The short answer: why is it held up at quarantine?
The main reason pet food and treats arriving in Korea through overseas direct purchase or a purchasing agent are stopped at quarantine is not a problem with the quality of the food, but that the product could be a route for livestock infectious diseases to enter. DailyVet (데일리벳) reported in June 2016 that if feed contains animal-derived ingredients such as meat, processed meat products or ingredients related to bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), import is prohibited or the product is subject to disposal or return to the sender, unless there is a quarantine certificate issued by the exporting country's government.
The problem is that it is hard for ordinary consumers to obtain this certificate when ordering individually. The same report said that individuals find it difficult to obtain a certificate when buying directly from overseas, so much feed does not clear customs. That a product is normally sold as pet food and that it can be brought into Korea are two separate facts.
Another point that is easy to confuse is that quarantine and the feed labeling system are different procedures. Quarantine is what the Animal and Plant Quarantine Agency (APQA) examines to prevent livestock diseases from entering, while the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) requires importers to file a report, register the ingredients and label in Korean. Passing one does not mean passing the other.
This article does not judge which products are allowed and which are not. Based on the public materials that could be confirmed, it explains the reasons and the structure, and for points that require a judgment it points you to an inquiry to the APQA.
What is quarantine trying to prevent?
According to the DailyVet (데일리벳) report, concern was raised that if more feed enters through overseas direct purchase without a quarantine report, livestock infectious diseases such as foot-and-mouth disease or highly pathogenic avian influenza could enter Korea (DailyVet, article of June 2, 2016). Feed is not food that people eat, so it is easy to feel it is safe, but animal-derived ingredients are treated as materials that can carry pathogens.
So quarantine does not look at whether a product is good or bad for the body; it looks at which country the ingredients came from, whether animal-derived components are included, and whether the exporting country's government issued a certificate. This is why the result can differ depending on the ingredient composition even for products of the same brand.
A DailyVet (데일리벳) article of December 18, 2018 reported that a considerable share of pet food is subject to quarantine and cannot be brought in without a quarantine certificate. The same article said that treats, nutritional supplements and supplements registered as feed are subject to the same rules. In other words, not only feed but also products that look like treats or nutritional supplements can be covered.
The article also reported that it advised that processed meat products such as canned beef, ham, sausage and jerky are designated quarantine articles. The legal scope of designated quarantine articles is explained in the Korean system section below, and whether an individual product falls under it must be confirmed with the APQA.
The June 2016 article also has 2014 Incheon Airport express cargo statistics. Of 5,605 cases (11.39 tons) of pet food, 2,289 cases (2.96 tons), or 40.8 percent, failed, and feed accounted for about 87 percent of the 2,630 failed overseas direct-purchase express cargo cases. These are data from one airport in 2014 and are not current figures.
How does Korea manage feed imports?
The Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) defines the business of importing and selling feed as the import business (Article 2) and calls the person who does it an importer. Importers must register the type, ingredients and ingredient amounts of the feed with the Mayor or Provincial Governor (Article 12), and must label the container or packaging with the registered ingredient details, sell-by date, precautions for use and so on (Article 13).
There is also a separate import report. Article 19, paragraph 1 requires an importer who wants to import feed designated by notice of the Minister of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs to file a report under the Ordinance of the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs. Article 14, paragraph 1 prohibits manufacturing, importing or selling anything that was imported without ingredient registration or without an import report.
Article 20 of the Enforcement Rule provides that an importer who wants to file an import report must submit to the reporting organization, before customs clearance, the feed import report together with a copy of the ingredient registration certificate, packaging labeled in Korean or an explanatory document with the contents in Korean, a commercial invoice and so on. The Korean labeling must follow the labeling items and methods in Appendix 4 of the Enforcement Rule.
Appendix 4 lists as labeling items for compound feed the ingredient registration number, the name and form of the feed, the guaranteed analysis (registered), the names of the ingredients used, precautions, purpose, actual weight, the manufacture (import) date and sell-by date, the name and address of the manufacturer (importer), and repackaging details.
In summary, a formally imported product comes in through the importer's ingredient registration, import report and Korean labeling. A product that an individual orders directly from an overseas shopping mall does not go through this route, so it can run into these requirements. How individual direct purchase is treated under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) could not be confirmed in this article.
The basis on the quarantine side is in the Act on the Prevention of Contagious Animal Diseases (가축전염병 예방법). Article 31 calls the articles subject to import and export quarantine designated quarantine articles, and sets their scope as animals and their carcasses, animal products such as bones, flesh, hides, eggs and hair, and feed and feed ingredients that may spread the pathogens of livestock infectious diseases, while leaving the specific articles to be set by an Ordinance of the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs.
Article 31, paragraph 1 of the Enforcement Rule lists as designated quarantine articles dogs and cats (item 2), processed meat products such as ham, sausage and bacon that have not been sterilized (item 9), animal flesh, bones, offal, fat, meat and bone meal and the like that have not been processed or sterilized (item 10), and feed and feed ingredients that the head of the APQA announces may spread pathogens (item 13). Paragraph 2 of the same article says that the head of the APQA sets by notice the scope, standards and confirmation methods for the sterilization, pasteurization and processing referred to in items 9, 10 and 13. The text of this notice was not opened while writing this article, so which degree of processing exempts a product from coverage is not explained here, and you are directed to ask the APQA.
For ingredient registration numbers and labeling in general, topics covered in other articles, see the articles label-feed-registration-number and korea-pet-food-label-law.
How do purchasing agents differ from overseas direct purchase?
Overseas direct purchase is when a consumer orders directly from an overseas shopping mall, and a purchasing agent is when a seller in Korea buys an overseas product on the consumer's behalf and passes it on. In both cases the goods come into Korea from overseas, and from the quarantine point of view what matters is where and from what ingredients the product was made.
According to the 2018 DailyVet (데일리벳) report, the APQA disclosed a list of 364 products that are sold on shopping sites in Korea and abroad but are handled as failing quarantine. This list reflects that time and may differ from the list today.
Even if the sales page of a purchasing-agent product says it is on sale in Korea, that may not mean it has passed quarantine. Check whether the sales page says if it is a formally imported product and whether it is a product subject to a feed import report, and if it is unclear, ask the seller or the APQA.
A specific list of quarantine-target ingredients provided by the APQA could not be confirmed in this article, so it is not introduced here, and product-specific checks are referred to an inquiry to the APQA.
The 2016 report said that most overseas direct-purchase feed fails quarantine and is disposed of or returned to the country of origin. From the consumer's point of view, the cost risk is that after payment the product can be returned or disposed of at the customs stage.
What do the United States and the EU do?
Korea is not the only place that sets conditions from an animal disease perspective on bringing in feed. The US FDA explains that when importing pet food, prior notice must be given for each import, the production facility must be registered with the FDA, and all ingredients must be approved food additives, GRAS, or defined in an AAFCO official publication.
The same FDA guidance explains that if a product contains animal-derived materials (meat, rendered materials, dairy and so on) and comes from a country with livestock diseases not present in the United States, a Veterinary Services permit from the US Department of Agriculture's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) is generally needed. This permit condition was confirmed through the FDA guidance, and the general requirements for pet food on APHIS's own pages could not be confirmed.
The EU's guidance on personal imports (Your Europe) says that travelers coming from non-EU countries are not allowed to bring in meat or dairy products, and that undeclared meat or dairy products are seized and destroyed and can lead to fines or criminal prosecution. As an exception, pet food for health reasons is limited to 2 kilograms or less, for a pet traveling with the person, in a state that does not need refrigeration, in branded packaging sold directly to consumers, and in unopened packaging unless it is in use.
This EU condition is guidance on baggage that travelers carry, and whether the same conditions apply as they are to feed sent from Korea to the EU by post or courier could not be confirmed. Also, this guidance is an EU rule for entry into the EU and has no bearing on whether Korea has an exception for small quantities.
All three countries are alike in treating feed containing animal-derived ingredients as a subject of disease control, but the specific documents and exceptions differ from country to country. Whether a small quantity is acceptable in Korea cannot be stated definitively on the basis of this article, so you must ask the APQA.
What owners should check before buying an overseas product
Checking the items below one by one before ordering an overseas product can reduce the risk of return or disposal. If the result of a check is unclear, the safer course is to put off the purchase and ask the APQA.
- Check whether the ingredient list contains animal-derived ingredients such as meat, processed meat products or animal by-products.
- Remember that treats, nutritional supplements and supplements registered as feed can also be subject to the same quarantine rules (DailyVet 2018 report).
- Ask the seller whether the phrase "on sale in Korea" on the sales page means formal import.
- Check whether the product's name is on the list of failed products published by the APQA. The date of the list may be old.
- If it is a formally imported product, look for packaging labeled in Korean and an ingredient registration number (Enforcement Rule, Appendix 4).
- Before buying, check who bears the refund and costs in case of return or disposal.
| Item to check | Where to check | If it is unclear |
|---|---|---|
| Whether animal-derived ingredients are included | The product's ingredient list | Ask the APQA |
| Whether it is subject to quarantine | APQA guidance and the failed-product list | Ask the APQA |
| Whether it is formally imported | Seller's guidance, packaging labeled in Korean | Ask the seller and the department in charge at the city or provincial government |
| Whether it counts as a treat or nutritional supplement | Product classification and ingredient composition | Ask the APQA |
| Cost on return or disposal | The seller's terms | Put off the purchase and ask the seller |
Common misconceptions
You often hear that a small quantity is fine, but the materials opened for this article could not confirm whether there is an exception for small quantities. Whether an exception exists, and if so under what conditions, must be asked of the APQA directly, and it cannot be assumed safe just because the quantity is small.
The idea that a famous brand is fine is also weakly founded. According to the 2018 report, the list of failed products published by the APQA also included products of several widely known brands. This is because quarantine is based on ingredients and documents, not on a brand's reputation.
Being held at quarantine does not mean the product is defective. Because this is control from the perspective of disease entry, the same product may be sold without problems in another country.
There is also the misconception that treats are not feed and so have nothing to do with quarantine. The report cited earlier said that treats, nutritional supplements and supplements registered as feed are subject to the same rules, and that processed meat products such as jerky were also presented as designated quarantine articles.
It is also easy to forget that labeling is required in order to sell imported feed. Article 13, paragraph 2 of the Act prohibits labeling the labeled items falsely or in an exaggerated way.
Where do I ask in these situations?
If you have already ordered, or customs clearance has been put on hold, or you want to know whether a product is subject to quarantine, asking the APQA or a nearby regional office is the most accurate. In the 2018 report as well, the guidance on quarantine failures was given by the APQA Incheon Airport Regional Office.
Problems with the ingredient registration or import report of feed are handled by the city or provincial government and the reporting organization under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법), so ask the relevant body. If you want to confirm whether a product is formally imported, one method is to contact the importer using the company name and address written on the packaging and confirm the ingredient registration number.
If your pet has already eaten it and shows symptoms such as vomiting, diarrhea or loss of appetite, do not try to judge the cause yourself; go to an animal hospital. Bringing the product packaging and ingredient list then helps with the examination.
Taking feed with you when traveling overseas with a pet is outside the scope of this article. The rules of the departure country and the arrival country each differ, so check with the agencies of the countries concerned.
Frequently asked questions
Q Is overseas direct-purchase feed fine in small quantities?
The materials opened for this article could not confirm an exception for small quantities. Because it cannot be assumed to be fine just because the quantity is small, ask the Animal and Plant Quarantine Agency.
Q Are treats and nutritional supplements also subject to quarantine?
The 2018 DailyVet (데일리벳) report said that treats, nutritional supplements and supplements registered as feed are subject to the same rules. An individual product must be confirmed with the APQA.
Q Does being held at quarantine mean the product is defective?
No. Quarantine is a procedure to prevent livestock diseases from entering, so it looks at ingredients and certificates separately from quality.
Q Do purchasing-agent products go through the same quarantine?
Because they too are goods coming into Korea from overseas, they should be checked from the same perspective. Whether clearance is possible cannot be known from the wording of the sales page alone.
Q What is different about formally imported feed?
Under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법), the importer is required to register the ingredients, file an import report and have packaging labeled in Korean (Articles 12 and 19 of the Act, Article 20 of the Enforcement Rule).
Q Is bringing in feed restricted in the United States and the EU as well?
According to FDA guidance, the United States may require an APHIS permit for products containing animal-derived materials, and the EU's guidance on personal imports does not allow meat and dairy products from non-EU countries and allows only pet food for health reasons, conditionally.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article contains only what was confirmed from 2016 and 2018 news reports, statutory texts, and FDA and EU guidance pages. The date when the list of quarantine-failed products began to be published and the sales procedure for failed products could not be confirmed. The text of the APQA head's notice setting the scope of sterilization and processing under Article 31, paragraph 2 of the Enforcement Rule that designates quarantine articles, the text of the APQA's quarantine guidance for pet food, whether there is an exception for small quantities, the current list of quarantine-target ingredients, and APHIS's own pages could not be confirmed. The statistics are as of 2014. Whether an individual product can clear customs must be asked of the Animal and Plant Quarantine Agency.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- Many quarantine failures: do not buy pet food and treats through overseas direct purchase or purchasing agents (2018.12.18) (검역불합격多 반려동물 사료·간식 해외직구·구매대행 하지마세요 (2018.12.18)) ↗
Used as the basis for the guidance that treats and nutritional supplements registered as feed are also subject to quarantine, the disclosure of a list of 364 failed products, and the guidance on processed meat products as designated quarantine articles.
- Do not carelessly buy pet food directly from overseas: quarantine failure rate exceeds 40 percent (2016.6.2) (반려동물 사료 해외직구 함부로 하지 마세요 검역 불합격률 40퍼센트 넘어 (2016.6.2)) ↗
Used as the basis for the 2014 Incheon Airport express cargo failure statistics, the requirements on meat and BSE ingredients and quarantine certificates, and the explanation of concerns about foot-and-mouth disease and avian influenza.
- Act on the Prevention of Contagious Animal Diseases and its Enforcement Rule (Article 31, designated quarantine articles) (가축전염병 예방법·같은 법 시행규칙 (제31조 지정검역물)) ↗
Used as the basis for the provision that the scope of designated quarantine articles and the sterilization and processing standards are set by notice of the head of the APQA.
- Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (Articles 2, 12, 13, 14 and 19) (사료관리법 (제2조, 제12조, 제13조, 제14조, 제19조)) ↗
Used as the basis for the definition of the import business, ingredient registration, labeling, the import report obligation and the prohibition provisions.
- Enforcement Rule of the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (Article 20, Appendix 4) (사료관리법 시행규칙 (제20조, 별표 4)) ↗
Used as the basis for the documents to submit for an import report, the Korean-labeled packaging requirement and the labeling items in Appendix 4.
- Importing Animal Food ↗
Used as the basis for the US guidance on prior notice, facility registration, ingredient requirements and the possibility of an APHIS permit.
- Taking animal products, food or plants with you in the EU ↗
Used as the basis for the EU ban on travelers from non-EU countries bringing in meat and dairy products and the conditions for pet food for health reasons.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 3 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
