to study. The 30-day Labrador trial introduced above reported changes in red blood cells and phosphate, while the 2022 JVIM prospective study reported that some echocardiographic measures improved slightly after the diet was changed, but itself wrote the limitations that the sample was small and the study was not blinded. It also said that sudden death was the most common cause of death even in dogs whose diet was changed. This also means it is hard to believe that changing the food alone solves the problem.
In summary, the possibility that diet contributes to DCM in some dogs remains open, but under what conditions, in whom and by what mechanism it happens is still not settled.
Under what system is feed managed in Korea?
Feed in Korea is managed under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법). The version of the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act confirmed at the National Law Information Center was one that had been partially amended on October 24, 2023 (Act No. 19752) and takes effect from April 25, 2024. However, in writing this article the text of the provisions was not opened and read, so the details of labeling duties and standards and specifications must be checked directly in the text of the law and in the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) notification Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격).
To be clear about what could not be confirmed: whether a Korean public body has issued a separate official position or product regulation on the relationship between grain-free food and DCM was not confirmed in this article. So it does not state how this hypothesis has been reflected in the Korean system.
What was confirmed from Korean information is at the level of trade media reports. The Dailyvet article mentioned earlier is a case of this issue being introduced in Korea, and it relays the content of a contribution to a pet food company Royal Canin (로얄캐닌) journal, not the findings of a Korean institution's investigation. Therefore owners in Korea are safer treating the overseas investigation course as reference information and making the actual decision together with their veterinarian.
How does this differ from overseas standards?
In the United States the FDA is carrying out the investigation seen above, and the nutrient levels of AAFCO are commonly cited as the standard for nutritional adequacy of feed. The FDA said that most grain-free products exceeded the AAFCO minimum for methionine-cystine, which means that meeting the minimum standard has not resolved the diet-associated DCM discussion. This is because minimum nutrient standards, ingredient availability and individual differences are separate issues.
This article could not directly open and compare AAFCO, FEDIAF or WSAVA documents, so it does not write what specific positions those bodies hold on this topic. The overseas positions this article confirmed are only the FDA web pages and two scholarly papers.
One general principle is confirmed in FDA materials. The FDA advises that when owners consider a food change they should talk to their veterinarian, and that the veterinarian should consult a veterinary nutrition specialist if needed. That is, overseas too, deciding together with a professional is advised over an owner changing food alone.
What should the owner check?
This article does not decide for you whether to change the food. However, the checklist below helps when you consult.
- Record what the ingredients near the front of the ingredient list of the current food are
- Organize the whole diet history, including not only the food but also treats, supplements and toppings. The FDA also says a veterinarian may ask for a diet history of everything the dog has eaten, including treats.
- Know your dog's breed, age and family history (heart disease in parents or siblings)
- Check when the dog last had a heart checkup (auscultation, echocardiography and so on)
- If you decide to change the food, do not change it suddenly, and discuss the transition method with your veterinarian
- Check whether you can contact the number on the food package to ask about ingredients and nutritional design
The labeled order of ingredients is only one clue. Even with the same ingredient list, the actual nutrition can differ depending on the processing method, the mixing proportions and availability, so safety cannot be judged from the ingredient list alone.
What are the common misunderstandings, and what are the facts?
Misunderstanding one. The idea that all grain-free food is dangerous. In its 2019 report the FDA said that most dogs in the United States appear to eat food without getting DCM, and explains that reports are voluntary and may not reflect the actual incidence. There is nothing in FDA materials that could be used to assert that grain-free food is risky.
Misunderstanding two. The idea that you can feel safe if the food contains grain. The FDA said there are also reports associated with food that contains grain. Whether grain is present is not a single criterion that settles this question.
Misunderstanding three. The idea that adding taurine alone solves it. As seen earlier, dogs with DCM and no taurine deficiency have also been reported, and problems of precursor nutrients such as methionine and cystine and of availability are being discussed, so it has not been settled by a single supplement. The type and amount of any supplement is for a veterinarian to decide after looking at the individual dog's condition.
Misunderstanding four. The idea that the problem is over because the FDA stopped updating. What the FDA said means that it will not make public updates until meaningful new scientific information emerges, and it is not a declaration that the investigation has ended or that a cause has been established. In the Q&A updated in 2024 as well, it said it would give further guidance if new substantive information emerges.
When you should see a veterinarian
If any of the following signs are present, contact an animal hospital before changing the food. The FDA too lists reduced energy, coughing, difficulty breathing and collapse as possible signs of DCM, and advises contacting a veterinarian promptly and getting emergency care if it is an emergency.
- Coughing that keeps going or gets worse at night
- Labored breathing, breathing with the mouth open, or fast breathing even at rest
- Exercise intolerance, finding walks or play harder than usual and tiring easily
- Suddenly collapsing or fainting
DCM can show no outward signs and be noticed only after it has progressed, and there are studies in which sudden death was reported. If the dog is a breed with a known predisposition or there has been heart disease in the family, discuss a checkup schedule with your veterinarian even without signs. The information in this article is not a diagnosis, and interpreting signs, testing, treatment and food changes must be judged by the treating veterinarian looking at the individual dog.
Frequently asked questions
Q Did the FDA say not to feed grain-free food?
The FDA explains that there is no confirmed information that these diets are inherently unsafe and should be removed from the market, and advises talking to a veterinarian before changing the food.
Q Is the FDA investigation over?
The FDA page has no notice that the investigation has ended. On December 23, 2022 the FDA said it would not make further public updates until meaningful new scientific information emerges, and in the Q&A updated in 2024 it said it would give further guidance if substantive information emerges.
Q What is the legume hypothesis the FDA mentioned?
It is the hypothesis that DCM reports may be related to foods in which peas, lentils, other pulses or potatoes occupy the front of the ingredient list. The FDA also explains that these ingredients have long been used and that there is no evidence they are inherently dangerous.
Q Does low taurine cause DCM?
Taurine deficiency was confirmed in some dogs with DCM, but not in all cases. In the 2022 JVIM prospective study, none of the DCM dogs had low taurine at enrollment. Taurine testing and supplementation for an individual dog are for a veterinarian to decide.
Q Can owners of small or medium dogs feel safe?
The FDA sees hereditary DCM as known mainly in large and giant breeds and as less common in small and medium dogs, but many diet-associated reports involved breeds with no known predisposition. Rather than feeling safe because of size, it is appropriate to be examined if there are signs.
Q Should I change the food I feed now right away?
This article does not decide whether to change. The FDA advises talking to a veterinarian before changing the food, and says a veterinary nutrition specialist can be consulted if needed. A sudden change can cause digestive problems, so discuss the transition method as well.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article is a general guide compiled from two FDA web pages, two scholarly papers and one Korean media article (introducing a pet food company contribution) that were read directly, and is not a diagnosis or a prescription. The text of the provisions of the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act and the AAFCO, FEDIAF and WSAVA documents were not opened and read, so their content is not written. The FDA report counts are voluntary reports and do not mean the actual incidence, and new investigation results after 2022 could not be confirmed. A dog with signs, or with a family history of heart disease, needs veterinary care regardless of the food.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- FDA Investigation into Potential Link between Certain Diets and Canine Dilated Cardiomyopathy ↗
Basis for the 2018 announcement, the 2019 reports, the December 23, 2022 update, the cause not being determined, and the guidance on signs and consulting a veterinarian.
- Questions & Answers: FDA's Work on Potential Causes of Non-Hereditary DCM in Dogs ↗
Basis for the count of 1,382 reports, reports also with food that contains grain, the explanation about legumes, and the absence of background incidence statistics.
- Responses in randomised groups of healthy, adult Labrador retrievers fed grain-free diets with high legume inclusion for 30 days display commonalities with dogs with suspected dilated cardiomyopathy ↗
Basis for the red blood cell, phosphate and taurine changes in the small 30-day feeding trial and the limitations stated by the authors.
- Prospective study of dilated cardiomyopathy in dogs eating nontraditional or traditional diets and in dogs with subclinical cardiac abnormalities ↗
Basis for the 9-month follow-up results, normal taurine at enrollment, sudden death, and the sample limitations.
- Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) ↗
Confirmed the legal framework for feed management in Korea and the enforcement information (effective April 25, 2024, Act No. 19752).
- To establish a link between grain-free food and DCM, taurine concentrations must be measured (그레인프리 사료와 DCM 연관성 밝히려면 타우린 농도 측정해야) ↗
A June 7, 2022 report. An article relaying the claims, in a contribution to the clinical journal of the pet food company Royal Canin (로얄캐닌) by a veterinary nutrition and cardiology specialist, about possible excess legumes and the need to measure taurine; this guide states in its text that this is a contribution from a pet food company.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 2 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
