Skip to content
Grochi · Neutral pet information from South Korea · English edition한국어
Grochi.English edition
Health care

My dog hops while holding up a hind leg: could it be patellar luxation?

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. This page is an English translation of the Korean edition as checked on 2026-11-19. If the two differ, the Korean edition is the reference. 한국어판 (Korean edition)

My dog hops while holding up a hind leg: could it be patellar luxation?
Short answer

Patellar luxation is a condition in which the kneecap slips out of its groove, and a gait in which the dog briefly lifts a hind leg and then puts it down again is a common sign. Management differs by grade and symptoms, so a veterinary examination is needed.

Key takeaways

  • Patellar luxation is a condition in which the kneecap (patella) slips inward or outward out of the groove at the end of the thigh bone, and in small dogs the inward form is described as common.
  • The typical sign owners see is a dog that suddenly lifts one hind leg while running, hops for a few steps and then walks normally again; this is called a skip gait.
  • Luxation is usually divided into grades 1–4, and it is explained that as the grade rises, the kneecap stays out of place for longer and bone deformity becomes more pronounced.
  • Whether to operate is decided by the veterinarian by looking at grade, limping, age and other joint problems together, and this article neither recommends nor discourages surgery.
  • If the dog keeps holding a hind leg up, the limping becomes more and more frequent, the dog suddenly limps badly after an injury, or the dog cannot stand on both hind legs, go to the hospital without waiting.

Is hopping while holding up a hind leg patellar luxation?

If a dog that was running well suddenly lifts one hind leg, goes a few steps on three legs, and then walks on all four legs again as if nothing had happened, patellar luxation is worth suspecting. The American College of Veterinary Surgeons (ACVS) explains that most patients show a pattern in which they suddenly hold up a leg for a few steps and then use it again, a gait that seems to skip a step (skip). The VCA animal hospital guidance and the Merck Veterinary Manual also introduce this gait, in which the dog briefly cannot bear weight and then recovers soon after, as the typical symptom.

However, this gait does not immediately mean patellar luxation. As ACVS notes that dogs with patellar luxation also tend to develop cruciate ligament disease, it is hard to say that there is only one reason a leg is lifted. The cause cannot be sorted out from an owner's observation alone, and VCA says the usual diagnostic order is for the veterinarian to feel the position and movement of the kneecap by hand and, if needed, to check the severity and other joint changes with X-rays.

So the conclusion of this article is simple. If the hopping with a raised hind leg keeps happening, it is better to film the dog walking for a short video, show it to the veterinarian at the visit, and get the diagnosis at the hospital. Diagnosis and treatment decisions are up to the attending veterinarian, not this article.

What exactly is patellar luxation?

The patella is a small bone at the front of the knee, commonly called the kneecap. When normal, it slides up and down in a groove (the trochlear groove) at the lower end of the thigh bone (femur) and transmits the force that extends and bends the knee. VCA describes luxation as a state in which the kneecap moves out of its original position.

The Merck Veterinary Manual classifies this condition as a developmental orthopedic disease. As the surrounding muscles and bone structure grow, they form abnormally, and the kneecap is pushed out of the groove toward the inside (medial) or the outside (lateral). It explains that for inward luxation, structural features such as a shallow groove or a twisted alignment of the thigh bone and shin bone are reported alongside.

ACVS explains that patellar luxation generally originates from an abnormality in the growth process, and that when the kneecap slips out of the groove more and more often, cartilage wears away, which can lead to arthritis and pain. VCA also says that arthritis develops as the dog ages and that, once it has developed, arthritis cannot be reversed.

Why is it so often mentioned for small dogs?

The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that inward luxation is common in small and toy breeds and in some large breeds and cats, while outward luxation is much rarer and appears mainly in large breeds. VCA likewise says that inward luxation is common in toy and small breeds such as the Maltese, Chihuahua, Poodle and Bichon Frise, and that genetic influence is often present.

The Orthopedic Foundation for Animals (OFA) in the US gives comparatively specific guidance on the hereditary nature of this condition. OFA writes that inward luxation should be regarded as a hereditary disease, and distinguishes that whether outward luxation in small breeds is hereditary is not yet known. For this reason, for people planning to breed, it runs a program of testing at 12 months of age or older. This does not apply directly to ordinary pet households with no breeding plans, but it helps in understanding that this condition is related to inborn structure and not to an owner's carelessness.

There is a point to be careful about here. Saying that it is often mentioned for small dogs does not mean that every small dog gets it. It can also occur in large dogs, so the gait actually seen and the veterinarian's examination findings matter more than the breed. This article does not give figures for the occurrence rate in particular breeds because I could not confirm them in the original source.

How are grades 1–4 divided?

The veterinarian checks by touch how easily the kneecap slips out, how long it stays out, and whether it can be put back by hand, and divides the condition into grades 1–4. The way it is described differs a little between organizations, but the main outline is the same. Summarized in a way that is easy for owners to understand from the descriptions of the Merck Veterinary Manual and VCA, it is as in the table below. This table is a summary to aid understanding, and the actual grade must be determined by the veterinarian's palpation and imaging tests.

The grade is only a tool that tells the current state of the disease, not a table that directly decides whether to operate. Even among dogs with the same grade 2, some barely limp and some are in pain often. Cases where only one knee is affected also differ from cases where both are affected. VCA says that in about 50% of affected dogs both knees are involved, and that the grades of the two knees can differ.

Summary of patellar luxation grades (combining the Merck Veterinary Manual and VCA descriptions)
GradeState of the kneecapWhat owners commonly see
Grade 1It slips out only when pushed and returns to place when releasedFew or no symptoms, or they appear only rarely
Grade 2It sometimes slips out on its own and goes back only when the leg is extended or turnedThe dog lifts the leg intermittently
Grade 3It is out of place most of the time and goes back when pushed in by hand but slips out againLimping is steady and bone deformity can be seen
Grade 4It is always out of place and cannot be put back by handSymptoms are severe, such as walking in a crouched posture

What signs show up at home?

The signs owners notice at home or on walks follow a similar pattern. The typical pictures introduced by VCA, ACVS and the Merck Veterinary Manual are as follows.

  • While running, the dog seems to skip a step, or goes a few steps on three legs and then walks on four legs again.
  • The dog holds the leg up and then stretches it out sideways or shakes it, as if putting the kneecap back in place.
  • Over time the limping becomes more frequent, and when it gets worse the dog limps continuously.
  • In a young puppy, the legs may look bowed, and in some cases this becomes more pronounced with growth.
  • In outward luxation in large dogs, a posture in which the knees seem to draw inward may be seen.

The Merck Veterinary Manual says symptoms usually begin before 1 year of age, whereas OFA says outward luxation in small breeds is sometimes identified at 5–8 years of age. In other words, you can neither conclude that it is a different disease because it was first seen later in life, nor that it is not.

Another important point is that pain is not always present. ACVS explains that mild cases may not be painful, and that pain often develops as the condition progresses. A dog that looks pain-free does not mean that no visit is needed, so for repeated symptoms it is better to have a veterinarian check the condition at least once.

Does surgery always have to be done?

There is no single right answer to this question, and the veterinarian decides for each dog. The direction that authoritative sources generally give is as follows. The Merck Veterinary Manual says surgery is generally recommended for grades 2–4 (moderate to severe), for marked limping, or when symptoms are getting worse. On the other hand, for mild cases (grade 1 and some grade 2), older dogs, and dogs in a condition where surgery is difficult, it says conservative management such as weight management, exercise control, physical therapy and anti-inflammatory pain relief is sometimes used. It adds, however, that conservative management reduces inflammation and discomfort but does not correct the bone structure, so the luxation can progress.

ACVS explains that luxation without symptoms, especially in small dogs, is often watched without surgery, and that surgery is usually considered at grade 2 or higher. It also says that over 90% of owners are satisfied with the dog's course after surgery, while advising that the outlook may be less good for large dogs or when other bone abnormalities are present, and that several weeks of rest and recheck visits are needed after surgery. VCA says that for most dogs surgery may be recommended to reduce arthritis or cruciate ligament rupture and that the higher the grade, the sooner surgery should be done, but adds that mild grade 1 may not need surgery.

All of this guidance is general principle and is not a criteria table that tells which dog needs surgery. It varies with the grade, the degree of limping, age, and the presence of other problems such as bone deformity, the cruciate ligament or the hip joint, so whether and when to operate should be decided after thorough consultation with the veterinarian. This article neither recommends nor discourages surgery.

What material is there in Korea?

In Korea too, patellar luxation in small dogs has long been a subject of veterinary research. One example is the 2005 doctoral dissertation (Kang Myung-gon, Evaluation of surgical treatment of patellar luxation in small-breed dogs) from the Department of Veterinary Medicine, Graduate School of Konkuk University. According to the abstract, of 613 dogs that visited one animal hospital in northern Gyeonggi Province, 64 (10.4%) were diagnosed with patellar luxation of various grades, and the most common breed was the Yorkshire Terrier (36%). It reports that 63% were female, 91% were congenital, 61% involved both knees, and 98% were inward luxation. There is also a result that in the group that did not have surgery, the grade rose in 83%.

Caution is needed in reading these figures. This is a single 2005 study of patients who visited one animal hospital, so it must not be read as the current occurrence rate among all pet dogs in Korea. Figures such as "70–80% of pet dogs in Korea have patellar luxation" circulate on the internet, but in writing this article I could not confirm the original statistics behind them, so they are not cited.

As for what share of pet dogs in Korea are small dogs, this article also does not give a number, because I could not confirm the original figures of a public survey. If you want the exact ratio, I recommend checking directly the original text of the pet protection and welfare survey published by the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) and the Animal and Plant Quarantine Agency (APQA). The guidance in this article is a general explanation drawing on both overseas sources and a Korean thesis abstract.

What can be managed in daily life?

There is not much direct guidance on daily-life management in the authoritative sources this article checked. The Merck Veterinary Manual lists weight management, exercise control, physical therapy and anti-inflammatory pain relief as conservative management items, and VCA also says weight loss is recommended for overweight dogs. The sources this article checked contain no guidance on adjusting the home environment, such as flooring, stairs or jumping onto furniture, so it is not covered here. Which exercise is safe depends on the dog's grade and condition, so it is better to ask a veterinarian and decide. If you wonder whether your dog has gained weight, check its current state using a body condition score. Another article on this site covers that.

What owners can do is as follows.

  • Check meal amounts and treats so the dog stays at an appropriate weight.
  • Record the gait on video from time to time and share the changes with the veterinarian.
  • Ask for kneecap palpation at regular health checkups to confirm the current grade.

Whether joint supplements help is a separate topic in terms of level of evidence, so it is not covered here and is only linked by pointing to a related article.

What owners can check
Item to checkHow to observeWhat to tell the veterinarian
How often the dog lifts the legMark the number of times during walks or play on a calendarHow many times a day and for how many days
One side or bothFilm the dog walking from behindLeft or right
Pain responseWatch whether the dog pulls away or cries when touchedWhether there is crying, licking or an attempt to bite
Weight changeWeigh regularly on the same scaleWhether it has recently increased, and the amount of food
Age and when it beganRecord the date the first symptom was seenWhether it has been since puppyhood or is recent

What are the common misunderstandings?

First is the idea that if the dog lifts the leg and soon seems fine, there is no problem. The skip gait is a pattern commonly seen as the kneecap slips out and goes back in. A short symptom does not mean there is no disease, and ACVS says that over time the limping can become more frequent and turn into continuous limping.

Second is the idea that small dogs are just like that. It is true that it is commonly mentioned for small dogs, but common and normal are different things. According to VCA, as it progresses, irreversible arthritis can develop and the risk of cruciate ligament rupture can rise, so even a common problem needs checking and management.

Third is the idea that surgery solves it completely and no later care is needed. ACVS says recurrence after surgery is rare, but advises that the outlook may be less good for large dogs or when other bone abnormalities are present, and that several weeks of rest and recheck visits are needed after surgery.

Fourth, the opposite idea that without surgery it will surely get worse is also not accurate. ACVS explains that when there are no symptoms, especially in small dogs, it is often just watched. In the end, the answer lies between the two extremes, in deciding with the veterinarian by looking at the individual condition.

Should I go to the hospital in these cases?

The following pictures described by ACVS and OFA differ from the usual mild skip gait, so it is better to be examined soon. This article does not judge whether something is an emergency, and another cause is also possible.

  • The dog keeps holding a hind leg up (ACVS).
  • The limping becomes more and more frequent and then continues (ACVS).
  • The pain seems severe as it progresses (ACVS).
  • A dog that had no problem before suddenly limps badly after a knee injury (ACVS).
  • In a small dog, both hind legs suddenly slip out together and the dog cannot stand properly (OFA).

The Merck Veterinary Manual advises checking for and treating cruciate ligament and meniscus damage that may be present together, and VCA also explains that dogs with luxation tend to get cruciate ligament disease. So a limp that suddenly becomes severe may be a problem beyond simple luxation.

Even if the symptoms look mild and intermittent, an owner cannot decide how long it is all right to wait, so contact the veterinarian and ask when the dog should be examined. In particular, if the dog suddenly cannot put weight on the leg or cannot stand, contact the hospital right away without waiting. Before the visit, preparing a video of the gait, the date the first symptom was seen, weight changes, and a list of medicines or supplements being taken helps the veterinarian grasp the condition. Do not try to put the kneecap back yourself; follow the veterinarian's guidance.

Frequently asked questions

Q What kind of disease is patellar luxation?

It is a condition in which the kneecap slips inward or outward out of the groove at the end of the thigh bone. The Merck Veterinary Manual classifies it as a developmental orthopedic disease and says that in small dogs the inward form is common.

Q My dog lifts only one hind leg now and then. Should I go to the hospital?

Even if it is occasional, if it repeats it is better to have an examination. There are several causes besides patellar luxation and it is hard for owners to tell them apart, and if possible, bringing a video of the dog walking helps.

Q If the grade is high, does the dog have to have surgery?

That cannot be assumed. The Merck Veterinary Manual and ACVS say surgery is usually considered at grade 2 or higher, but the veterinarian decides individually by looking at limping, age and other joint problems together.

Q Can it be luxation even if the dog does not seem to be in pain?

Yes. ACVS explains that mild luxation may not be painful, and that pain often develops as it progresses. Even without symptoms, you can have the kneecap checked at a health checkup.

Q Does weight management help?

The Merck Veterinary Manual lists weight management as a conservative management item, and VCA says weight loss is recommended for overweight dogs. Decide the target weight and method together with a veterinarian.

Q Is it a hereditary disease?

OFA says inward luxation should be regarded as a hereditary disease. However, it distinguishes that for some types, such as outward luxation in small breeds, whether it is hereditary is not known, so it is hard to conclude that every case is hereditary.

Q Can I put the kneecap back myself at home?

It is not recommended. Touching it wrongly can cause pain or damage, so if luxation is suspected, it is safer to show the dog to a veterinarian and follow their guidance.

Limits and scope of this guide

This article is an editorial draft based on 4 overseas veterinary sources and 1 Korean doctoral thesis abstract, and it has not been reviewed by veterinary professionals. It cannot replace diagnosis, the decision on surgery, or treatment for an individual animal, and a veterinary examination is required. The Korean thesis is single-hospital data from 2005 and does not represent the current occurrence rate across Korea, and the share of small dogs in Korea and up-to-date occurrence statistics are not given because I could not confirm the original sources.

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.

Sources and check dates

  1. Patellar Luxation in Dogs and Cats ↗

    Used as the basis for the definition of luxation, the grade 1–4 descriptions, the skip gait, the criteria for considering surgery and the conservative management items.

  2. Luxating Patella in Dogs ↗

    Used as the basis for the examples of small breeds, the about 50% share involving both knees, the arthritis and cruciate ligament risks, and the weight loss guidance.

  3. Patellar Luxation ↗

    Used as the basis for the skip gait, watching luxation without symptoms, considering surgery at grade 2 or higher, and the guidance on the course after surgery and recheck visits.

  4. Patellar Luxation ↗

    Used as the basis for the guidance on the heritability of inward luxation, the testing program for breeding dogs, and the age of onset.

  5. Evaluation of surgical treatment of patellar luxation in small-breed dogs (소형견에서 슬개골 탈구의 수술적 치료 평가; Kang Myung-gon, Konkuk University doctoral dissertation, 2005) ↗

    Used as the basis for introducing the result that 64 of 613 patients at one animal hospital in Korea were diagnosed with luxation, and the rate of grade increase in the group without surgery.

Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.