Do human grade, holistic and premium have a legal definition?
Put briefly, in the current South Korean feed labeling standards that this guide checked, no item is seen that defines the words "human grade" (휴먼그레이드), "holistic" (홀리스틱) or "premium" (프리미엄) themselves or sets conditions for their use. The materials checked are the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법), the MAFRA notice Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) (Notice No. 2024-27, in force April 1, 2024) and its Appendix 15. These three phrases are common in product descriptions, but using them does not guarantee any quality grade set by law.
However, having no definition does not mean any expression may be used. Article 13, paragraph 2 of the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) provides that manufacturers, importers and sellers must not label labeled matters falsely or in an exaggerated way. Even a phrase with no definition can raise a false or exaggerated labeling issue if it differs from the actual contents of the product and misleads consumers. Conversely, with no definition there is also no standard for judging good or bad from the phrase alone.
On the other hand, some phrases such as "natural" (천연), "low" (저), "light" (라이트), "one hundred percent" (백 퍼센트) and "gluten-free" (무글루텐) have conditions set by Appendix 15 of the notice. Even though they look like the same kind of promotional wording, phrases with conditions and phrases without are mixed together, so this guide explains the two separately. It also notes, apart from the current rules, that standards are scheduled to be created for "organic" (유기) and "human-edible" (사람이 먹을 수 있는) labeling in the amended notice scheduled to take effect from September 2028.
Why do so many of these phrases have no definition?
The feed labeling system has long been managed within the same framework as feed for livestock such as cattle, pigs and chickens. In its press release of December 16, 2024, MAFRA pointed out that dog and cat food had been managed together with livestock feed, and said it had prepared an amendment that sets separate labeling standards for dog and cat food. In other words, the phrases common in pet food marketing were an area that the system was following behind.
The United States is in a similar position. The consumer FAQ page of AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) describes premium as a term that is "not regulated at all in feed law", and says a premium feed carries no higher requirements than ordinary feed. The same page introduces human grade as a marketing term for which AAFCO has prepared guidance. AAFCO's guidance page also explains that AAFCO itself does not regulate, test, approve or certify feed, and is an organization that creates model regulations that states and other bodies may adopt into law.
In summary, in both South Korea and the United States, adjectives created in the market spread before the system did, and the system responds by picking out expressions consumers are likely to misunderstand and attaching conditions. That is why whether a definition exists differs from phrase to phrase. This is the reason it is hard to guess overall quality from a single phrase.
As for the word holistic, this guide found no definition provision in any of the South Korean or US official materials it opened directly. Because this is something that could not be confirmed, it does not conclude that no definition exists, and states only the fact that a definition could not be confirmed.
What expressions are prohibited and what are allowed in South Korea?
The center of the current rules is Appendix 15 of the notice Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격). This appendix lists the scope of false or exaggerated labeling and advertising as items. Among the items this guide read, the ones consumers are likely to meet are the following.
- Labeling or advertising with contents that differ from what was registered in component registration, manufacturing business registration or import declaration
- Contents saying the feed is effective in preventing or treating disease. The appendix states that because feed serves as animal nutrition or is needed to maintain health and growth, it cannot be labeled as diagnosing, treating, alleviating, managing or preventing disease
- Contents that differ from the facts about the manufacturing method, manufacture date or sell-by date
- Contents saying a commendation, letter of appreciation, or certification, assurance or endorsement was received (except where it is under laws and regulations, such as a government commendation, certification or assurance by a public body such as a central administrative agency, or product certification under the Industrial Standardization Act)
- Labeling that, through the use of a foreign language or similar, causes confusion with a foreign product or with technical cooperation with a foreign country
- Labeling that disparages other businesses, or labeling that emphasizes content of little relevance to the product's quality, raw materials, registered components or effects, or an ingredient that was not used, so that other products are indirectly perceived as different
- Labeling of the function or action of a specific ingredient that consumers could mistake for a veterinary drug
Conversely, there are also expressions that are not treated as false or exaggerated. These include expressions that it helps healthy growth and the maintenance of healthy activity of animals, expressions that it helps maintain health, promote health, improve constitution or supply nutrition, and simple expressions of encouragement that do not name a specific disease. However, the appendix states that expressions naming a specific disease such as diabetes, constipation or cancer, or saying the feed is effective in treating disease, are not allowed.
What can be learned here is that the law does not evaluate the tone of a phrase, but looks at whether it differs from the facts, whether it makes the product look like a drug, and whether it matches what was registered. This appendix is a standard for filtering out labeling that differs from the facts, not a standard that gives a quality grade to words such as human grade or premium.
Emphasis claims with conditions: natural, low, light, diet
The "emphasis labeling standards" in the same Appendix 15 attach specific conditions to a few phrases. Restated in new words, what this guide checked is as follows.
"Natural" (천연) can be labeled where the additive is a natural additive notified in the Standards and Specifications for Food Additives, and it is also said to be labelable where the product contains no synthetic binders, artificial (compound) flavors, synthetic colors or synthetic preservatives, or other synthetic ingredients that are artificial or added after harvest, and has not gone through any process other than minimal physical processing. The "one hundred percent" (백 퍼센트) label can be used only where no substance other than the labeled raw material has been added. Feed that uses no wheat, rye or barley and has a gluten content of 20mg/kg or less can carry a gluten-free label (the grain-free expression, which means no added grain, is the subject of another guide and is not covered here).
"Low" (저), "free of" (무), "high (or rich)" (고) and "contains (or source of)" (함유) must meet the detailed criteria for nutrient content emphasis labeling by applying mutatis mutandis Article 9 and Attached Form 1 of the Labeling Standards for Foods (식품등의 표시기준), and can be used only where the nutrient was lowered or removed through the manufacturing process. "Less" (덜), "more" (더), "reduced or light" (감소 또는 라이트), "fortified" (강화) and "added" (첨가) may show the difference as a percentage or a value compared with another product's standard value, and the standard value must be calculated from 3 or more feeds with the same feed name that have a high market share. Crude protein, crude fat, crude fiber, crude ash, amino acids, calories, carbohydrates, sugars, saturated fat, trans fat, cholesterol and sodium must differ by at least 25%, and vitamins and minerals must differ by at least 10% of the daily recommended amount. For "less, light, reduced", the difference must be larger than the reference value for "low".
The term "diet" (다이어트) appears, in the range this guide read, as an item saying it can be labeled on liquid products with 2kcal or less per 400mL. How this word applies to ordinary dry or wet feed that presents itself as for weight management could not be confirmed.
Labeling prohibited to prevent consumer misunderstanding
Appendix 15 separately prohibits labeling that consumers misunderstand or confuse. The items this guide read are as follows.
- Labeling that emphasizes a nutrient in feed that did not go through a manufacturing process that lowers or removes that nutrient and that originally contains none of that nutrient at all
- Pictures or photographs suggesting a flavor or taste, where the flavor or taste of the raw material was produced with synthetic flavoring (there are exceptions, such as an apple picture being allowed where apple juice and flavoring are used together as raw materials)
- Terms such as "ionized water" (이온수), "water of life" (생명수), "mineral spring water" (약수) and "preservative-free" (무방부제)
- Labeling such as "no preservatives" (무보존제), "no added preservatives" (보존제 무첨가) and "no colorants" (무착색제) (allowed only where preservatives or colorants were not added directly and none were carried over from the raw materials)
There is also an item that, to label the presence of specific bacteria and the like, the count of those bacteria must be labeled together. There is also an item that prohibits labeling that leads people to think all the raw materials are meat, but it is said to be an exception if the meat content is shown in the same place.
Looking at this list, it stands out that a phrase consumers often see, such as "preservative-free" (무방부제), is actually a prohibited target. A phrase is not allowed just because it reads as having a good meaning. It is difficult for an ordinary pet owner (guardian) to judge whether pet food marketing phrases comply with the law, but when such words are seen, you can ask the manufacturer for the basis.
What does the amended notice scheduled to take effect in September 2028 change?
The current notice and the amended notice to take effect in the future must be read separately. In its press release of December 16, 2024, MAFRA said it would set standards for emphasis labeling that consumers may misunderstand, such as "organic" (유기) and "human-edible" (사람이 먹을 수 있는). The content is that to label "organic", certification under the Environmentally-Friendly Agriculture and Fisheries Act must be obtained, and that to label "human-edible food" or a similar phrase, the product must comply with laws on food that people eat, such as the Food Sanitation Act.
The same press release said it would also make specific the standards for labeling that can cause confusion, such as labeling and advertising that may lead people to mistake the efficacy and effects of an ingredient added to food or drink for people as the efficacy and effects of the pet food, and labeling and advertising that cite or state research on the manufacturing method. It also included making labeling of the raw material content ratio mandatory where a raw material name is used in the product name or the raw material is labeled as effective for health or function.
On the timing, Dailyvet reported that under the amended notice that sets separate standards for dog and cat food, labeling for complete pet food and other pet food takes effect in September 2028, and relayed that the industry is requesting detailed guidelines and a further grace period. This guide considers that the timing may change and does not describe the amended notice as the current standard.
According to the September 2025 Dailyvet report, the amended notice was promulgated on September 3, 2025 and takes effect in September 2028. The history in the National Law Information Center lists it as MAFRA Notice No. 2025-93, issued September 4, 2025 and taking effect September 3, 2028. The same report says that to label dog and cat food "organic", certification under related laws such as the Environmentally-Friendly Agriculture and Fisheries Act is needed, and that the expression "human-edible" can be used only if the requirements of food-related laws such as the Food Sanitation Act and the Framework Act on Food Safety are met. A December 2025 report says that a MAFRA official in charge explained at a briefing that expressions such as human-edible food can be used only where compliance with the standards of food-related laws can be proven, that the "human grade" (휴먼그레이드) expression also falls under this, and that the food-related law standards of an exporting country are not recognized. The same report also contains a remark that a further grace period of about 1 year is under consideration. Because these are newspaper reports, the wording of the notice itself was not confirmed, and until it takes effect the current Appendix 15 applies.
How are these phrases seen under US standards?
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) explains that under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, pet food must be properly labeled and truthfully labeled. The FDA's feed regulation guidance page says it judges whether a product is a food or a drug by its intended use, that is, the efficacy it labels, and that a complete feed claiming to treat or prevent disease is generally regarded as an unapproved animal drug. This page does not address the meaning of marketing terms such as natural or premium.
AAFCO's FAQ page introduces premium as a term not regulated under feed law, and explains that natural is a loose term that does not mean safe. This page states that natural and all-natural labeling must meet certain guidelines. For organic, it says AAFCO gives no warning or advice, and the specific content of the standards of the US Department of Agriculture's National Organic Program (NOP) could not be opened because access was blocked. Human grade is introduced as a marketing term with separate AAFCO guidance, but the text of the guidance (a draft PDF) could not be read as text, so its conditions are not written here.
Reduced to a single line, the difference between South Korea and the United States is that South Korea sets emphasis labeling conditions and prohibited labeling relatively specifically in the notice's appendix, while in the United States states adopt the AAFCO model regulations, so application may differ by state. The comparison of standards itself is covered in a separate guide.
What owners can check instead of the phrases
Phrases are words chosen by the manufacturer, so they are hard to use as a basis for comparison. Where the same information can be found in the South Korean labeled matters, it is better to rely on that. The table below sets out, phrase by phrase, what to open instead.
The order for reading the table is simple. First look at the component registration details and ingredient list on the back of the package, and compare whether the phrase matches that content. It is also good to remember that the ingredient list is written in descending order of blending ratio, and that under the amended notice, labeling the raw material content ratio is scheduled to become mandatory when a raw material name is in the product name. If the phrase and the labeled content seem to disagree, take a photo and ask the manufacturer.
The check goes only as far as the owner reading and judging, and if the pet has a particular condition or is on a prescription diet, consult an animal hospital before changing the feed.
| Phrase | Legal definition (range checked) | Item to check instead |
|---|---|---|
| Human grade (휴먼그레이드) | No defining item found in the current Appendix 15 of the notice | Raw material names, manufacturer labeling, asking the manufacturer for supporting materials |
| Holistic (홀리스틱) | No definition confirmed in South Korean or US official materials | Guaranteed analysis (registered), order of the ingredient list |
| Premium (프리미엄) | No defining item in South Korea; AAFCO explains it as a term that is not regulated | Component registration details, ingredient list |
| Natural (천연) | Conditions in Appendix 15 (no synthetic binders, colors, preservatives and so on) | Ingredient list and additive labeling |
| Low, light, reduced (저·라이트·감소) | Numerical criteria in Appendix 15, such as a 25% difference | The standard value being compared against and the actual guaranteed analysis (registered) |
| No preservatives (무방부제·무보존제) | Appendix 15 prohibits some labeling or allows it conditionally | Preservative entries in the ingredient list |
| Organic, human-edible (유기·사람이 먹을 수 있는) | No defining item at present; reported that under the amended notice scheduled to take effect in September 2028, organic requires certification and the human-edible expression requires meeting food-related law requirements | Whether there is labeling related to organic certification, manufacturing facility information |
Common misunderstandings and where to ask
- Misunderstanding 1: Because it says premium, it is a top grade that passed a legal standard. In the materials checked, no such grading system is seen in South Korea, and the US AAFCO explains it as a term that is not regulated.
- Misunderstanding 2: If it says natural, it has no additives at all. Natural in Appendix 15 is a condition under which natural additives may be allowed and synthetic ingredients must be absent, so reading the ingredient list is the more reliable way.
- Misunderstanding 3: If it says it received certification or endorsement, it is an officially recognized evaluation. Appendix 15 as a rule places advertising that it received certification, assurance or endorsement within the scope of false or exaggerated claims, with exceptions for cases under laws and regulations such as certification by public bodies or product certification under the Industrial Standardization Act.
- Misunderstanding 4: The amended notice is already in force. It is scheduled to take effect in September 2028, and feed is currently in a transition period between the current notice and the new standards.
If the labeling looks doubtful or you are worried about your pet's condition because of the feed, ask as follows. For product information, request supporting materials from the manufacturer's or seller's customer center, and when a labeling violation is suspected, you can ask MAFRA or the feed department of the competent local government. If vomiting, diarrhea or appetite changes continue, or if the pet is on a prescription diet, do not change the feed on your own, and consult an animal hospital.
Frequently asked questions
Q Is the human grade label legally defined in South Korea?
In the current feed labeling standards this guide checked (Appendix 15 of the notice), no item defining human grade was found. Dailyvet, citing a MAFRA explanation, reported that the amended notice scheduled to take effect in September 2028 requires the human-edible expression to meet the requirements of food-related laws, and that the human grade expression also falls under this.
Q What do premium and holistic mean?
No defining item was found in the South Korean notice, and AAFCO explains premium as a term not regulated at all in feed law. Holistic had no definition in the official materials checked.
Q Are there conditions for using the word natural?
Appendix 15 sets conditions for the natural label, such as the absence of synthetic binders, artificial flavors, synthetic colors and synthetic preservatives and having gone through only minimal physical processing. The exact application is checked through the manufacturer's explanation and the ingredient list.
Q What standards do light or low-fat labels follow?
Low, free of and high labels apply the Labeling Standards for Foods (식품등의 표시기준) mutatis mutandis. Appendix 15 sets that comparative labels such as less, light and reduced must differ by at least 25% from another product's standard value in crude protein, crude fat and so on.
Q May feed be labeled as preventing disease?
Appendix 15 places labeling and advertising of efficacy in preventing or treating disease within the scope of false or exaggerated labeling. Expressions at the level of helping maintain health fall within the range not treated as false or exaggerated.
Q Where do I ask if the labeling looks doubtful?
First ask the manufacturer for supporting materials, and if a violation is suspected, you can ask MAFRA or the feed department of the competent local government. For an animal's health problems, consult an animal hospital.
Limits and scope of this guide
This guide is based only on the text of laws and regulations and official materials opened on November 19, 2026. The South Korean definitions of human grade and holistic were not found in the notice checked, and it is not concluded that they are absent from other subordinate rules. The text of the US USDA organic standards and of the AAFCO human grade guidance could not be opened, so no conditions are written. For the details of the amended notice, only the press release and the gist of newspaper reports were checked, and the timing of enforcement may change. It does not judge whether the labeling of any specific product is lawful, and health problems are judged by an animal hospital.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) ↗
Used as the basis for the prohibition of false or exaggerated labeling in Article 13, paragraph 2.
- Standards and Specifications for Feeds (MAFRA Notice No. 2024-27) (사료 등의 기준 및 규격(농림축산식품부고시 제2024-27호)) ↗
Used as the basis for explaining the scope of false or exaggerated labeling, the emphasis labeling standards and the prohibited labeling in Appendix 15.
- Pet food with nutrition information at a glance (press release, 2024-12-16) (반려동물 사료, 영양 정보까지 한눈에 딱!(보도자료 2024.12.16)) ↗
Used as the basis for the plan to create standards in the amended notice for organic and human-edible labeling.
- Report related to D-2 years until enforcement of complete pet food labeling standards (반려동물 완전사료 표시기준 시행 D-2년 관련 보도) ↗
Used as the basis for the reported content that the amended notice is scheduled to take effect in September 2028 and that the industry is requesting a grace period.
- Report on the confirmation and promulgation of the amended pet food separate labeling standards notice (반려동물사료 별도 표시 기준 고시 개정 확정·공포 보도) ↗
Used as the basis for the report on the promulgation of the amended notice on September 3, 2025, its taking effect in September 2028, and the standards for organic and human-edible expressions.
- Report on the explanation of the amended notice at the Pet Food Forum (2025.12.16) (펫푸드 포럼 개정 고시 설명 보도(2025.12.16)) ↗
Used as the basis for the explanation by the official in charge that the human grade expression falls under the condition of meeting food-related law standards, and for the remark about a further grace period under consideration.
- AAFCO FAQs ↗
Used as the basis for AAFCO's explanation of the terms premium, natural, organic and human grade.
- Understanding Pet Food ↗
Used as the basis for the explanation that AAFCO is an organization that creates model regulations and does not regulate or approve feed.
- FDA's Regulation of Pet Food ↗
Used as the basis for the explanation that in the United States food and drugs are distinguished by the efficacy labeled.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 7 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
