If I feel a lump, is it all right to just watch it for now?
No lump can be identified by touch, so record its location, size and date; if it is larger than 1cm and has been there for over a month, it should be tested by a veterinarian; and if it grows, changes in appearance or makes the animal uncomfortable, it should be shown to a veterinarian sooner without waiting out the month. This criterion was confirmed in the Today's Veterinary Practice commentary. Meanwhile, lumps on and under the skin are very common. The Merck Veterinary Manual's owner-facing page on skin tumors in dogs explains that tumors arising on or just under the skin are the tumors seen most commonly in dogs. And a lump does not automatically mean cancer. Many are less worrying, such as benign lumps of clumped fat, areas swollen from inflammation, and cysts.
However, you cannot tell which it is by touching it. The same Merck page explains that skin tumors vary widely and that working out what one is should be left to a veterinarian. It also explains that a malignant mast cell tumor can look like a benign lipoma, so a diagnosis cannot be settled from appearance alone.
So “let's just watch it for now” can be risky without a time frame and a criterion. The Today's Veterinary Practice commentary points out that just watching can lead to leaving a lump too long. This article is not meant to tell you which lumps are dangerous; it organizes the guidance of authoritative sources on what to record before showing a veterinarian and when to bring the lump to the hospital. What a lump is and the direction of treatment are always decided by a veterinarian who sees and tests it directly.
What kinds of lumps are there?
Lumps on or under the skin are explained as falling into several broad groups. Below are representative examples introduced by the Merck Veterinary Manual owner-facing page and others; please keep in mind as well that they are hard to tell apart by appearance alone.
- Lipoma: a common benign lump made of fat, often described as soft and movable. It is said to be common in older, heavier dogs.
- Cyst: a lump in which a sac forms in the skin and fills with contents. The Merck page advises not to try to squeeze out and remove a keratin-filled skin cyst (see the explanation of epidermal cysts).
- Wart-like lump (papilloma): caused by papillomavirus and described as often going away on its own over time.
- Histiocytoma: a button-shaped lump common in young dogs, generally described as shrinking on its own within 2 to 3 months, but that applies only after testing has confirmed what kind of lump it is.
- Inflammation, abscess or injection-site reaction: swelling can occur from bacterial infection, an insect or tick bite site, or a reaction at an injection site.
- Tumors such as mast cell tumor: the Merck page introduces mast cell tumor as the most commonly seen malignant tumor in dogs and explains that it can look like a lipoma. There are also melanoma, carcinoma, sarcoma and others.
This list is not a tool for telling which lump is which. A lump you thought was like a lipoma because it was soft and movable can turn out to be something else on testing, and conversely, one that looks hard can be less worrying. So please use the list only to understand “how varied they are.”
| Category | Features generally described | What owners should know |
|---|---|---|
| Lipoma | Described as a soft, movable benign lump | Other lumps look similar, so confirmation is needed |
| Cyst | A lump in which a sac in the skin fills with contents | It is advised that squeezing can spread the contents into surrounding tissue and cause severe inflammation |
| Wart-like lump | Viral papillomas sometimes go away on their own | Check again if the appearance changes |
| Inflammation, abscess, injection-site reaction | May come with warmth and pain | For injection sites in cats, see the 3-2-1 rule |
| Tumors such as mast cell tumor | Can look like a benign lump | Cannot be told apart by appearance alone; confirm by cell testing |
Why can't a lump be told apart by touch, and what tests are done?
What a lump is ultimately depends on what cells are inside it. So in veterinary oncology, a test that directly examines the cells is described as the first step. The representative one is the fine-needle aspirate (a test in which cells are taken from the lump with a thin needle and examined under a microscope). The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that a veterinarian collects cells by fine-needle aspirate or obtains tissue by biopsy to evaluate it, and that diagnosis requires specialist knowledge and testing equipment. The WSAVA 2017 congress material (VIN) introduces the fine-needle aspirate as minimally invasive, relatively low in cost, quick, and helpful in telling tumors from inflammation.
If the fine-needle aspirate does not yield enough cells or the result is ambiguous, biopsy (a test that removes a part of the tissue) is described as the next step. The same source explains that small lesions can be sampled with an 8mm punch and larger lesions by an incisional biopsy of part of the lesion.
There is one more piece of guidance worth noting. A commentary in Today's Veterinary Practice explains that it does not recommend removing a skin lump of unknown identity whole as the first step. This is because malignant tumors often need a wide excision margin of 2–3cm, and operating without knowing what it is may fail to secure a sufficient margin. That is, the direction of the general guidance is “first confirm what it is and then decide the method,” rather than “if we take it off we'll find out.”
After the test results come back, whether to watch, remove or run other tests depends on the type of lump and the pet's age and health condition. Even if benign, removal can be considered if it causes problems, and conversely, the Merck page explains that a benign tumor without ulceration that does not interfere with daily life may need no treatment. This judgment is also the veterinarian's.
Where does the “pea size, one month” criterion come from?
The criterion owners encounter most is “See Something, Do Something” (meaning do not just pass by what you see, but act). According to the Today's Veterinary Practice commentary, this guidance is a cancer awareness campaign created by veterinary oncologist Dr. Sue Ettinger with input from other specialists and VCA animal hospitals. The core is that if a dog or cat has had a pea-sized (1cm) lump for one month, a fine-needle aspirate or biopsy should be done. The commentary adds that the guideline uses 1cm as its reference size but that smaller lumps can also be aspirated or biopsied.
This source points out that there is no specific guidance on when to aspirate a skin lump and when to watch it, so lumps can end up being watched too long. It also states that watching with the eyes alone is not enough, and this commentary and the WSAVA material explain that even experienced veterinarians and oncologists cannot tell whether a lump is malignant by looking at or touching it.
A few things need to be distinguished when reading this criterion. First, it is a suggestion for veterinary clinicians, and it has not been confirmed to be a legal obligation or a standard adopted by every professional society. This article conveys only the content of the commentary and congress material that were opened and checked. Second, “one month” is not a safe line. If there are other warning signs, such as rapid growth or bleeding, it is better to be examined without waiting out the month. Third, if you are anxious before a month has passed, you may bring it in earlier. It is safer to read this criterion not as permission to “wait until then” but as a suggestion to avoid putting off testing.
What kinds of lumps are reported in Korea?
Korean cases show that lumps are not rare. A study published by a research team at the Jeju National University College of Veterinary Medicine in the Korean Journal of Veterinary Research, 2019, vol. 59 no. 4, histopathologically analyzed 478 feline biopsy specimens sent by veterinarians nationwide over 72 months, from January 2013 to December 2018. According to the abstract, 232 of them (48.54%) were skin masses, and of the 232 skin masses, 171 (73.71%) were neoplastic and 61 (26.29%) were non-neoplastic. Among the tumors, mast cell tumor was the most common at 60.23%, followed by lipoma at 5.85%, basal cell carcinoma at 4.68% and fibrosarcoma at 4.68%, and the head was the most common site at 43.27%.
Please take care in how you read these numbers. These figures are the distribution among cats whose biopsy specimens were sent for pathology examination. They gather cases already judged to need testing, so they do not mean that this proportion of lumps felt at home are tumors. Also, this study was about cats, so it cannot be applied to dogs as is, and all that can be conveyed is that the researchers concluded that skin tumors are the most common tumors in cats and that mast cell tumor is the most common skin tumor.
There is also a practical point in the Korean setting that owners should know. As more pets live indoors, owners spend more time petting the body, and lumps are often found during bathing or grooming. A groomer or a neighbor may point out a lump first, but do not judge from their words alone; it is better to have it checked at an animal hospital. This is only a general explanation, and Korean regional statistics have not been confirmed.
Is there a separate criterion for lumps at injection sites in cats?
For cats, there is guidance to look separately at when a lump forms where an injection was given. Most are a temporary inflammatory reaction after the injection, but in rare cases an injection-site sarcoma (a soft-tissue tumor arising at the injection site) can develop. The guideline on injection-site sarcoma from the Advisory Board on Cat Diseases (ABCD) in Europe introduces the “3-2-1 rule” for sorting this out. It advises that work-up including tissue testing is justified if a lump at a vaccination site is still there 3 months after vaccination, is larger than 2cm in diameter, or is still growing 1 month after vaccination. The guideline also explains that when a lump is found in the skin of a cat, tests for diagnosis are generally needed.
The figures in the same guideline are also worth noting. US and Canadian data (1998–2000) are said to have reported 0.3 injection-site sarcomas and 11.8 post-vaccination inflammatory reactions per 10,000 vaccinations. This is context showing that most lumps at vaccination sites are inflammatory reactions, but the figures are reported to differ greatly by country and survey method, so they should not be read as numbers showing the risk in Korea.
What owners need to do is simple. If a lump is felt after vaccination, write down the date of vaccination and the part of the body, check whether the 3-2-1 rule applies, and tell the hospital. The vaccination schedule and management of the vaccination site themselves are not the subject of this article, and for the feline vaccination schedule you can refer to a separate article (고양이 예방접종 일정). It must not lead to the conclusion that vaccination should be avoided, and decisions related to vaccination should also be discussed with the attending veterinarian.
What should I record at home, and what should I not do?
The most useful thing you can do at home when you find a lump is to record it. The WSAVA 2017 material introduces having owners check the body once a month and make a “body map” noting the location, size and test result of each lump. It also stresses that the veterinarian should measure and record lumps to track changes.
- Photos: take them at the same angle and lighting, placed next to a ruler or a coin so the size can be gauged. Keep the date.
- Size: measure width and length with a ruler and record them. If it is hard to measure exactly, keep a photo as well.
- Body map: mark the location of the lump on a drawing or photo of the pet's body and write the date it was first found.
- Changes: note color, warmth, oozing, hair loss, licking or scratching behavior, and signs of pain.
There are also things not to do. The Merck page advises not to try to squeeze out and remove a keratin-filled skin cyst (see the explanation of epidermal cysts) and explains that the contents can spread into surrounding tissue and cause severe inflammation. It is better not to squeeze or pick at lumps that are not cysts either. A pet may lick or scratch a lump and cause infection, so how to prevent this is advised to be discussed with a veterinarian. Applying human ointment or antiseptic on your own is also not recommended.
Records are not a tool for deciding whether to go to the hospital. Records are only material that helps the veterinarian grasp changes quickly. If any of the warning signs below are present, get examined first rather than piling up more records.
| Item | Method | How it helps when taking it to the hospital |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Mark it on the body map and write the date it was first found | Tell each one's changes apart when there are several |
| Size | Measure width and length with a ruler, repeat in the same way | Gauge the speed of growth |
| Photo | Same angle, with a ruler, keep the date | The veterinarian can compare changes by eye |
| Condition | Note color, warmth, oozing, pain response | Grasp possible inflammation or urgent changes |
| Whole body | Write down changes in appetite, weight and energy | Changes that seem unrelated to the lump are also clues |
In these cases, should I go to the hospital without waiting?
What matters more than the presence of a lump is how the lump changes. The warning signs described by authoritative sources are summarized as follows. If even one item applies, do not watch for several days; contact a veterinarian right away and get examined.
- It grows, changes in appearance or makes the animal uncomfortable: the Today's Veterinary Practice commentary advises evaluating a lump that grows, changes in appearance or makes the animal uncomfortable.
- It bleeds or ulcerates: in its explanation of anal sac gland tumors, the Merck page explains that large tumors commonly ulcerate and bleed, and a lump of any type that bleeds or is open is safer not to put off.
- A lump at a cat's injection site meets the 3-2-1 rule.
- It is around the nails or in the mouth: the Merck page explains that squamous cell carcinoma under a nail can cause limping, nail deformity, infection and nail loss, and that severe warts on the lining of the mouth can make chewing and swallowing difficult.
Even if there are no such signs and the lump is small and unchanged, if you have just found it, it is recommended to show it to a veterinarian once. This also matches the direction of the “pea size, one month” guidance seen earlier. When you go for a regular health checkup, tell them in advance that there is a lump. The timing and items of health checkups are covered in the article on health checkups by age.
Older pets get new lumps more often, so the habit of petting the body helps. However, please do not dismiss a lump as merely a sign of aging just because the pet is old. At the examination, show the recorded photos and body map and explain since when it has been there and how it has changed, which makes it easier for the veterinarian to judge.
What are common misunderstandings about lumps?
First, the thought that “it doesn't hurt, so it's fine.” A lump that does not hurt can also be a tumor. Pain is only one of the warning signs and is not proof of safety.
Second, the thought that “it's small, so it's fine.” The guidance seen earlier suggests testing even a small 1cm lump if it has been there a month. Even if small, what it is cannot be known from the outside.
Third, the saying that “everyone gets them when they get old.” It is true that there are common benign lumps such as lipomas, but common is not the same as safe. Malignant lumps can arise in the same age range too, so confirmation is needed.
Fourth, the judgment that “it feels soft, so it's a lipoma.” As the Merck page says, a malignant mast cell tumor can look like a lipoma.
Fifth, the worry that “poking it with a needle will spread it.” The WSAVA material and the Today's Veterinary Practice commentary that this article checked introduce the fine-needle aspirate as a minimally invasive first-step test. The risks and benefits of testing are for the veterinarian to explain for the individual situation, so ask if you are worried.
Sixth, the thought that “I can just squeeze it out at home or put medicine on it.” The Merck page advises not to try to squeeze out and remove a keratin-filled skin cyst (see the explanation of epidermal cysts) and explains that the contents can spread and cause severe inflammation.
Frequently asked questions
Q I can feel a lump. Is it all right to watch it for a few days before going to the hospital?
Waiting and watching for a few days is not recommended. Record the location, size and date with photos, but that record is material to show the veterinarian, not a reason to wait. Contact a veterinarian and ask when it should be shown. There is a suggestion to do a fine-needle aspirate or biopsy if a 1cm lump has been there for a month, and this does not mean it is all right to wait a month. If it grows, changes in appearance, makes the animal uncomfortable, or there is bleeding or ulceration, get examined right away without waiting.
Q Can I tell whether a lump is benign or malignant by feeling it?
No. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that a malignant mast cell tumor can look like a lipoma, and the Today's Veterinary Practice commentary also states that even experienced veterinarians cannot tell whether a lump is malignant by looking at or touching it. A veterinarian judges by cell testing and similar methods.
Q What kind of test is a fine-needle aspirate?
It is a test in which cells are taken from the lump with a thin needle and examined under a microscope. The WSAVA 2017 material (VIN) explains that it is minimally invasive and quick and helps tell tumors from inflammation, but that the result is sometimes not sufficient for a diagnosis. In that case, biopsy is described as the next step.
Q The lump has burst and is oozing. Is it all right to squeeze it?
It is better not to squeeze or pick at it. The Merck page advises that squeezing a keratin-filled skin cyst (see the explanation of epidermal cysts) can spread the contents into surrounding tissue and cause severe inflammation. Talk to a veterinarian about how to stop the animal from licking it and about treatment.
Q My cat's injection site has swollen up. When should it be tested?
The 3-2-1 rule in the guideline of the Advisory Board on Cat Diseases (ABCD) in Europe advises that work-up including tissue testing is needed if a lump after vaccination is still there after 3 months, exceeds 2cm in diameter, or is still growing after 1 month. Write down the date and site of the vaccination and tell the veterinarian.
Q Isn't a lump on an older pet just aging?
Lumps do appear more often with age, but that does not mean they can all be regarded as benign lumps from aging. Even if there are common lumps such as lipomas, a lump that is new or changing needs to be checked. If you find a new lump, show it to a veterinarian.
Q How should I photograph a lump?
Take photos at the same angle and lighting, with a ruler next to the lump so the size can be gauged, and keep the date. The WSAVA material introduces making a body map containing location, size and test results.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article is an editorial draft and has not completed professional veterinary review. It organizes the general guidance of the overseas sources and Korean journal abstract that were opened and checked, does not replace care for an individual pet, and does not judge the identity, treatment or prognosis of a lump. The “pea size, one month” guidance is a suggestion for clinicians and has not been confirmed as a standard adopted by every professional society. The Korean figures are limited to the abstract of one study of feline biopsy specimens, cannot be applied to dogs, and are not the proportion among all lumps felt at home. The criteria vary with the location of the lump and the condition of the animal, so be sure to talk to a veterinarian.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- Tumors of the Skin in Dogs (Dog Owners) ↗
Used as the basis for the common types of skin lumps, the point that diagnosis cannot be made from appearance alone, fine-needle aspirate and biopsy, and the guidance not to squeeze.
- Veterinary Oncology: What to Do With Lumps and Bumps on Dogs and Cats ↗
Used as the basis for the See Something, Do Something criterion (pea size 1cm, one month), the explanation that a lump cannot be told by touch, and the guidance not to remove a lump of unknown identity first.
- A Practical Approach to Lumps and Bumps (WSAVA 2017 Congress) ↗
Used as the basis for the order of fine-needle aspirate and biopsy, body map recording, and the guidance for monthly owner checks.
- GUIDELINE for Feline Injection-Site Sarcoma ↗
Used as the basis for the 3-2-1 rule for lumps at feline injection sites and the reported figures for post-vaccination inflammatory reactions and injection-site sarcoma.
- A retrospective study of feline cutaneous tumors in Korea from 2013 to 2018 ↗
Used as the basis for conveying, as stated in the abstract, the share of skin masses among 478 Korean feline biopsies and the distribution by tumor type.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
