Is it a meal or a treat, and what do I look at to tell?
Whether a product is a meal or a treat is told apart by the intended use and the nutritional adequacy statement on the package. The most reliable clue is not the product's shape, size, smell or price but the intended use and the nutritional adequacy statement written on the package. This is because something that looks like bagged food may be a treat, and something that looks like a can or pouch may be a main food. In the end, the only thing an owner can judge with their own eyes is the wording on the package.
To sum up, look at three things in order. First, for a Korean product, see whether the feed type says complete feed (완전사료) or other feed (기타사료). Second, for an imported product, see whether the nutritional adequacy statement has an expression like “complete and balanced” or one like “intermittent or supplemental feeding only.” Third, see whether words such as treat or snack are written prominently on the front of the product.
If there is no label confirming that it is a main food, it is safer to avoid feeding the product as the daily meal and to understand it as a treat or supplement. Conversely, even when there is a main-food label, whether it suits your pet's age and health condition is a separate matter, so please talk to a veterinarian about that.
This article does not cover daily treat allowances or human food, and focuses on how to tell main foods and treats apart from the package label.
Why can feeding treats like a main food for a long time be a problem?
A product recognized as complete feed is made to meet set nutrition standards, and it is designed so that the product alone covers the day's nutrition. The Rural Development Administration (RDA, 농촌진흥청) describes a product labeled as complete feed as a feed that can supply the necessary nutrition when fed on its own. Treats and supplemental products, on the other hand, often do not have to meet such design conditions.
The US FDA says treats, snacks and supplements are generally not made to be a pet's sole diet and are often not complete and balanced. The US AAFCO gives as an example of such products canned tuna that lacks vitamins and minerals. This means that even if the taste and palatability are good, essential nutrients may be missing or skewed to one side.
So if treats or supplemental products fill the place of the main food for a long time, an imbalance can arise in which certain nutrients run short and others become excessive. Which nutrients fall short, and by how much, differs from product to product, and it can take time before symptoms appear. For that reason, it is hard to judge that things are fine just because no problem is noticeable.
Growing pets, pets that are pregnant or nursing, and pets with a chronic illness may have more sensitive nutritional needs. In such cases it is better to be sure to talk to a veterinarian before changing the main food. This article is a general explanation of how to read labels, not a diagnosis or feeding instruction.
How does Korea divide complete feed and other feed?
The Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) announced that it is newly introducing nutrition standards for dog and cat food. A product that meets the nutrient requirements for each growth stage can be labeled pet complete feed (반려동물완전사료), and a product that does not is classified as pet other feed (반려동물기타사료). The nutrition standard, which is the benchmark for nutrient requirements, was prepared by the National Institute of Animal Science (NIAS).
The Rural Development Administration (RDA) explains that this nutrition standard presents recommended amounts of essential nutrients and energy requirements by life stage, adapted to Korean conditions, and that MAFRA revised the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) notice and newly created Annex 15-2. It says that, in consideration of the industry's preparation time, a 3-year grace period is set starting in 2025, and the system is scheduled to be fully enforced from 2028.
DailyVet (데일리벳), a Korean veterinary trade publication, explains that the aim of this system is to let consumers tell apart feed that can be fed as a main food from feed that should be fed only like a treat. That article interprets complete feed as feed composed to meet all the nutrient requirements for each growth stage without any separate nutrition supply, and reports that a company that wants to label a product as complete feed must be able, where necessary, to prove through a feed testing institution, an accredited testing institution or the like that it was manufactured in line with the nutrition standard.
There is a caution here. Before the grace period ends, the labels on products on the market may still vary. Products that already use the new label and products that use the old style of label can be distributed side by side, so if the feed type field is blank or ambiguous, it is better to ask the manufacturer or seller directly about the intended use. The materials consulted for this article did not confirm the details of how other feed is divided into sub-uses such as treats and nutrition-adjustment products, so this article does not assert it.
How does this differ from overseas labeling?
US feed labeling is based on the AAFCO model regulations, and the nutritional adequacy statement is printed in small type on the back or side of the package. AAFCO explains that this statement is used in one of the set formats, and for example begins by saying the product was formulated to meet the levels set by the AAFCO dog or cat food nutrient profiles. The target stage, such as growth, adult dog or cat maintenance, or all life stages, is written alongside it.
The US FDA explains that the nutritional adequacy statement on the label tells whether the product can be the sole diet, and that the key expression is “complete and balanced.” To use this expression, a product must meet the AAFCO nutrient profiles or pass a feeding trial under AAFCO procedures. It adds that endorsements or certification marks from other organizations do not guarantee nutritional adequacy.
Products that are not main foods carry a statement such as “This product is intended for intermittent or supplemental feeding only.” The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that products that do not meet the complete and balanced requirement must use this statement and are suitable only for limited, intermittent or supplemental feeding. AAFCO says that treats and snacks are exempt from the nutritional adequacy requirement if a word such as snack or treat is written prominently on the front of the package.
There are two main differences between Korea and the US. Korea, under its new system, divides the feed type itself into complete feed and other feed, and bases the criterion on a nutrition standard prepared by the state. The US communicates through the nutritional adequacy statement, not through a type name. Also, overseas statements follow the laws and standards of the country concerned, so you cannot assume that a foreign statement means the same thing as Korea's complete feed label.
Where do toppers, mixers and freeze-dried products belong?
Toppers and mixers are products put on top of or mixed into food, and freeze-dried products are products with the moisture removed. Such names describe only the product's form or how it is used, and do not tell you whether it is a main food or a treat. The public materials consulted for this article did not explain that products are classified separately by these forms, so the key point is not to judge a product to be a main food from its form name alone.
Tell them apart the same way. Even for a freeze-dried product, if the package has a complete feed label or a “complete and balanced” statement, it can be read as designed to be a main food in the sense of that label. Conversely, if a product is labeled a topper or mixer and carries supplemental wording, it is hard to regard it as a product that fills a meal on its own.
FEDIAF, the European pet food industry association, also has guidance that distinguishes feed for sole feeding (complete) from other feed (complementary), but the original text could not be opened and checked while writing this article, so its content is not covered.
A situation that is easy to confuse is gradually increasing a product mixed into food because the pet likes it. If the mixed-in product is supplemental, the nutritional makeup of the whole diet can change as the share of the main food shrinks. When using such products, it is safer to talk to a veterinarian about how to adjust the amount of food.
What should I check on the package before buying?
The table below lists the labels you can find on a package and their general meanings. The meaning of a label can differ by country and over time, so use it as a reference.
After looking at the table, it is good to check in the following order.
- See whether the feed type field says complete feed (완전사료) or other feed (기타사료).
- For an imported product, see whether there is a nutritional adequacy statement and, if so, whether the target stage suits your pet.
- See whether words such as treat or snack appear on the front.
- Check whether the directions for use say to feed it alone or to put it on top of or mix it into food.
- If the wording is ambiguous or cannot be found, ask the manufacturer or seller about the intended use.
The National Institute of Animal Science (NIAS) says the Korean labeling items include the ingredient registration number, name and form, ingredient names, intended use of the feed, actual weight, manufacture date and sell-by date, and manufacturer information. It was confirmed that there is a separate field for the intended use of the feed, but the specific way the intended-use field is filled in could not be confirmed in this article.
| Label | General meaning | May it be read as a main food? |
|---|---|---|
| Pet complete feed (반려동물완전사료) | Labeled as feed that meets the nutrition standards for each growth stage | Possible under the labeling standard; whether it suits your pet is a separate check |
| Pet other feed (반려동물기타사료) | Classified as feed that does not meet the nutrition standards | Do not assume it is a main food |
| complete and balanced | Meets a US-standard nutrient profile or passed a feeding trial | Possible per the label; check the target life stage |
| intermittent or supplemental feeding only | A label saying to use it only occasionally or as a supplement | No |
| snack, treat labeling | Labeled as a treat, which can exempt it from the nutritional adequacy requirement | No |
What are the common misunderstandings about treats and main foods?
The first misunderstanding is the idea that if it looks like kibble, it is a main food. Even kibble-shaped pieces can be for use as treats. The intended use must be checked from the label, not the shape.
The second misunderstanding is the idea that if the ingredients look good, the balance will also be right. Ingredient names looking good and nutrients being included in balance are different matters. The US FDA also says endorsements or certification marks from other organizations do not guarantee nutritional adequacy. In the direction of the Korean revision as well, the intent is for complete feed to be required to prove that it meets the nutrition standards.
The third misunderstanding is the idea that if there is wording saying humans can eat it, it is enough as a main food. MAFRA says that labels such as “human-edible” must follow the laws on food that people eat, but this is a statement about the safety of ingredients and does not mean nutritional balance.
The fourth misunderstanding is the idea that the term other feed means a bad product. Other feed is only a classification for feed not labeled as complete feed that meets the nutrition standards, and it is not an assessment of low quality. It can be used appropriately for supplemental or treat purposes. The important point, though, is not to fill a meal with it alone.
The fifth misunderstanding is the idea that it is fine because the pet eats it well. High palatability does not mean the nutrition is right. Eating well and having sufficient nutrition must be checked separately.
In these cases, talk to a veterinarian
In the following situations, it is better not to rely on the package label alone and to talk to a veterinarian. This article is general information and does not replace an individual diagnosis or prescription.
- When treats or supplemental products have been replacing the main food for a long time and you do not know how to change the diet from here
- When your pet will eat only one product and has been refusing its food for several days
- When weight has noticeably increased or decreased, the coat or skin condition has changed, or energy has dropped
- When the diet needs to be chosen carefully because of a growth stage, pregnancy or nursing, old age or a chronic illness
- When your pet is eating a prescription diet or a diet for a specific condition and you want to add a topper or treat
When you consult, it helps to take photos of the package of the product you are feeding, both front and back, and to write down for several days what your pet eats in a day. This is because the product name, feed type, nutritional adequacy statement and feeding method can then be checked.
When the diet needs to change, do not change it suddenly; proceed slowly following the veterinarian's guidance. Each pet differs in digestion and health conditions, so it is hard to assume that this article's general explanation applies as is to your pet.
Frequently asked questions
Q If my pet eats treats well, can I give them instead of the main food?
If the package does not have a main-food label such as complete feed (완전사료) or “complete and balanced,” giving it in place of the main food is not recommended. This is because treats and supplemental products may be balanced in nutrition only in part. To change the diet, talk to a veterinarian first.
Q Is other feed (기타사료) a feed that must not be fed?
No. Other feed is a classification for feed not labeled as complete feed that meets the nutrition standards. It can be used as a treat or supplement, but it is safer not to regard it as a product that fills a meal on its own.
Q Does the complete feed label apply to every product now?
The Rural Development Administration (RDA) says a 3-year grace period is set starting in 2025 and full enforcement is scheduled from 2028. During the grace period the new label and the old label can be distributed together, so it is better to check the feed type and intended use yourself before buying.
Q What is the difference between the “complete and balanced” statement and the “intermittent or supplemental feeding only” statement?
The former is a label meaning that the product meets a US-standard nutrient profile or passed a feeding trial and can be the sole diet. The latter is a label meaning that the product does not meet the nutritional requirements and should be used only occasionally or as a supplement.
Q Is a freeze-dried product or topper a main food or a treat?
You cannot tell from the name or form alone. Judge by whether the package has a complete feed label or a “complete and balanced” statement, or a supplemental or treat statement. If it is hard to check, it is better to ask the manufacturer.
Q If there is a main-food label, is it always right for my pet?
No. A main-food label means the nutrition is met under that standard, and whether it suits age, health condition and allergies is a separate matter. Check the target life stage, and talk to a veterinarian about any questions.
Limits and scope of this guide
This is a general explanation for pet owners and is not a diagnosis or feeding instruction for an individual pet. Because Korea's new labeling system is in a grace period, labels on products on the market may vary, and the detailed sub-use classification of other feed and the classification criteria for toppers, mixers and freeze-dried products could not be confirmed in the materials consulted. The original text of the European FEDIAF guidance could not be confirmed.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- Reading Labels ↗
Used as the basis for explaining the format of the complete and balanced statement, the intermittent or supplemental feeding only statement, and the conditions for the treat-label exemption.
- "Complete and Balanced" Pet Food ↗
Used as the basis for the point that the nutritional adequacy statement tells whether a product can be a main food, and the point that treats and supplements are often not complete and balanced foods.
- Dog and Cat Foods ↗
Used as the basis for the explanation that products that do not meet the complete and balanced requirement must use the intermittent or supplemental feeding statement.
- Press release on the revision of pet food labeling standards (반려동물 사료 표시 기준 개정안 보도자료) ↗
Used as the basis for the division into complete feed and other feed by whether nutrition standards are met, who prepares the nutrition standard, and the direction of the revision of labeling items.
- Pet food will also be managed under a national standard (press release) (반려동물 사료도 국가 기준으로 관리한다 (보도자료)) ↗
Used as the basis for the nutrition standard and the creation of Annex 15-2, the explanation of sole feeding of complete feed, and the schedule of a 3-year grace period from 2025 and full enforcement in 2028.
- Complete feed? Other feed? What changed with the new labeling for pet food (완전사료? 기타사료? 반려동물사료 표시사항 신설, 무엇이 달라졌나) ↗
Used as the basis for the aim of letting consumers tell apart feed for use as a main food from feed fed only like a treat, and for the explanation of the requirement to prove a product is complete feed.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 1 Korean law or notice. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
