Skip to content
Grochi · Neutral pet information from South Korea · English edition한국어
Grochi.English edition
Health care

How do ivermectin, milbemycin, selamectin and moxidectin heartworm preventives differ?

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. This page is an English translation of the Korean edition as checked on 2026-11-22. If the two differ, the Korean edition is the reference. 한국어판 (Korean edition)

How do ivermectin, milbemycin, selamectin and moxidectin heartworm preventives differ?
Short answer

All four ingredients are macrocyclic lactones and act on infective larvae. The differences show up in dosage form, other parasite ingredients combined with them, whether an injectable exists, and the cat product list.

Key takeaways

  • Ivermectin, milbemycin oxime, selamectin and moxidectin are all macrocyclic lactones (ML), and research literature explains that the active ingredients of heartworm preventives sold in the United States belong to this class.
  • Heartworm preventives are not drugs that kill grown adult worms but drugs that act on young larval stages recently acquired through mosquitoes, and the American Heartworm Society (AHS) advises that they must be given before the larvae pass into a stage they can no longer remove effectively.
  • Dosage form (oral, topical, injectable) and the other parasite ingredients included differ by ingredient; in the AHS chart only moxidectin was found as a sustained-release injectable, and no injectable for cats was found.
  • Research literature says that reports of lack of efficacy against ML resistance came mainly from the southern United States, but missed doses were common in those cases, so the cause is hard to separate.
  • The Korean Veterinary Medical Association (KVMA) says heartworm preventives in Korea are prescription-only veterinary medicinal products (처방대상 동물용의약품), so the choice of ingredient and product should be made with a veterinarian, not by the owner.

What do the four ingredients have in common, and how do they differ?

To start with the conclusion, ivermectin, milbemycin oxime, selamectin and moxidectin are all macrocyclic lactone (ML) ingredients. A 2012 review by Bowman in Parasites & Vectors presents these four as the ML ingredients used for heartworm prevention. Because they are the same class, they work in the same general direction. A 2024 review in Frontiers in Veterinary Science explains that MLs kill the highly susceptible L3 and L4 larval stages of heartworm so that adult worms cannot develop.

What, then, makes the ingredients differ? There are roughly four points. The first is which dosage forms are available: oral, topical (applied to the skin) or injectable. The second is whether the same product also contains ingredients aimed at parasites other than heartworm. The third is whether the ingredient appears in the list of products for cats. The fourth is how it is treated in safety discussions such as resistance and the sensitivity of some dog breeds.

This article does not rate any ingredient as better, and it does not explain how to choose a drug. It gives no dose or dosing interval either. It explains what the drugs are and how they are distinguished, within the range written in public and professional sources. How heartworm is transmitted, why prevention is advised year-round, and what to do after a missed dose are covered in the basic heartworm prevention article, so only the ingredients are discussed here.

Is a preventive really a drug that stops infection in advance?

The name "preventive" sounds like a drug that blocks something from entering the body before it arrives, but the way the sources describe the action is a little different. The AHS owner guidance states that all approved heartworm medications work by eliminating the immature (larval) stages. The targets are the infective larvae that enter through a mosquito bite and the larvae that develop into the next stage. By contrast, the U.S. FDA states clearly that heartworm preventives do not kill adult worms.

Bowman's review explains this principle as follows. Because the drugs leave the body relatively quickly, they do not protect continuously after a single dose; they are given monthly and work by killing larvae that entered the body during the previous 30 days. In other words, the drug works backward on larvae acquired over the past period. That is why keeping to the dosing date matters.

AHS advises that in as little as 51 days, larvae can pass into a juvenile (immature adult) stage that a preventive can no longer effectively eliminate, and warns that a late dose can let larvae reach that stage. It also explains that preventives are highly effective but not complete. This is the same whichever ingredient is used.

The finer points of the mechanism are explained in the 2024 review. It says that action on glutamate-gated chloride channels is the main mechanism, and adds that in test-tube experiments at concentrations equivalent to those in the body the effect on parasite movement was small, so the host's immune system also plays an important role in the body. These details come from an academic review and are not a basis for an owner to choose a drug.

How do dosage form and the other parasites combined differ by ingredient?

AHS publishes a preventives chart for dogs and cats on its website. This article summarizes only, within the range read from that chart, which forms exist for each ingredient and whether ingredients for other parasites are included. The chart is based on products sold in the United States and cannot be taken to be the same as products approved and sold in Korea. The cells in the chart that show which parasites are targeted had broken alignment and could not be confirmed. The target parasites, age and weight criteria of an actual product must follow the product label and the veterinarian's advice.

In the AHS chart, ivermectin is listed as an oral drug for dogs (monthly); no single-ingredient product was confirmed, and combinations with pyrantel and combinations with pyrantel and praziquantel appear. Milbemycin oxime is listed as an oral drug (monthly) for dogs and cats, and for dogs there are combinations with praziquantel, lufenuron or spinosad in addition to the single-ingredient product. Selamectin is a topical drug (monthly) with single-ingredient products for dogs and cats, and for cats there is also a combination with sarolaner.

Moxidectin has the widest range of forms. Oral products for dogs include combinations that contain external parasite ingredients such as afoxolaner, sarolaner and lotilaner together with pyrantel and others, and topical products combined with imidacloprid are on both the dog and cat lists. For cats there is also a topical product combined with fluralaner. For injectables, single-ingredient moxidectin products labeled for 6-month and 12-month intervals are on the dog list. In this list, ivermectin was not found among the cat entries. Which parasites each product targets could not be confirmed because the alignment of the chart was broken.

The FDA explains that some preventives also contain other ingredients that are effective against intestinal parasites or that target fleas, ticks and ear mites. So even when the same ingredient name is printed, the parasites targeted differ by product.

Summary of forms by ingredient read from the AHS preventives chart (United States basis, may differ from products approved in Korea, not dosing guidance)
IngredientForm found in the chartOther ingredients combined (varies by product; target parasites not confirmed)Cat list
IvermectinOral for dogs (monthly)Pyrantel, some with praziquantelNot found within the range read for this article
Milbemycin oximeOral for dogs and cats (monthly)Some dog products with praziquantel, lufenuron or spinosadA single-ingredient oral product is listed
SelamectinTopical (monthly)Some cat products with sarolanerA single-ingredient topical product is listed
MoxidectinOral, topical, injectable for dogs (labeled 6 and 12 months)Depending on the product, imidacloprid, external parasite ingredients such as afoxolaner, pyrantel, praziquantelTopical products combined with imidacloprid or fluralaner are listed

How are injectable moxidectin and cat products described?

The AHS owner guidance explains that injectable preventives are given every 6 or 12 months, and the AHS cat guidance says a sustained-release injectable preventive is available for dogs 6 months of age or older. The FDA also states that there is one product for dogs that is injected under the skin every 6 or 12 months. In the AHS list, this injectable is moxidectin. The 2024 review says that a sustained-release moxidectin injection aims at 6 months or 1 year of protection from a single injection and that owner compliance was higher than with monthly drugs. However, this review had authors who were Zoetis employees (5 authors) and was funded by Zoetis, so comparisons of products should be read with possible bias in mind.

Cats are different. The AHS cat guidance states that preventives for cats come in two forms, topical and oral, and mentions sustained-release injectable preventives only for dogs. The FDA also states that for cats both topical and oral products are all given monthly. Dosing intervals differ by product, so they must be checked with the product label and the veterinarian. Either way, using a dog product on a cat on one's own is not recommended.

There is also a reason why checking the ingredient and product matters especially for cats. AHS advises that there is no approved drug therapy for heartworm infection in cats, and that the drug used to treat infections in dogs is not safe for cats. The FDA also says there is no approved drug to treat heartworm infection in cats. So for cats it matters even more whether the preventive ingredient and product are approved for cats. Even with the same ingredient, the concentration and combination of a product differ between dogs and cats, so a drug suited to one animal should not be used on another species.

What is the resistance discussion, and how far has it been confirmed?

In Bowman's review, ML resistance means a state in which the proportion of individuals in a population that can tolerate the set dose of a drug has increased. Bowman explains that ML resistance is well known in intestinal nematodes. For heartworm, he introduces reports of lack of efficacy in dogs in the Mississippi Delta region of the United States, where infection appeared even though preventives had been given. He adds that, because dosing was irregular in many cases, it is hard to explain the failures by resistance alone, and he writes that there have been no reports yet on whether the resistance trait is heritable. Bowman states that he received financial remuneration from the manufacturers of the products mentioned in the review.

The 2024 review writes that resistance has been identified in the United States, mainly in the Lower Mississippi River Valley, and explains that no confirmed resistant strains have been reported in Europe so far. It also stresses that owner non-compliance rather than product failure is still the major cause of heartworm disease diagnosed in dogs. The same paper reports that in laboratory studies moxidectin was more effective than ivermectin, milbemycin oxime and selamectin against the resistant strains tested, but because this comparison involves the sponsor's product, independent confirmation is needed rather than accepting it as it stands.

The AHS website is described as having a separate Resistance Statement. This article could not read that document, so it does not write how AHS specifically advises on resistance. In summary, resistance is a topic that has actually been reported, but the situation in Korea could not be confirmed from the sources of this article. That is not a reason to stop prevention, and which ingredient suits an animal is decided by a veterinarian who knows the region and test results.

What does it mean that some dog breeds are sensitive to ivermectin?

This topic is covered in detail in a separate article (MDR1 ivermectin sensitivity), so only a sentence or two is given here. The 2024 review explains that if there is a defect in the ABCB1 (formerly MDR1) gene, which is commonly recognized in collies and some other breeds, the protein that normally keeps substances from entering the brain does not work properly, so MLs can accumulate in the brain and toxicity can appear even at low doses. When the breed or bloodline is known, the owner should tell the veterinarian before an ingredient is chosen. An owner should not decide which ingredient is safe.

How are these drugs classified and sold in Korea?

The KVMA explains that heartworm preventives in Korea are managed as prescription-only veterinary medicinal products (처방대상 동물용의약품). The legal framework for this classification is Article 85 of the Pharmaceutical Affairs Act (약사법). Paragraph 6 of that article provides that a person licensed as a veterinary medicinal product wholesaler must not sell, without a veterinarian's prescription, veterinary medicinal products designated by notice of the Minister of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (those that may harm the health of people and animals through misuse or abuse, those that require a veterinarian's specialized knowledge, and those recognized as likely to cause problems in dosage form and pharmacological action). Sales among animal hospital operators, pharmacy operators and wholesalers are an exception. Paragraph 7 provides that a pharmacy operator may sell the veterinary medicinal products of paragraph 6 without a prescription, except injectable antibiotic preparations and injectable biological preparations. Paragraph 8 makes exceptions for sales to livestock farms in islands and remote areas and for cases where an emergency disease-control order has been issued. Under Article 95 of the same Act, a person who sells veterinary medicinal products without a prescription in violation of paragraphs 6 and 7 is punished by imprisonment of up to 1 year or a fine of up to KRW 10,000,000.

According to the KVMA notice, the prescription-only veterinary medicinal products were expanded from November 13, 2022, and it cites as the basis Article 85, paragraphs 6 and 7 of the Pharmaceutical Affairs Act and the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs's Regulation on Designation of Prescription-Only Veterinary Medicinal Products (처방대상 동물용의약품 지정에 관한 규정). The same notice states that for heartworm preventives the main manufacturers and importers supply them only to animal hospitals because of side effects, that wholesalers cannot sell prescription-only heartworm preventives without a prescription, and that an animal hospital reselling prescription-only veterinary medicinal products to wholesalers or pharmacies is subject to imprisonment of up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 50,000,000.

However, this article could not open the text and appended tables of the Regulation on Designation of Prescription-Only Veterinary Medicinal Products (처방대상 동물용의약품 지정에 관한 규정) directly. So how ivermectin, milbemycin, selamectin and moxidectin are each listed in the appended table, and whether each is prescription-only, must be checked against the appended table of the notice and approval information, and this article does not assert it. Designation may differ by ingredient and the rules are revised, so the latest provisions should be checked at the National Law Information Center (law.go.kr). Which products the Animal and Plant Quarantine Agency (APQA) has approved could not be confirmed from the sources of this article either.

So what is practical for owners is simple. In Korea, a heartworm preventive is a drug decided by a veterinarian after an animal hospital visit, and the table in this article is not a list of products approved in Korea but a summary by ingredient from the AHS in the United States. Do not obtain a drug from an ingredient name found online, and do not use a dog product on a cat or a livestock product on a companion animal instead.

What should owners check, and what are the common misunderstandings?

Choosing a drug is the veterinarian's job, but there is information that helps if the owner conveys it accurately to the clinic. It helps to have the following ready.

  • The ingredient name and product label of the drug currently given (check whether intestinal parasite or flea ingredients are also included)
  • Whether any flea and tick drug or dewormer is used together (have the clinic check that ingredients do not overlap)
  • The dog's breed and family history, and whether there was an adverse reaction to a drug before
  • The date the drug was last given and the product name

Common misunderstandings are also worth noting. The first is the idea that "the newer the ingredient, the better." In the sources read for this article, there was no sentence that generalized a ranking of ingredients, and the comparative studies had sponsorship problems. The second is the idea that "an injectable finishes it in one go." An injectable also has to be given again at the set interval, and the protection period follows the product label. The third is the idea that "a preventive also removes worms already acquired." The FDA states that it does not kill adult worms. The fourth is the idea that "this ingredient is in a flea and tick drug, so there is no need to give anything separately." The parasites targeted differ by product, so check with the label and the veterinarian's advice. The fifth is the idea that "there is talk of resistance, so prevention is meaningless." The 2024 review explains that non-compliance is still the main cause.

There is something easy to miss while comparing ingredients. Why a test before starting a preventive and regular tests are needed is covered in the basic heartworm prevention article, but regardless of ingredient, one point is repeated here once more: an animal that has never been tested should talk with a veterinarian before starting.

Information about ingredients that owners can pass to the clinic
InformationWhy it is neededHow to prepare
Ingredient name of the drug currently usedTo check that ingredients of the same class do not overlapKeep a photo of the ingredient label on the box or leaflet
Flea, tick and deworming drugs used togetherBecause the parasites targeted differ by productWrite down the product name and the last dose date
Breed and previous adverse reactionsBecause some breeds may be sensitive to MLsTell the veterinarian the bloodline and previous reactions
Whether the animal is a catBecause the cat product list and ingredient combinations differDo not use a dog drug on a cat

When should I contact a veterinarian?

In the following cases it is better to contact an animal hospital without waiting. First, when something abnormal appears after the animal has taken or been given a preventive, such as vomiting, diarrhea, severe lethargy, trembling, stumbling or seizures. In particular, if neurological signs such as stumbling or seizures appear, contact an animal hospital immediately. Bringing the drug package and ingredient label helps the assessment.

Next, when a cat has licked or swallowed a drug made for dogs, or when a livestock drug or another animal's drug has been given. In these cases it is safer to tell the clinic even without symptoms. A veterinary examination is also needed when coughing continues or breathing looks difficult even though a preventive is being given, or when the animal tires easily and loses weight. Being on a preventive does not mean one can conclude there is no infection.

Finally, when you want to change the drug. If an owner changes the ingredient or product on one's own, some parasites may overlap or be missed. Tell the clinic the reason for changing and the current drug, and decide together with the veterinarian.

Frequently asked questions

Q Are all four ingredients the same type of drug?

Bowman's 2012 review and the 2024 review explain that all four ingredients belong to the macrocyclic lactone (ML) class. Being in the same class does not mean the form or target parasites of the products are the same.

Q Do preventives also remove adult worms already in the body?

No. The FDA states that heartworm preventives do not kill adult worms, and AHS advises that approved drugs work by eliminating the immature larval stages. If adult worms are suspected, a veterinarian's test and judgment are needed.

Q Is injectable moxidectin better than a monthly oral drug?

This article does not judge which is better. The 2024 review reports that the injectable had higher owner compliance, but some of its authors are Zoetis employees and the study was funded by that company. A veterinarian makes the proposal according to age, weight, medical history and how easily the owner can visit the clinic.

Q Are selamectin or milbemycin products also used for cats?

The AHS list includes an oral milbemycin oxime product and a topical selamectin product for cats. However, which products are approved for which animals in Korea could not be confirmed in this article. Do not use a dog product on a cat, and always check with a veterinarian.

Q Is it true that resistance has developed and preventives no longer work?

The research literature writes that there have been reports of lack of efficacy in some parts of the United States and that resistance has been identified, but it explains that failure to keep to dosing is still the main cause. The situation in Korea could not be confirmed from the sources of this article.

Q I heard ivermectin is risky for breeds such as collies. Is that so?

The 2024 review explains that in dogs with an ABCB1 (MDR1) gene defect, MLs can accumulate in the brain and toxicity can appear even at low doses. Details are covered in a separate MDR1 article. Tell the veterinarian the breed or the gene test result.

Q Can I buy heartworm preventives at a pharmacy in Korea?

According to the KVMA, heartworm preventives are prescription-only veterinary medicinal products and wholesalers cannot sell them without a prescription, and the main manufacturers and importers supply them only to animal hospitals. Paragraph 7 of Article 85 of the Pharmaceutical Affairs Act (약사법) excludes only injectable antibiotics and injectable biological preparations from sales without a prescription at pharmacies, so whether a pharmacy may sell one is not decided by this provision alone and the appended table of the notice and approval information must be checked together. Check the latest rules at the National Law Information Center (law.go.kr), and consult an animal hospital before buying.

Limits and scope of this guide

This article is an editorial draft and has not completed review by a veterinarian or pharmacist. It does not replace diagnosis, prescription, drug choice, dose or dosing interval for an individual animal. The table of forms by ingredient was read from the U.S. AHS list and may differ from products approved and sold in Korea, and the products approved in Korea and the ingredient-by-ingredient content of the appended table of the Regulation on Designation of Prescription-Only Veterinary Medicinal Products (처방대상 동물용의약품 지정에 관한 규정) could not be confirmed directly. The cells for target parasites by product in the AHS chart could not be read, and the AHS Resistance Statement and the full guideline text (PDF) could not be read either, and the Merck Veterinary Manual and CAPC did not open and were not used. The 2024 review is sponsored research and was only partly read. Decisions about drugs or adverse reactions must be made with a veterinarian.

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.

Sources and check dates

  1. Heartworm Basics ↗

    Used as the basis for how approved preventives eliminate young larval stages, the 51-day guidance, the forms of preventives (oral, topical, 6- to 12-month injectable), and the explanation that some products also target other parasites. The Resistance Statement was only a link and could not be read.

  2. Heartworm Preventives (preventives chart) ↗

    Used to check forms by ingredient, ingredients combined, the dog and cat lists, and injectable intervals. The cells showing target parasites had broken alignment and could not be confirmed, and the PDF chart was not read.

  3. Heartworm in Cats ↗

    Used as the basis for the point that cat preventives are topical and oral, and that there is no approved treatment drug.

  4. Keep the Worms Out of Your Pet's Heart! The Facts about Heartworm Disease ↗

    Used as the basis for the point that preventives do not kill adult worms, the product forms for dogs and cats and the need for a veterinary prescription, and the guidance on other parasite ingredients in some products.

  5. Heartworms, macrocyclic lactones, and the specter of resistance to prevention in the United States ↗

    Used as the basis for the four ingredients being MLs, the principle of monthly dosing that kills larvae from the previous 30 days, and the lack-of-efficacy reports and resistance discussion.

  6. A review of moxidectin vs. other macrocyclic lactones for prevention of heartworm disease in dogs with an appraisal of two commercial formulations ↗

    Used as the basis for how MLs act, sustained-release moxidectin injection, the regions where resistance was reported, and breed sensitivity related to ABCB1. Because it is pharmaceutical-company-sponsored research, comparisons may be biased. Only the earlier part of the text was read.

  7. Notice on the expansion of prescription-only veterinary medicinal products (수의사처방대상 동물용의약품 확대 시행 알림) ↗

    Used as the basis for the expansion of prescription-only products on November 13, 2022, the guidance on prescription and distribution of heartworm preventives, and the names of the legal basis and the notice.

  8. Pharmaceutical Affairs Act, Article 85 (Special Provisions for Veterinary Medicinal Products) (약사법 제85조 동물용 의약품 등에 대한 특례) ↗

    Used as the basis for the limits on sales without a prescription and the exceptions in Article 85, paragraphs 6, 7 and 8, and the penalty in Article 95. Based on the text in force from 2026-11-12.

Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.

This guide relies on 1 Korean law or notice. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.