Skip to content
Grochi · Neutral pet information from South Korea · English edition한국어
Grochi.English edition
Food & nutrition

How do you balance the nutrition in home-made dog food (cooked or natural diets)?

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. This page is an English translation of the Korean edition as checked on 2026-11-19. If the two differ, the Korean edition is the reference. 한국어판 (Korean edition)

How do you balance the nutrition in home-made dog food (cooked or natural diets)?
Short answer

A home-cooked recipe is not balanced just because the ingredients are good. The advised approach is to follow a recipe designed by a veterinary nutrition specialist exactly as measured, without changing it, and to have regular check-ups.

Key takeaways

  • Even with fresh ingredients, home-made dog food easily gets out of balance in calcium, minerals and vitamins, so feeding a generic recipe from the internet or a book for a long period is not recommended.
  • Overseas veterinary sources advise as the basic approach using a recipe designed for the dog's age, weight and health condition by a board-certified veterinary nutritionist (such as ACVN in the US and ECVCN in Europe), and having check-ups at set intervals.
  • When ingredients are dropped or swapped at will and amounts are adjusted by eye, and this builds up, the nutritional balance breaks down over time; this is called recipe drift.
  • Grapes, raisins, onions, garlic, xylitol, chocolate, macadamia nuts and the like can be dangerous to dogs even in small amounts, so they should be left out of home-cooked ingredients, and if a dog has eaten them, note the amount and contact an animal hospital right away.
  • In Korea no public system that verifies the nutritional balance of home-cooked recipes has been identified, so consulting a veterinarian or a veterinary nutrition specialist is the most realistic safeguard.

Can home-made food be nutritionally balanced?

It can be, but it is not easy. Home-made dog food, commonly called a cooked or natural diet, gives an impression of freshness because the owner chooses the ingredients directly. However, for a dog to eat it every day without problems, many essential nutrients such as protein, fat, calcium, phosphorus, zinc, iron and vitamins must be in set proportions to one another. This balance is a separate matter from the freshness or quality of the ingredients.

Overseas veterinary sources consistently advise two things. First, to feed home-cooked food, it is better to use a recipe designed by a veterinary nutrition specialist. Second, that recipe must be followed as it is, without changing the ingredients or amounts. A guide from VCA, a US animal hospital network, explains that simply mixing meat, grains and vegetables, or giving leftover food, can lead to nutritional imbalance over time.

This article does not give recipes or supplement doses. Needs vary with a dog's age, weight, activity level and illnesses, so numbers in a general article can actually be dangerous. Instead, it organizes why the balance breaks, what to check, and whom to consult. The risks and benefits of raw feeding (feeding raw meat) are covered in a separate article, so only one line is mentioned here. Raw feeding carries the additional problem of bacterial contamination, and, as with cooked food, the nutritional balance still has to be right.

How balanced are publicly available recipes?

A representative study that investigated this question directly is a 2013 paper by researchers at the University of California, Davis School of Veterinary Medicine. It is “Evaluation of recipes of home-prepared maintenance diets for dogs,” published by Stockman et al. in the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association (JAVMA) volume 242, issue 11, and it is a study that evaluated recipes for home-prepared maintenance diets. In writing this article, I confirmed the PubMed bibliographic information, but that PubMed record does not carry an abstract, so I could not check the original figures directly, and the figures below are what a veterinary commentary summarizing the study (SkeptVet blog, May 2013) reports. According to the commentary, 200 recipes were evaluated, 129 of them written by veterinarians, and only 5 recipes could be interpreted as having sufficient levels of all essential nutrients by US National Research Council (NRC) standards. The same commentary reports that 9 recipes met AAFCO nutrient standards, and that all 4 recipes written by board-certified veterinary nutritionists were complete.

What this result says is simple. A recipe written by a veterinarian is not automatically balanced, and recipes from board-certified veterinary nutritionists, who specialize in nutrition design, were the most reliable. However, this study uses 2013 data, and the comments on the commentary introduce criticisms that only some of the diets were actually analyzed, about the authors' interests, and that it used a calculation method rather than feeding trials, so it is better to understand it as a broad direction rather than each individual number.

Other surveys point in a similar direction. According to Veterinary Practice News, a 2012 study that analyzed 67 recipes for dogs and cats with kidney disease found that none met all NRC recommended amounts. In a 2021 study of 100 online recipes (75 for dogs, 25 for cats), all diets without supplements were low in calcium, and zinc deficiency was also common. The same article reports that in a 2025 analysis by the Dog Aging Project, about 6% of home-prepared dog diets were potentially nutritionally complete. These numbers differ in subjects and criteria from study to study, so they cannot be compared directly with one another, and the result of one overseas study cannot be applied as it is to dogs in Korea.

Which nutrients are often lacking?

The one the sources name first is calcium. According to what veterinary trade media summarize, home-cooked food without a concentrated calcium source is generally low in calcium. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that a meat-based diet, or a diet of only hamburger and rice, can cause calcium deficiency and nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism. Conversely, in fast-growing large-breed puppies, too much calcium can also cause problems in bone growth, so it is not safe for an owner to add a calcium product at will.

Next come minerals and vitamins. The VCA guide names calcium, phosphorus, zinc, magnesium and iron as the most common imbalances in home-prepared diets. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that feeding only liver can cause an excess of vitamin A, and that cases of rickets from vitamin D deficiency mostly appear in animals fed home-cooked food without supplementation. It also points out that raw egg white contains avidin, which binds biotin.

A point worth noting here is that both deficiency and excess are problems. The Merck Veterinary Manual advises avoiding indiscriminate mineral supplementation, because eating too much of one mineral can reduce the absorption of other minerals. So rather than adding supplements at will because something seems lacking, the advised approach is to use specific vitamin and mineral supplements calculated by a specialist, exactly as directed. Which supplement to use and how much is not covered in this article.

Whom should I consult, and how is a recipe designed?

The first method that overseas veterinary sources advise is a board-certified veterinary nutritionist. The VCA guide explains that a veterinarian may recommend consulting a specialist qualified by organizations such as ACVIM, ECVCN and CAVN. An experienced nutrition specialist reviews the dog's medical records, asks the owner about the feeding history, and uses a calculation program to create a recipe with ingredient substitutions and portions suited to that individual. The written report contains the recipe, the daily amount and the number of feedings, and in many cases supplements and a re-check schedule are included. It also tells you that a consultation fee and a recipe fee are often charged separately.

According to what Veterinary Practice News summarizes, most home-prepared diets are not balanced unless prescribed by a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, checking a full nutritional analysis is the only way to confirm that a diet is complete and balanced, and home-prepared diets for dogs with illnesses should be supervised by a veterinarian or a veterinary nutrition specialist. The World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) Global Nutrition Committee runs a toolkit for veterinary professionals and owners, but the page introducing this toolkit did not directly explain how to evaluate a home-cooked recipe. Therefore, what official position WSAVA takes on home-cooked food could not be confirmed for this article, and the content above was confirmed from VCA, Veterinary Practice News and the Merck Veterinary Manual.

Regular check-ups are also designed in together. The VCA guide advises finding problems early with an exam, blood tests and urine tests at about 6-month intervals. This is because even if a recipe looks appropriate at first, needs change with the dog's growth, aging and illness. All treats and supplements currently being fed must also be told to the veterinarian.

Why does a recipe drift out of balance over time even when it is followed?

A common cause of broken nutritional balance is recipe drift. Veterinary Practice News calls an owner changing or leaving out ingredients, ratios or supplements over time recipe drift, and explains that it is the most common finding among owners feeding home-prepared recipes. It says small changes may have little effect on overall nutrient intake, but some omissions or changes can greatly lower the nutritional quality of the diet.

There are also problems with measuring and substitution. Typical examples are scooping ingredients in by eye, swapping in other meat or vegetables because the original is hard to get, or leaving out a supplement because the dog has grown tired of it. The VCA guide explains that leaving out or swapping ingredients can break the nutritional balance, and that the problem is especially large in growing puppies and dogs that need a special diet. Conversely, it also points out that sticking to one recipe for a long time can prolong an imbalance if that recipe turns out to be deficient.

That said, a recipe in which ingredients can be changed at will is not a good one. Veterinary Practice News explains that a recipe that is open-ended, with no substitution rules, is hard to judge for adequacy. Feeding a variety may prevent some deficiencies, but it can also leave gaps in nutrient intake. It also points out that when a recipe is complicated, owners can tire and, over time, cut the recipe down. So when a substitution is needed, it is safer to ask the specialist who designed the recipe in advance which substitutions are permitted.

Which foods are dangerous to dogs?

When making home-cooked food, you must avoid not only nutritional problems but also toxic ingredients. According to guidance from the US ASPCA, grapes and raisins are associated with kidney damage, and onions, garlic and chives can cause gastrointestinal irritation and anemia through damage to red blood cells. Xylitol, found in gum, candy, baked goods and toothpaste, can cause low blood sugar and liver damage, and the methylxanthines in chocolate and coffee can cause vomiting, tremors, seizures and arrhythmia, with cocoa powder and baking chocolate being especially dangerous. Macadamia nuts can cause lethargy, vomiting, tremors and raised body temperature.

Beyond these, alcohol, raw yeast dough that is still rising, high-fat nuts and excessive salt are also advised as dangerous foods. The same standard applies when sharing food people eat. You need to check whether such ingredients are in the recipe and whether they get mixed in as treats or seasoning.

The ASPCA's guidance is that if you suspect a dog has eaten a dangerous food, you should note the amount eaten and contact an animal hospital or an animal poison control center right away. In some cases you must not wait for symptoms to appear. For example, xylitol is described as able to start with vomiting, lethargy and loss of coordination and progress to seizures, with liver damage appearing within 12 to 24 hours.

What is the situation in Korea?

A public system that verifies or certifies the nutritional balance of home-cooked recipes in Korea could not be confirmed in this survey. The Korean system is being developed mainly around commercial feed. According to a press explanatory release from the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA), the current Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) divides pet feed into single-ingredient feed (단미사료), complementary feed (보조사료) and compound feed (배합사료), and, based on the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) revised in September 2025, plans from September 2028 to manage it divided into types such as pet complete feed (반려동물완전사료) and other pet feed (반려동물기타사료). Pet complete feed refers to feed whose nutrient composition is built to meet all the nutrient requirements of each growth stage without separate nutritional supplementation.

The National Institute of Animal Science (NIAS) of the Rural Development Administration (RDA) introduced nutrient standards for dog and cat feed in a policy briefing on October 23, 2024. As a guideline presenting minimum recommended levels of essential nutrients, it contains recommended levels for 38 nutrients for adult dogs and 40 for puppies and breeding bitches; it was designed mainly for the feed industry to use in labeling complete feed, and it explained that the standards referred to were those of the US and Europe. No mention of home-made food could be confirmed in this briefing, so there is no basis to say that this standard can be used as it is to evaluate home-cooked recipes.

In sum, in Korea too, the nutritional balance of home-cooked food is not an area guaranteed by law and system, but an area that the owner and veterinarian check together. Where veterinary nutrition consultation can be obtained at animal hospitals in Korea differs from hospital to hospital, so please first ask your regular veterinarian.

What should owners check?

If you are starting home-cooked food or already feeding it, you can go through the items below. Each item organizes the guidance of the sources introduced earlier from the owner's perspective, and it presumes discussion with a veterinarian. If even one item cannot be confirmed, it is better to ask your regular veterinarian about that part first.

It helps in particular to keep a record of the recipe's source and designer. If you write down the date you received the recipe, the specialist who designed it and the names of the supplements designated for use with it, it is easier for the veterinarian to review the diet later if the dog's condition changes. Even when you feel like changing an ingredient because the dog has grown tired of it, the habit of not changing it right away but asking the specialist who designed it first is the simplest way to prevent recipe drift.

Checklist for owners feeding home-cooked food
What to checkWhy
Who designed the recipeA study commentary says recipes designed by board-certified veterinary nutritionists were the most reliable, and a recipe being written by a veterinarian does not ensure that it is balanced.
Whether it was checked with a nutrition calculation programVeterinary Practice News explains that checking a full nutritional analysis is the only way to know a diet is complete and balanced.
Whether the ingredients and amounts were left unchangedDropping and substituting at will and measuring by eye are the causes of recipe drift.
Whether calcium and vitamin and mineral supplementation is included in the designHome-cooked food without a concentrated calcium source tends to be low in calcium, and without supplements designated by a specialist, trace nutrients can go out of balance.
Whether dangerous foods have been mixed inGrapes, onions, garlic, xylitol, chocolate, macadamia nuts and the like can be a problem even in small amounts.
Whether regular exams and tests are being doneVCA advises an exam and blood and urine tests at about 6-month intervals.
Whether the dog is growing, senior or has an illnessNeeds differ and the effects of problems are larger, so design and management by a specialist are essential.

What are common misunderstandings, and when should I go to the hospital?

There are a few common misunderstandings. First, the idea that feeding a variety of fresh ingredients naturally balances the diet. As seen earlier, variety can fill some deficiencies but can also create new ones, and a diet without a concentrated calcium source is generally low in calcium. Second, the idea that adding supplements fills the gaps. The Merck Veterinary Manual advises that indiscriminate mineral supplementation creates imbalance instead. Third, the idea that a recipe written by a veterinarian is safe. In the commentary on the Stockman study, a considerable number of recipes written by veterinarians were also deficient. Fourth, the idea that raw feeding has no balance problem. Raw feeding only adds the risk of bacterial contamination while the balance problem stays the same, and please refer to the separate article for details.

In the following cases, it is advisable to go to an animal hospital and tell them the feeding history.

  • When vomiting or diarrhea repeats, or weight drops or rises noticeably
  • When the coat becomes dull and sheds, or the skin condition worsens
  • When the gait is abnormal or the dog limps and a bone or joint problem is suspected, especially in a growing puppy
  • When the dog may have eaten grapes, onions, garlic, xylitol, chocolate or the like, go right away without waiting for symptoms
  • When a diagnosis requiring dietary management has been given, such as kidney, liver or pancreatic disease

The most important first step is not to hide from the veterinarian the fact that you are feeding home-cooked food, and to tell them the recipe and the supplements being used.

Frequently asked questions

Q Is it all right to follow a dog home-cooking recipe from the internet or a book exactly?

It is not recommended. According to the commentary summarizing the 2013 study by Stockman et al., of 200 publicly available recipes evaluated, only 5 had sufficient levels of all essential nutrients by NRC standards. Using a recipe designed by a board-certified veterinary nutritionist is what is advised.

Q If I add supplements to home-cooked food, will it be balanced?

Adding them at will is not recommended. The Merck Veterinary Manual advises that indiscriminate mineral supplementation can cause imbalance, and VCA explains that vitamin and mineral supplements designated by a specialist should be included in the design.

Q Is it all right to swap the recipe's ingredients for others?

Before swapping, check with the specialist who designed it whether the substitution is permitted. VCA advises that leaving out or swapping ingredients can break the nutritional balance, and that the problem is especially large in growing puppies.

Q What if feeding only home-cooked food feels like too much of a burden?

Home-cooked food is a heavy burden because the design and measurements must be kept. This article does not recommend a particular feeding method, so please decide with your regular veterinarian which feeding method suits the dog.

Q My dog ate just a little grape or onion. Will it be all right?

The ASPCA advises that grapes and raisins are associated with kidney damage, and onions and garlic with damage to red blood cells, and says that if a dog has eaten them, note the amount and contact a veterinarian or poison control center. Do not assume it is fine; ask an animal hospital.

Q Is there a system in Korea that verifies home-cooked recipes?

It could not be confirmed in this survey. The Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs plans to manage feed types such as pet complete feed from September 2028, but this is a system for commercial feed, not one that verifies home-cooked recipes.

Limits and scope of this guide

This article is general information and does not give recipes or supplement doses. For the Stockman study, the PubMed record has no abstract, so the original figures could not be checked and the secondary commentary's figures were cited, and the results of overseas studies cannot be applied as they are to dogs in Korea. WSAVA's official position on home-cooked food and the current state of veterinary nutrition consultation in Korea could not be confirmed. Discuss an individual dog's diet with a veterinarian.

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.

Sources and check dates

  1. Evaluation of recipes of home-prepared maintenance diets for dogs (Stockman et al., JAVMA 2013;242(11):1500-5) ↗

    Used as the basis for the study's bibliographic information (authors, affiliation, journal, year). This PubMed record has no abstract, so the figures could not be checked against it.

  2. Evidence Update - Homemade Diet Recipes for Your Pet are Unreliable ↗

    Used as the basis for the summary of the Stockman study's results, such as 200 recipes, 5 meeting NRC standards and 4 specialist recipes being complete (secondary commentary).

  3. Home-prepared diets for pets (집에서 만든 반려동물 식단) ↗

    Used as the basis for the commonly imbalanced nutrients, consulting a specialist, caution about changing ingredients, and regular check-up guidance.

  4. Home-prepared diets: good intentions, good nutrition? ↗

    Used as the basis for recipe drift, calcium deficiency, and the introduction of the 2012, 2021 and 2025 studies.

  5. Nutritional Requirements and Related Diseases of Small Animals ↗

    Used as the basis for calcium and vitamin problems and the caution against indiscriminate mineral supplementation.

  6. People Foods to Avoid Feeding Your Pets ↗

    Used as the basis for guidance on foods dangerous to dogs, such as grapes, onions, xylitol and chocolate.

  7. Press explanatory release on pet feed management (반려동물 사료 관리 관련 보도설명자료) ↗

    Used as the basis for the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) revised in September 2025 and the plan to manage feed types from September 2028.

  8. Policy briefing on nutrient standards for dog and cat feed (2024-10-23) (개·고양이 사료 영양표준 정책브리핑(2024-10-23)) ↗

    Used as the basis for the nature of the Korean nutrient standards, the number of nutrients, and the standards referred to.

Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.

This guide relies on 2 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.