The short answer: what has been confirmed about raw feeding, and what is flagged as a risk?
Here is the big picture from the materials this article checked on feeding dogs uncooked meat, organs and bones (raw feeding, a raw-meat-based diet). Many improvements are claimed, but I could not find any confirmed by controlled studies, while the points flagged as risks are supported by public agency materials and papers.
On the claimed-benefit side, there is an online survey of 218 owners in Italy (BMC Veterinary Research, 2019). Owners answered that the coat became shiny, muscle built up and teeth became cleaner, but the researchers wrote that these benefits are mainly at the level of anecdote and are unproven.
On the risk side, the US FDA and CDC advise against raw feeding. The reasons are that raw meat can carry bacteria such as Salmonella and Listeria, and that these bacteria can spread not only to the dog but also to the people living with it. I also confirmed in the Merck Veterinary Manual that the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), CDC and the FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine do not recommend feeding raw or undercooked animal protein.
This article is not meant to blame owners who feed raw. It sets out separately what has been confirmed and what has not, and then organizes how hygiene can be managed if you choose raw feeding anyway. Judgment about an individual dog's health is up to a veterinarian.
How much evidence is there for the benefits of raw feeding?
The reasons for choosing raw feeding show up fairly well in owner surveys. In the Italian survey, about 60% of respondents began raw feeding after getting information online, and the most common reasons were, in order, wanting to respect the dog's carnivorous nature (26%), wanting to improve health (24%) and dissatisfaction with commercial food (21%). 79% of respondents had stopped commercial dry food completely.
What stands out is the gap between owners' perceptions and the risk. In the same survey, 94% thought raw feeding was safe for dogs, and 65% answered that a dog cannot get sick from raw food. Yet about 45% reported that they had experienced digestive signs such as diarrhea, constipation and vomiting. Respondents who relied on a veterinarian to plan the diet were 8%, and those who relied on a nutrition specialist were only 5%.
This survey is a convenience sample recruited from Facebook raw-feeding groups and the analysis stayed at descriptive statistics, so it does not represent all owners or dogs that eat raw. The survey also asked about changes owners felt, so it is not a study that measured actual health indicators and compared them with a raw-fed group.
The Merck Veterinary Manual also says that research on raw diets is limited, which makes it hard for veterinarians to give evidence-based recommendations. Within the range this article searched and read, I could not find a study that showed, compared with a control group, that raw feeding improves health. However, not finding one is not proof that none exists, so the assessment could change if new research appears.
What materials confirm the pathogen risk?
The most often cited material is a survey by the US FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine (CVM). FDA says that from October 2010 to July 2012 it tested more than 1,000 pet foods, and that 196 raw dog and cat foods added in the second year were analyzed at 6 testing laboratories. The results were Salmonella in 15 (about 8%) and Listeria monocytogenes in 32 (about 16%). In the same survey, other types such as dry dog food are said to have had almost no positives.
This survey is more than 10 years old and covered products sold in the United States, so it should not be read as is as the contamination rate of products sold in Korea today. Even so, the explanation that products made from raw meat have no heat-based sterilization step and so carry a structural contamination risk is consistent.
The Merck Veterinary Manual says it estimates Salmonella contamination of raw beef and pork meant for human consumption at about 3.5–4%, and writes that raw meat can also carry E. coli O157:H7, protozoa and nematodes. It also says that since 2017 FDA has recalled several raw products because of Salmonella and Listeria, and that, taking market share into account, raw food was recalled much more often than cooked commercial food.
It is important that a dog's feces are also an exposure route. The Merck manual says an animal that eats raw food may show clinical signs and may also shed pathogens in its feces. So it is hard to judge that a dog is safe for the family just because it looks healthy. CDC says that dogs with weak immunity and young puppies are more vulnerable.
What are the risks for people, especially children, older adults and people with weakened immune systems?
The risk of raw pet food does not stay with the dog. CDC says that bacteria from raw pet food and treats can spread through the kitchen and the home and make both people and pets sick. The hands that touched the food, the bowl that held it, the counter the food touched, and the mouth and feces of a dog that ate raw food are the routes of transmission.
The people CDC lists as more likely to become seriously ill from foodborne germs are children under 5, adults 65 and older, people with weakened immune systems, and pregnant people. If you have such family members at home, the risk of raw feeding becomes a matter for the whole family, not the choice of one dog. In the Italian survey too, 28% of raw-feeding households had a person whose immunity was compromised or still developing, meaning a young child, an older adult, a person with a chronic illness or a pregnant person, and 77% of the dogs spent the whole day indoors, which the researchers gave as a reason to reconsider.
FDA also says that owners who handle raw pet food may have a higher risk of infection. In its guidance on handling pet food and treats, FDA says that not feeding raw food is the most preferable way to prevent these bacterial infections, and says that if you choose raw feeding you should follow handling rules.
To reduce the risk to people, in addition to handling the food carefully, it is important to keep the dog from licking faces, mouths and broken skin. CDC advises in particular not letting the dog lick the face and mouth right after a meal, and not letting it lick open wounds or broken skin.
What did antibiotic-resistant bacteria studies report?
A cross-sectional study done in the UK (Groat et al., published 2022) is the representative one. This study compared 190 fecal samples collected from 140 households in May–July 2015, that is, feces from 114 raw-fed dogs and 76 non-raw-fed dogs.
In the results, Salmonella was detected in 8 of the 114 raw-fed dogs (7%) and was not detected in the non-raw-fed group. E. coli resistant to one or more antibiotics was 54.4% in the raw-fed group and 17.1% in the non-raw-fed group. Multidrug-resistant E. coli, which do not respond to three or more classes, were 24.6% and 3.95%, and third-generation cephalosporin-resistant E. coli were 30.7% and 3.95%. Except for some drugs, the differences are said to have been statistically significant.
The limitations are also clear. The authors wrote that they relied on owner questionnaires, that voluntary recruitment through social media may reduce representativeness, and that because there is no standard raw diet in the UK, the risk may differ depending on ingredients and storage methods. The samples were also taken once per dog in a cross-sectional study, so it cannot be asserted that raw feeding is the cause, and it should also be kept in mind that there were only 8 Salmonella-positive dogs.
This is the only antibiotic-resistance paper this article opened and checked directly, so I avoid generalizing about scale. Still, the result shows a direction, that resistant E. coli may appear more often in the feces of raw-fed dogs, and explains why hand hygiene matters for owners who clean up feces. How much actual infection in people increases was not covered by this study.
What risks are flagged for nutritional imbalance and feeding bones?
The Merck Veterinary Manual lists nutrient imbalance, tooth damage, gastrointestinal obstruction or perforation, and pathogen exposure as the risks of raw-meat-based diets. The manual does not go as far as spelling out which ingredients the risks come from, so this article does not assert that bones are themselves the cause of obstruction. However, if bones are fed along with the food, it is worth discussing the possibility of tooth fracture and digestive tract blockage with a veterinarian in advance.
On the nutrition side, the broad structure the manual describes is this. Once you design a recipe yourself, a home-prepared diet easily loses quality control and consistency, and it is hard to make a complete and balanced diet. So it advises using a recipe written by a board-certified veterinary nutritionist rather than a recipe seen on the internet or in a book. It also points out that home diets do not go through the testing applied to commercial complete foods. Parts that are especially important for growing puppies, such as the balance of calcium and phosphorus, are not covered at length in this article, and the balance of cooked diets is explained in a separate article.
CDC also says that raw food is not healthier or more nutritionally complete just because it is raw. In other words, being raw and nutritional balance are separate issues.
Within the literature this article checked directly, I could not obtain figures comparing the frequency of obstruction or fractures from feeding bones between raw-fed and non-raw-fed groups. So I do not say what percentage. If vomiting, drooling, reduced appetite or difficulty passing stool continues after feeding bones, going to an animal hospital following the criteria in the last section below is safer.
What do freeze-dried and high-pressure processing (HPP) labels mean?
When a product package says freeze-dried, dried by freezing, high-pressure processing (HPP) or high-pressure pasteurization, it is easy to take it to mean that the food has gone through a safe treatment. But the materials this article checked explain it a little differently.
CDC says that freeze-drying, drying or freezing raw protein reduces bacteria but does not eliminate all of them. So it still classifies freeze-dried raw products and treats as raw, and also regards products that were irradiated or high-pressure processed as raw. It also points out that treats such as rawhide or freeze-dried treats can be raw too.
The Merck Veterinary Manual says that freezing and freeze-drying do not eliminate all pathogens, and that high-pressure processing reduces many pathogens but usually does not eliminate them. The key point is that having a label does not mean the food is free of bacteria.
So what an owner can look at is, rather than the name of the process, whether the manufacturer tests the final product for Salmonella, E. coli and Listeria, what method it uses to reduce bacteria, how often the facility is cleaned, and whether a veterinary nutrition specialist is involved. These are exactly the questions CDC recommends owners ask. If a manufacturer does not answer such questions specifically, that in itself is information for your decision.
I confirmed by search that there are papers on the effect of high-pressure processing, but I could not open and read the originals for this article. So I have not written figures for reductions under particular conditions.
How is this managed in Korea, and what materials exist?
In Korea, pet food is managed under the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) and the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) notice Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격). In an explanatory press release, MAFRA said it revised this notice in September 2025, with enforcement scheduled for September 2028, and plans on that basis to manage pet food by dividing it into types such as pet complete feed and other pet feed. Pet complete feed is defined as feed composed to meet all nutrient requirements of each growth stage without separate nutritional supplementation. It also said the government inspects distributed feed every year and takes action if the law is violated.
This material does not deal with raw food directly. Within the range this article checked, I could not find an official material in which the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS), MAFRA or the Animal and Plant Quarantine Agency (APQA) separately gave guidance on Salmonella risk in raw dog food. So it cannot be said that there is official Korean guidance on raw feeding.
The research material confirmed in Korea was encountered through news reports. In a survey of 62 raw foods for dogs and cats (all produced in Korea) collected from domestic online sellers in July–August 2023, 3 samples were positive in an avian influenza gene test, and from 2 of them (both for dogs) live low-pathogenic H9N2 virus was isolated. The corresponding author was reported to be from a Kyungpook National University research team and the journal to be Veterinary Microbiology, but this article could not open the original paper. According to the reports, the researchers suggested that because poultry safety management focuses on bacteria, virus management may be insufficient, and that pet food should also be included in public health management. This is the result of a sample of 62 products, so it cannot be generalized to all products in Korea.
If I feed raw anyway, what is the hygiene checklist?
If you have decided to continue raw feeding even after talking to a veterinarian, making the handling rules FDA and CDC advise into daily habits is the way to reduce risk. The table below organizes the guidance of the two agencies so that owners can check it easily.
First, the starting point CDC stresses is to talk to a veterinarian first if you choose raw feeding, and it advises planning a home-prepared diet together with a veterinarian or a veterinary nutrition specialist. Without such checks, no matter how well hygiene is kept, nutrition problems can remain.
Check the household makeup too. If there are children under 5, adults 65 and older, people with weakened immune systems or pregnant people, that is a reason to reconsider raw feeding itself. FDA advises cooking pet food you make yourself to the proper internal temperature measured with a food thermometer.
| Area | What to check |
|---|---|
| Hands | Wash with soap and water before and after touching raw food. FDA advises washing with soap and water for at least 20 seconds after touching raw food |
| Counters and tools | Wash, then disinfect surfaces and tools that were touched. FDA names a solution of 1 tablespoon of bleach in 1 quart of water as an effective disinfectant |
| Storage | Keep frozen until use and thaw in the refrigerator or microwave (FDA). Avoid thawing on the counter or in the sink |
| Separation | Seal and keep apart from other food (CDC). Do not rinse raw meat (FDA) |
| Leftovers | FDA advises covering and refrigerating leftovers right away, or throwing them away safely |
| Contact with the dog | Stop licking of the face and mouth right after meals, stop licking of broken skin, wash the face after being licked |
| Product | Check whether the manufacturer answers about testing the final product for Salmonella, E. coli and Listeria and about its method of reducing bacteria |
| Recall information | Do not feed recalled food (CDC). Check recall information on a regular schedule |
What are common misunderstandings, and when should I go to the veterinarian?
Let me correct a few common misunderstandings.
- The claim that a dog's stomach is so acidic that raw meat does no harm: the Merck manual this article checked says an animal that eats raw food may show clinical signs and may shed pathogens in its feces.
- The claim that freezing kills the bacteria: the methods section of the FDA CVM survey says raw products were generally in frozen packaging, and the Merck manual says freezing does not eliminate all pathogens.
- The claim that freeze-drying or HPP is the same as cooking: CDC says freeze-drying reduces bacteria but does not eliminate them.
- The claim that if the dog looks healthy there is no problem: the Merck manual says an animal that eats raw food can shed pathogens in its feces, so it is hard to judge that it is safe just because it looks healthy.
- The claim that raw is more nutritious: CDC says raw is not automatically healthier or nutritionally complete.
The times to see a veterinarian are these. When a raw-fed dog has vomiting or diarrhea that lasts more than a day, when there is bloody stool, when it is lethargic and not eating, or after eating bones when it drools, has trouble swallowing, tries to vomit but nothing comes out, or cannot pass stool. If a family member who is a child under 5, an older adult, a pregnant person or a person with weakened immunity has vomiting, diarrhea or fever and there is a raw-fed dog at home, tell the medical staff that fact. Before changing to a new diet, it is better to check the individual dog's condition together with the veterinarian you usually see.
Frequently asked questions
Q Does feeding raw food make the coat better and the teeth cleaner?
In the survey of 218 owners in Italy (BMC Veterinary Research, 2019), owners named coat shine and clean teeth as good points, but the researchers wrote that these benefits are mainly at the level of anecdote and are unproven. In the literature this article checked, I could not find a benefit confirmed by controlled studies.
Q If the raw food is frozen, can I worry less about bacteria?
The Merck Veterinary Manual says freezing and freeze-drying do not eliminate all pathogens. It is hard to say that worry about bacteria disappears because the food was frozen, and it is better to understand freezer storage as a storage rule that slows growth, not a means of eliminating bacteria.
Q Are freeze-dried products not raw food?
CDC says that freeze-drying or drying raw protein reduces bacteria but does not eliminate all of them, so freeze-dried products are also regarded as raw pet food. So it is safer to apply hygiene rules equivalent to those for ordinary raw food.
Q Is it all right to feed raw food if there are young children or older adults at home?
CDC says that children under 5, adults 65 and older, people with weakened immune systems and pregnant people can become more seriously ill from foodborne germs. If you have such family members, it is better to reconsider raw feeding, or to talk first to a veterinarian and the family doctor.
Q Is raw feeding related to antibiotic-resistant bacteria?
In a cross-sectional study comparing 190 fecal samples in the UK, raw-fed dogs shed antibiotic-resistant E. coli more often than non-raw-fed dogs (resistant E. coli 54.4% versus 17.1%). However, causation cannot be asserted, the sample is not large, and an increase in infection in people was not covered.
Q Is there no Korean material on raw pet food?
This article could not confirm official guidance dedicated to raw food from the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS), MAFRA or the Animal and Plant Quarantine Agency (APQA). A study that surveyed 62 raw foods in Korea and isolated live H9N2 avian influenza virus from 2 of them was reported in the news, but the original paper could not be opened.
Q If I want to feed raw anyway, what should I do first?
CDC advises talking to a veterinarian first if you choose raw feeding, and planning a home diet together with a veterinarian or a veterinary nutrition specialist. After that, make hygiene rules such as handwashing, disinfecting counters, freezer storage, refrigerator thawing and stopping the dog from licking into habits.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article describes only within the range of materials opened and checked directly: FDA, CDC, the Merck Veterinary Manual, 2 papers and a Korean news report. The original AVMA policy and some papers (high-pressure processing, bone complications, other resistant-bacteria studies) did not open, so no figures from them are given, and I could not confirm guidance dedicated to raw feeding from Korean agencies. The raw-food survey figures are old US data, and decisions about an individual dog's diet and the diagnosis of illness should be made with a veterinarian.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- Get the Facts! Raw Pet Food Diets can be Dangerous to You and Your Pet ↗
Used as the basis for the results of testing 196 raw foods in 2010–2012 (Salmonella in 15, Listeria in 32) and for the rules on handwashing, disinfectant solution, thawing, not rinsing and cooking temperature.
- Tips for Safe Handling of Pet Food and Treats ↗
Used as the basis for FDA's guidance that not feeding raw food is the most preferable way to prevent infection, and for the rules on handwashing and washing bowls.
- About Pet Food Safety (2025-01-30) ↗
Used as the basis for the high-risk groups, the point that freeze-dried is also classified as raw, the list of questions for manufacturers, and the rules on sealed and separate storage and stopping licking.
- Dog and Cat Foods - Management and Nutrition ↗
Used as the basis for the point that raw feeding research is limited, the list of risks, the limits of freezing, freeze-drying and high-pressure processing, and the guidance on home diets.
- Faecal carriage of Salmonella and antimicrobial-resistant E. coli in raw-fed and non-raw-fed dogs (Groat et al., 2022) ↗
Used as the basis for the comparison figures on shedding of antibiotic-resistant E. coli and Salmonella and for the study's limitations.
- Raw meat-based diets for dogs: survey of owners' motivations, attitudes and practices (2019) ↗
Used as the basis for the benefits claimed by owners, the authors' statement that the benefits are unproven, and the household composition figures.
- Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs explanatory press release (revision of the Standards and Specifications for Feeds, plan to manage pet food types) (농림축산식품부 보도설명자료(사료 등의 기준 및 규격 개정, 반려동물 사료 유형 관리 계획)) ↗
Used as the basis for the notice revised in September 2025 and the plan, scheduled to take effect in September 2028, to manage pet food types.
- Survey of 62 raw pet foods in Korea finds H9N2 avian influenza (국내 반려동물 생식사료 62개 조사해보니..H9N2형 조류인플루엔자 나왔다) ↗
Used as the basis for relaying the news report of the study of 62 raw foods in Korea (the original paper could not be confirmed).
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 2 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
