How are feed calories labeled, and what do you do when there is no statement?
A product that follows the model regulations of the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) writes calories as metabolizable energy (ME) per 1 kg of feed, that is, kcal ME/kg, and is required to write together the calories per unit that owners use, such as a cup or a can. Metabolizable energy means the share of the energy in the feed that the animal can actually use in its body.
On Korean packaging, this kind of calorie statement is often not seen. Within what this guide read of Appendix 4 of the Enforcement Rule of the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법 시행규칙) and Appendix 15 of the notice, no item requiring calories to be written on pet food was found. So the absence of a calorie statement does not by itself mean the product violates the law.
When there is no statement, an owner can do three things.
- Ask the manufacturer's customer service for the metabolizable energy value (kcal/kg or kcal per cup).
- Find the guaranteed analysis on the package (crude protein, crude fat, crude fiber, crude ash) and the moisture value, and approximate by the modified Atwater method.
- Do not set the feeding amount yourself based on the approximate value; consult a veterinarian while watching changes in weight and body shape.
This guide explains these three in turn. A calorie number is helpful when comparing feeds or discussing weight management, but it is good to know from the start that it cannot be assumed that the number is an exact value.
Why is a calorie statement needed, and what does it mean?
Even when the same weight is eaten, the energy that enters the body differs from feed to feed. A feed with more fat or less moisture holds more energy even in the same 1 kg, and a moist wet food with high water content has much lower energy per weight. So when changing feeds, giving the same volume or the same weight as is may change the energy actually consumed.
The MSD Veterinary Manual, in explaining the calorie item of US labels, introduces that the statement is written under the heading Calorie Content, giving metabolizable energy on an as-fed basis per 1 kg of feed and per everyday unit such as a can, a cup or one treat. Here kcal/kg is a value for the weight of the feed, not for the animal's body weight.
The same manual explains that feeds with similar moisture content can have their calories compared directly, but feeds with different moisture, such as dry and wet, must be adjusted to a dry matter basis or a calorie basis for comparison. Converting to a dry matter basis is covered in a separate guide, so here it is enough to remember that comparing the kcal/kg of feeds with different moisture directly leads to a misunderstanding.
A calorie statement is not a number that decides the feeding amount but a number that tells the energy density of the feed. How much to feed varies with the individual's weight, age, activity level, neutering status and disease status, so it is not decided by this one number.
Is a calorie statement mandatory in Korea?
The Korean rules this guide directly checked are Appendix 4 of the Enforcement Rule of the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (Labeling items and methods for containers and packaging) and Appendix 13 (component registration of compound feed) and Appendix 15 (detailed labeling standards) of the notice Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격).
Appendix 4 of the Enforcement Rule lists as labeling items for compound feed the component registration number, name and form of the feed, guaranteed analysis (registered), names of raw materials used, details of veterinary drugs added, precautions, purpose of the feed, actual weight, manufacture (import) date and distribution period or sell-by date, manufacturer (importer) information, repackaging details, and matters set by the Minister of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs for the feed process and the like. Calories are not among the items listed. The same appendix provides that the guaranteed analysis is shown as a percentage (%), with min. attached to the minimum amount and max. to the maximum amount.
Appendix 13 of the notice sets the registered components by feed type, and while the entry for poultry such as chickens includes a calculated value of metabolizable energy (MEn), the dog entry lists crude protein, crude fat, calcium, crude ash, crude fiber and phosphorus, without energy. In Appendix 13 as this guide checked it, no entry naming cats separately was found.
Calories appear elsewhere in a limited way. Appendix 15 provides that, for highlighted comparisons of nutrient content, a nutrient including calories must differ by at least 25% from the standard value of other products, and that a liquid product may use the term diet if it has 2 kcal or less per 400 mL. This means that if a highlighted claim based on calories is made, that figure is needed, and it is not a rule that all products must write calories.
In summary, within what this guide read, a calorie statement is not mandatory in Korea, and some manufacturers may write it voluntarily. However, because the last labeling item of the Enforcement Rule is left open as matters set by the Minister, and this guide did not check every notice provision, this judgment is limited to the scope checked.
How does the US AAFCO system write calories?
AAFCO's calorie guidance page explains that calories are written as an average value. This means the average of values from multiple analyses, not a method that guarantees a minimum or maximum like the guaranteed analysis. The unit is kcal/kg, and calories per cup or per treat are converted and written alongside it.
The conversion is simple. The AAFCO guidance says to divide the kcal/kg value by 1,000 to get kcal per 1 g and then multiply by the weight (g) of a cup or one treat. As the guidance's example, a feed with 3,688 kcal/kg is about 442.6 kcal per cup if 1 cup is taken as 120 g, and about 36.9 kcal per treat if one treat is taken as 10 g. The weight of one cup differs with kibble size and density, so even the same cup has different calories from feed to feed.
The Washington State administrative rule in the US (WAC 16-252-118) follows the same structure as is. It requires metabolizable energy to be shown in kcal/kg on an as-fed moisture basis and converted to calories per everyday unit such as a can, a measuring cup or a treat, and allows two methods of obtaining the value: the modified Atwater formula or a feeding trial procedure set by AAFCO. A value obtained by a feeding trial carries the notation fed, meaning it was fed. There is also a provision that a statement supporting the calorie determination must be submitted if the authority requests it.
One point of caution is that US state rules differ from state to state in how far they have adopted the model regulations. Korean products are under no obligation to follow this framework, and it can be understood that imported products and some Korean products voluntarily write in this format.
How do you approximate calories when there is no statement?
The method the AAFCO guidance presents has two steps. First, obtain nitrogen-free extract (NFE, an estimate of carbohydrates). With all values on the package taken as percentages on an as-fed basis, NFE is what remains of 100 after subtracting crude protein, crude fat, crude fiber, moisture and crude ash.
Next, multiply by the modified Atwater factors. ME (kcal/kg) = [(3.5 × crude protein) + (8.5 × crude fat) + (3.5 × NFE)] × 10. Protein and carbohydrate are taken as 3.5 kcal per 1 g and fat as 8.5 kcal, and because percentage values are used, multiplying by 10 at the end makes it kcal/kg.
A hypothetical set of numbers for understanding the calculation is as follows. If crude protein is 26, crude fat 14, crude fiber 3, moisture 10 and crude ash 7, then NFE is 100 - (26 + 14 + 3 + 10 + 7) = 40. ME is [(3.5 × 26) + (8.5 × 14) + (3.5 × 40)] × 10 = (91 + 119 + 140) × 10 = 3,500 kcal/kg. This value is an illustrative number and not the value of any specific product.
The guaranteed analysis written on Korean packaging is in a minimum or maximum format for each component, and which component is written as min. and which as max. has to be checked directly on the product package. Appendix 4 provides that min. is shown for the minimum amount and max. for the maximum amount. So it should also be taken into account that a result calculated from these values is an approximation based on guaranteed values, not on actual average analysis values.
| Item | Where to find it | Role in the calculation |
|---|---|---|
| Crude protein | Package guaranteed analysis | Multiply by 3.5 and add |
| Crude fat | Package guaranteed analysis | Multiply by 8.5 and add |
| Crude fiber | Package guaranteed analysis | Subtract when obtaining NFE |
| Crude ash | Package guaranteed analysis | Subtract when obtaining NFE |
| Moisture | Package guaranteed analysis or ask the manufacturer | Subtract when obtaining NFE |
| Nitrogen-free extract (NFE) | Not written directly, so calculated | Multiply by 3.5 and add |
Why can the estimate differ from the actual value?
First, NFE is not a measured value but what remains after subtracting the other components from 100. The AAFCO guidance states that NFE is an estimate because carbohydrates are not measured directly, and, citing the lack of a uniform method for measuring carbohydrates, does not recommend labeling about carbohydrates either. Any error in measuring the other components accumulates in NFE.
Second, the modified Atwater factors are values that assume average digestibility. The same 3.5 is used for protein and carbohydrate and 8.5 for fat, but the degree to which they are digested differs by ingredient. A feed with a lot of fiber or many poorly digestible ingredients may have lower actual metabolizable energy than the calculated value, and a difference in the opposite direction is also possible.
Third, the guaranteed analysis on the package is a guaranteed minimum or maximum value and so differs from the actual content. Allowing for manufacturing variation, the actual value moves around the guaranteed value.
Fourth, which laboratory did the analysis also has an effect. The AAFCO guidance notes that laboratories that mainly analyze human food may not use the same modified Atwater values, which can make calories inaccurate. This means that even if calories are written in an analysis report, it is necessary to check whether it is a calculation for pet food.
This guide could not directly confirm figures on what percentage the modified Atwater calculation departs from actual feeding trials. So it does not give the size of the discrepancy as a number, and it is advisable to use the calculated value only for rough comparison between feeds.
What are the common misunderstandings about calories?
One misunderstanding is the idea that a higher kcal/kg is bad or good. Energy density only shows the character of a feed and is not in itself a ranking of quality. The energy density suited to a very active animal and the one suited to an animal needing weight management can differ.
Another is the idea that 1 cup of any feed has the same calories. The weight that fits in one cup differs with kibble shape and density. As in the AAFCO guidance, calories per cup come out only by multiplying kcal/kg by the grams per cup.
The third is the idea that the feeding amount can be set exactly from a calculated calorie value. The MSD Veterinary Manual explains that the feeding guide on a label sets amounts by body weight and number of feedings, but this is at most general guidance, and weight and body shape must be checked continuously to prevent overfeeding or underfeeding. An approximated calorie value is within the same limit.
The fourth is the idea that a product with no calorie statement is unsuitable. As seen earlier, calories are not in the list of labeling items in the Korean Enforcement Rule, so the absence cannot be asserted as illegal at once. Conversely, a written calorie figure does not mean that value has passed verification by a public agency.
Lastly, it is easy to think that a product carrying a word such as light or diet has low calories. The Korean notice sets standards for such highlighted claims, but what those standards mean from the owner's side has to be checked separately in the manufacturer's explanation and figures. Marketing wording is covered in a separate guide.
What should an owner check, and when is consultation needed?
The items to check on the package and in manufacturer materials are as follows.
- Whether there is a calorie statement and, if so, whether it is kcal/kg or kcal per cup, and whether it is on an as-fed basis
- The crude protein, crude fat, crude fiber, crude ash and moisture values in the guaranteed analysis, and the min. and max. notation
- Whether the manufacturer tells you the weight (g) of one cup
- What weight and age the feeding guide is based on
- Whether the manufacturer obtained calories by calculation or by a feeding trial
When changing feeds or adjusting weight, do not look only at the calorie number; set a regular interval to check and record weight and body shape (how well the ribs can be felt, the waistline). Such checks tell you better than the calorie number whether actual intake is appropriate.
It is good to contact an animal hospital in the following cases.
- When weight visibly rises or falls even though the feeding amount is kept the same
- When appetite suddenly changes or vomiting or diarrhea continues
- When you need to decide the feeding amount for a young animal, a pregnant or nursing animal, an elderly animal or an animal with a chronic illness
- When you are about to start a diet for weight management
Because feeding amounts vary greatly between individuals, this guide does not give specific amounts. If the manufacturer's labeling information is ambiguous, ask the manufacturer, and if legal labeling or false labeling is suspected, you can ask a competent agency such as the National Agricultural Products Quality Management Service (국립농산물품질관리원), which checks feed labeling.
Frequently asked questions
Q Must calories (kcal) be written on Korean feed packaging?
The 12 labeling items for compound feed in Appendix 4 of the Enforcement Rule of the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법 시행규칙) that this guide checked do not include calories, and the guaranteed analysis for the dog entry in Appendix 13 of the notice has no energy either. So it was not confirmed as mandatory, but because matters set by the Minister are left open and not every provision was viewed, this answer is limited to the scope checked.
Q What does kcal ME/kg mean?
It means how many kcal of metabolizable energy are in 1 kg of feed. Metabolizable energy is the share of the energy eaten that the animal can actually use in its body, and in the US AAFCO system it is written on an as-fed moisture basis.
Q How do I convert kcal/kg into calories per cup?
According to the AAFCO guidance, divide the kcal/kg value by 1,000 to get kcal per 1 g and multiply by the weight (g) of one cup. The weight of one cup differs from feed to feed, so use the value the manufacturer provides.
Q May I calculate the calories of a feed with no statement myself?
It can be approximated by obtaining NFE and then using the modified Atwater factors 3.5, 8.5 and 3.5. However, because NFE is an estimate and digestibility differs, the result may differ from actual metabolizable energy, so it is to be used only as a reference value for comparison, not as a basis for setting the feeding amount.
Q May I compare the kcal/kg of wet and dry food as they are?
When moisture differs greatly, they are hard to compare as they are. The MSD Veterinary Manual explains that feeds with similar moisture content can be compared directly, but feeds of different types should be compared after adjusting to a dry matter basis or a calorie basis.
Q May I set the daily feeding amount from the calculated calories?
It is not advisable. The energy needed differs greatly between individuals by weight, age, activity level, neutering status and health condition. The feeding amount is set in consultation with a veterinarian while watching changes in weight and body shape.
Limits and scope of this guide
This guide judged whether a calorie statement is mandatory in Korea only within the scope checked, namely Appendix 4 of the Enforcement Rule and Appendixes 13 and 15 of the notice, and did not check every provision of the notice or later amendments (for example, the planned change to the feed labeling system). Because there are no directly checked figures on how far the modified Atwater calculation departs from actual feeding trials, none are given. Energy needs and feeding amounts by species, age and health condition of pets are not covered, and because individual differences are large, a veterinarian should be consulted. US rules differ by state in how far they are adopted and when they are revised, so they may differ from the current state. Whether calorie labeling is included in the amended notice for separate labeling standards for dog and cat food, scheduled to take effect in September 2028, could not be confirmed.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- Enforcement Rule of the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act [Appendix 4] Labeling items and methods for containers and packaging (사료관리법 시행규칙 [별표 4] 용기 및 포장에의 표시사항 및 표시방법) ↗
Used as the basis that the 12 labeling items for compound feed in Appendix 4 do not include calories, and that the guaranteed analysis is shown as a percentage with min. and max.
- Standards and Specifications for Feeds (Appendix 13 component registration of compound feed, Appendix 15 other labeling items for feed) (사료 등의 기준 및 규격 (별표 13 배합사료 성분등록, 별표 15 사료의 기타 표시사항)) ↗
Used as the basis that the dog entry's registered components have no energy, and that calories are mentioned only in the comparison highlighting standard (25% difference) and the diet labeling standard for liquid products.
- Strengthening pet food safety management (press release, 2021-03-17) (반려동물 사료 안전관리 강화 (보도자료, 2021-03-17)) ↗
Used as the basis for the Korean labeling system in which compound feed has 12 labeling items, false and exaggerated labeling is prohibited, and it is subject to inspection.
- Calorie Content (AAFCO Startups) ↗
Used as the basis for explaining the kcal/kg statement, the NFE calculation, the modified Atwater factors 3.5, 8.5 and 3.5, the per-cup conversion and the limits of estimation.
- WAC 16-252-118 Determination of calorie content ↗
Used as the basis for explaining the as-fed kcal/kg statement, the conversion to everyday units, the two determination methods (calculation or feeding trial) and the fed notation.
- Dog and Cat Foods (Merck Veterinary Manual) ↗
Used as the basis for the explanation of the kcal/kg and per-everyday-unit statement under the heading Calorie Content, the way to compare feeds with different moisture, and that the feeding guide is general guidance.
- Introduction of separate standards and specifications for dog and cat food (Dailyvet) (개·고양이 사료 별도 기준규격 도입(데일리벳)) ↗
Used, in explaining the limits, as the basis for the report that the amended notice was promulgated on September 3 and takes effect from September 2028, 3 years later.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 2 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
