Skip to content
Grochi · Neutral pet information from South Korea · English edition한국어
Grochi.English edition
Veterinary clinics

Why anesthesia is used for dental scaling, and the South Korean legal position

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. This page is an English translation of the Korean edition as checked on 2026-11-23. If the two differ, the Korean edition is the reference. 한국어판 (Korean edition)

Why anesthesia is used for dental scaling, and the South Korean legal position
Short answer

The American Veterinary Dental College says anesthesia-free scaling is not appropriate for dogs and cats, citing cleaning below the gum line, a complete oral examination and airway protection. The World Small Animal Veterinary Association and the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association also take a negative view of dental procedures without anesthesia. This article also covers the position under South Korea's Veterinarians Act.

Key takeaways

  • In a position statement adopted in 2004, the American Veterinary Dental College (AVDC) explains that access to the space below the gum line of every tooth is impossible in a dog or cat that is not anesthetized, and that a complete oral examination cannot be done, and says anesthesia-free scaling is not appropriate.
  • The dental guidelines of the World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) describe dentistry without anesthesia as ineffective or even damaging, and the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association (CVMA) considers dental procedures without anesthesia or sedation to be associated with animal welfare concerns while offering only minimal health benefit.
  • The AVDC also acknowledges that anesthesia is never completely risk-free. For that reason, asking the clinic about the health evaluation before anesthesia, monitoring during anesthesia and recovery care is a practical response for owners.
  • South Korea's Veterinarians Act (수의사법) provides that only a veterinarian may treat animals (Article 10), but this article did not directly confirm the original text of any official decision that scaling counts as treatment under the Act, and confirmed it only through a 2015 trade-press report.
  • The descriptions of the 20 items in the 2025 animal hospital fee survey by the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) do not mention scaling or anesthesia, so this article gives no scaling cost figures.

Why is anesthesia used for scaling? A short answer first

General anesthesia is used for scaling in dogs and cats not only because they will not hold their mouths open the way people do. The American Veterinary Dental College (AVDC) position statement explains that anesthesia has three advantages: it replaces the patient's cooperation, it removes pain during treatment, and it protects the airway and lungs from accidental aspiration (AVDC position statement, checked 2026-11-23). Add to this cleaning below the gum line and examining every tooth one by one, and the AVDC considers procedures without anesthesia not appropriate.

The professional-body materials this article checked are those of the AVDC, the World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA), summaries of the guidelines of the American Animal Hospital Association (AAHA), the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association (CVMA), and the Merck Veterinary Manual. The AVDC, WSAVA and CVMA take a negative view of procedures without anesthesia, the Merck manual writes that cleaning an awake animal does not improve periodontal health, and the AAHA abstract has no sentence on this point. Not every source speaks with the same strength, so this article states what each body actually wrote, together with the name of the body.

Being worried about anesthesia is natural. The AVDC statement itself acknowledges that it is natural for owners to be concerned when told their pet needs anesthesia. The same document admits that anesthesia is never completely risk-free, while explaining that modern anesthetic and patient evaluation techniques used in veterinary hospitals minimize the risks. This article does not say there is no risk. It sets out what the risk-reducing steps are and what owners can ask.

This article does not evaluate any particular animal hospital or business, and it does not judge whether anesthesia is right for your pet. Whether an individual animal can be anesthetized can only be judged by the veterinarian who knows its age, underlying conditions and test results. This article is an editorial draft and has had no professional review by a veterinarian. Brushing and oral-care products are covered in Grochi's basic pet dental care article and its product comparison article, so they are not repeated here.

Why is scaling under general anesthesia recommended?

The reasons given in the AVDC statement (adopted by its board on April 10, 2004) are specific. First, tartar is firmly attached to the tooth surface and is removed with ultrasonic and sonic scalers and hand instruments with a sharp working edge, and the statement explains that even slight head movement can injure the oral tissues and the person working can be bitten.

Second, the statement explains that professional scaling covers the tooth surfaces both above and below the gum line and is followed by polishing. The most critical part is the tooth surface inside the gingival pocket, the space between the gum and the root, where periodontal disease is active. In people, a trained professional can scale teeth without anesthesia because the patient cooperates, but the AVDC writes that access to the space below the gum line of every tooth is impossible in an unanesthetized dog or cat. It also says that removing tartar only from the visible tooth surfaces has little effect on the animal's health, gives a false sense of accomplishment, and that the effect is purely cosmetic.

Third is the complete oral examination. The AVDC considers the complete oral examination, an important part of professional scaling, impossible in an unanesthetized patient. The tooth surfaces facing the tongue cannot be examined, and areas of disease and discomfort are likely to be missed.

Fourth is airway protection. The AVDC explains that inhalation anesthesia using a cuffed endotracheal tube protects the airway and lungs from accidental aspiration.

Fifth is dental radiography (X-rays). The periodontal disease entry for small animals in the Merck Veterinary Manual says the 2019 AAHA Dental Care Guidelines strongly recommend full-mouth intraoral dental radiography in all dental patients (Merck Veterinary Manual, checked 2026-11-23). The entry also describes periodontal disease as diagnosed and treated under general anesthesia by trained veterinary professionals, and writes that cleaning an awake animal improves the cosmetic appearance of the tooth crowns but does not improve periodontal health. This article could not open the relevant sentence of the AAHA guidelines itself (see the next section) and confirmed the radiography recommendation through the Merck manual's introduction of it.

Reasons given for scaling under anesthesia (as confirmed in the AVDC statement and the Merck Veterinary Manual)
ReasonWhat the source explainsWhere confirmed
Cleaning below the gum lineThe tooth surface inside the gingival pocket, where periodontal disease is active, is the most critical part, but access below the gum line of every tooth is impossible in a dog or cat that is not anesthetizedAVDC statement
Complete oral examinationThe tooth surfaces facing the tongue cannot be seen, and areas of disease or discomfort are likely to be missedAVDC statement
Safety and painRisk of tissue injury from movement and of being bitten; removal of pain during treatmentAVDC statement
Airway protectionInhalation anesthesia with a cuffed endotracheal tube protects the airway and lungs from accidental aspirationAVDC statement
Dental radiographyIntroduces the 2019 AAHA guidelines as strongly recommending full-mouth intraoral radiography in all dental patientsMerck Veterinary Manual

How do professional bodies view anesthesia-free scaling? Wording by body

There are several terms for scaling without anesthesia. The AVDC stated in its position statement that it prefers the term Non-Professional Dental Scaling (NPDS) as more accurate than the commonly used "anesthesia-free dentistry." This article uses "scaling without anesthesia" in line with common usage, but tried to convey each body's wording as it was written.

The AVDC says that performing non-professional dental scaling on an unanesthetized pet is inappropriate for the reasons summarized in the previous section. The statement also says that safe use of anesthetics or sedatives requires evaluating the patient's general health and size, determining the drug and dose, and continual monitoring, and that prescribing or administering anesthetic or sedative drugs by a non-veterinarian can be very dangerous and is illegal. This last sentence is phrased for the United States and Canada, and the Korean legal position is covered separately in another section.

The World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) Global Dental Guidelines were published in an edition issued in 2020 (Journal of Small Animal Practice, volume 61, issue 7), followed by a revised edition in 2026 (same journal, volume 67, issue 10). The abstracts of both editions say the guidelines include a discussion of the deleterious effects of anesthesia-free dentistry, and describe this procedure as "ineffective at best and damaging at worst." This sentence is in the abstract of the guidelines themselves (WSAVA guidelines abstract, checked 2026-11-23). This article confirmed the sentence only in the abstract and could not open the body of the guidelines, so it does not cite detailed supporting points from the body.

In its dental position statement dated October 21, 2022, the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association (CVMA) stated that it considers anesthesia-free or sedation-free dentistry, including non-professional dental scaling, to be inappropriate since these practices are associated with animal welfare concerns while offering only minimal health benefits for the animal (CVMA position statement, checked 2026-11-23).

The abstract of the American Animal Hospital Association (AAHA) 2019 Dental Care Guidelines describes a 12-step protocol for oral health assessment, dental cleaning and periodontal therapy, and says the guidelines include recommendations on general anesthesia, pain management, facilities and equipment (Europe PMC abstract, checked 2026-11-23). This article could not open the original AAHA guidelines, so it does not directly quote any sentence AAHA wrote about anesthesia-free dentistry. It states only that this abstract includes recommendations on anesthesia.

That the positions of the AVDC, WSAVA and CVMA point in the same direction is a fact this article confirmed, but it does not replace decisions about an individual animal's procedure. Which animals can tolerate anesthesia and what evaluation is needed beforehand is judged by the treating veterinarian from medical records and tests.

Positions on dental procedures without anesthesia, by body (within the range confirmed in each source)
BodySource and datePosition this article confirmed
AVDC (American Veterinary Dental College)Position statement, adopted 2004-04-10Non-professional dental scaling of an unanesthetized animal is not appropriate
WSAVA (World Small Animal Veterinary Association)Dental guidelines abstract, 2020 edition (volume 61, issue 7) and 2026 edition (volume 67, issue 10)Dentistry without anesthesia is ineffective or even damaging
CVMA (Canadian Veterinary Medical Association)Dental position statement, 2022-10-21Dental procedures without anesthesia or sedation are not appropriate
AAHA (American Animal Hospital Association)2019 Dental Care Guidelines abstractIncludes recommendations on general anesthesia (the abstract has no sentence on anesthesia-free procedures; the original could not be opened)
Merck Veterinary ManualPeriodontal disease in small animals entry, full review February 2024, updated April 2025Cleaning the teeth of an awake animal improves only the cosmetic appearance of the crowns and does not improve periodontal health

What can you ask the clinic if you are worried about anesthesia?

The way to reduce worry about anesthesia is not to avoid it but to know how it is prepared for and managed. The AVDC statement says that safe use of anesthetics or sedatives requires evaluating the patient's general health and size and continual monitoring. In line with this standard, these are questions an owner can ask the clinic in a dental context. General anesthesia questions for surgery are covered further in Grochi's article on questions to ask before surgical anesthesia, so only a short, dentistry-specific list is given here.

  • How do you evaluate my pet's health before anesthesia? Which tests are included, and could the anesthesia plan change depending on the results?
  • How do you decide the anesthesia method, taking my pet's age, weight and underlying conditions into account?
  • Who keeps watching my pet's condition during anesthesia, and which items are monitored?
  • Do you use an endotracheal tube? How is the airway protected during cleaning?
  • Is dental radiography included? If the results make an extraction or further treatment necessary, in what order are the cost and the decision handled?
  • If a problem is found during the procedure and the plan changes, how will you contact me?
  • Where and how will recovery be monitored, and what should I watch for at home after discharge, and what number should I call?

The last two questions are also linked to cost. This article did not confirm whether Korea's explanation-and-consent rules for major treatment such as surgery apply to scaling. So it helps to get the expected cost and the possibility of additional procedures in writing or by text message even before scaling. Responding to veterinary fee disputes is covered in Grochi's article on animal hospital fee disputes.

There is no reason for a clinic to be bothered by questions, and the more specific the explanation, the easier it is for owners to decide. However, this article does not evaluate the quality of the answers. If you feel the explanation is not sufficient, hearing another clinic's opinion is the owner's choice.

How does the Veterinarians Act treat scaling by grooming shops or businesses in South Korea?

Article 10 (prohibition of unlicensed treatment) of the Veterinarians Act (수의사법) at the National Law Information Center (law.go.kr) (in force November 13, 2026, Act No. 21623) provides that no one other than a veterinarian may treat animals. Exceptions are made for treatment of aquatic animals by a person holding an aquatic animal disease control license and for treatment prescribed by Presidential Decree (National Law Information Center, checked 2026-11-23). Article 2 defines the animal veterinary business as the business of treating animals or preventing animal diseases. Article 2 does not spell out which acts "treatment" includes. So whether scaling counts as treatment cannot be known from these two articles alone, and the interpretation has to be checked.

Under Article 39, paragraph 1, item 2, a person who treated an animal in violation of Article 10 is subject to imprisonment for up to 2 years or a fine of up to KRW 20,000,000, and both may be imposed together. Article 16-5 of the same Act provides that, notwithstanding Article 10, an animal health technician may perform nursing or treatment-assistance work for animals under the direction of a veterinarian within an animal hospital. Because this provision limits its scope to "within an animal hospital, under the direction of a veterinarian," it is not a provision that addresses scaling done by a business outside an animal hospital. This article did not open the specific list of exceptional treatments set by Presidential Decree.

How, then, were scaling services at grooming shops or animal sales businesses judged? This article could not directly open the original text of any official Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) document, court judgment or Korean Veterinary Medical Association position saying that scaling is a treatment act. So it does not claim to have confirmed an official judgment's original. However, an article published on July 13, 2015 by Dailyvet, a veterinary trade publication, reports that in a case where a local animal sales business performed scaling without anesthesia using a household tooth-cleaning device, MAFRA replied that this was judged to be a violation of Article 10 of the Veterinarians Act (Dailyvet article, checked 2026-11-23). The same article reports that MAFRA regarded scaling in the veterinary field as well as a treatment act carried out to prevent and treat gum disease and the like. This is secondary information confirmed through a newspaper article and concerns an individual case about 11 years ago, so it cannot be generalized to the current interpretation or to every business. The fine ceiling stated in that article also differs from the current statute, so this article uses only the figures in the current statute.

The practical meaning for owners is this. Even if a business advertises that it removes tartar without anesthesia, an owner cannot sort out whether that is legally permitted. This article does not judge individually whether such businesses are legal or illegal. If you want to know the legal position, it is appropriate to contact the MAFRA companion and livestock animal veterinary medicine team or the animal-related department of the city, county or district office with jurisdiction.

How do overseas standards differ from South Korea's, and how do you look into costs?

The statements of professional bodies in the United States and Canada raise the licensing question together with the medical limits of procedures without anesthesia. The AVDC writes that only licensed veterinarians may practice veterinary medicine in the United States and Canada, and takes the position that dental services provided by anyone other than a veterinarian or a supervised, trained veterinary technician amount to practicing without a license. In Korea too, Article 10 of the Veterinarians Act lets only veterinarians treat animals, but the detailed structure, such as the animal health technician system and the exceptional treatments, is not the same as the US veterinary technician system. So the legal sentences of a foreign statement should not be read across to Korea as they are.

The medical grounds should be viewed differently. Reasons such as no access below the gum line, no complete oral examination and airway protection are explanations about animal anatomy and the way a procedure is done regardless of country, so they are material for owners in Korea too. But this article does not make that judgment for you; it only reports that professional bodies explain it this way.

This article does not summarize costs as figures. The press release of MAFRA's nationwide animal hospital fee survey (3,950 clinics surveyed), announced on December 22, 2025, describes the survey items as 20 types of fees that clinics are required to post, divided into 2 types of consultation (examination) fees, consultation fee, hospitalization fee, 6 types of vaccination fees, 3 types of blood test fees, 4 types of imaging test fees, and 3 types of medication and dispensing fees (MAFRA press release, checked 2026-11-23). Scaling and anesthesia items were not found in this press release. This article did not open the individual clinic and item screens of the fee survey and disclosure system. So there are no public-data figures for scaling cost in this article.

Scaling cost can vary with pre-anesthesia tests, anesthesia time, dental radiography and the scope of the procedure, so asking the clinic item by item and getting the expected cost in writing is the way to go. This article does not judge which price is appropriate.

What are the common misunderstandings?

The first misunderstanding is that removing visible tartar is enough. The AVDC statement says that removing tartar from visible surfaces has little effect on the animal's health and that the effect is purely cosmetic. The Merck Veterinary Manual entry on periodontal disease in small animals likewise explains that cleaning an awake animal improves only the appearance of the crowns and does not improve periodontal health. This is in line with the explanation that the problem of periodontal disease lies mainly below the gum line.

The second misunderstanding is that anesthesia always leads to a serious accident. The AVDC says anesthesia is never completely risk-free but explains that modern anesthetic techniques and patient evaluation in veterinary hospitals minimize the risk, and that millions of dental scaling procedures are safely performed in hospitals every year. This figure is the AVDC's wording in its 2004 statement and is not a statistic this article verified separately. An explanation that risk is low does not mean your own pet's risk is low. If your pet is old or has an underlying condition, the treating veterinarian makes a separate judgment through the pre-anesthesia evaluation.

The third misunderstanding is that a method without anesthesia is gentler and safer. The abstract of the WSAVA guidelines describes dentistry without anesthesia as ineffective or even damaging. The AVDC explains that if the animal moves, oral tissues can be injured and the operator can be bitten. It means that the impression of safety and actual safety are not the same.

The fourth misunderstanding is that good brushing means scaling is never needed. The AVDC recommends daily home care from an early age, such as brushing, as helping to reduce the need for dental procedures, and also mentions periodic examination by a veterinarian and scaling under anesthesia when indicated. The structure of this statement is that home care is not a replacement but is done alongside. For brushing methods and products, see Grochi's pet dental care articles.

The fifth misunderstanding is that asking questions because you are worried about anesthesia shows distrust of the clinic. Evaluation before anesthesia and monitoring are what the AVDC names as conditions for safe use, so asking about them is a legitimate check.

When to talk to a veterinarian

This article is not a diagnosis or treatment instruction. In the following situations, it is better to have a veterinarian look at the mouth first rather than deliberating over scaling. These are when the breath has become very bad, when your pet chews on only one side or is reluctant to eat, when it begins to dislike having the area around the mouth touched, when the gums are red or bleeding, and when teeth look loose or broken. Whether the cause of such signs is tartar or another oral disease cannot be sorted out by owners, and whether anesthesia is needed is decided after an examination.

If, after anesthesia, you see worrying changes at home, such as signs of difficulty breathing or being unusually lethargic, contact the clinic that discharged your pet right away and follow its instructions. This standard is not a sentence from the documents this article checked but general safety guidance, and the contact details and instructions the clinic gave at discharge take priority.

If your pet is old or has an underlying condition such as heart or kidney disease and you are more worried about anesthesia, the first step is to discuss it with the clinic after seeing the results of the pre-anesthesia evaluation. If the clinic's plan does not seem convincing, you may seek another clinic's opinion. If you come across a business offering scaling without anesthesia, check whether it is an animal hospital where a veterinarian treats animals and how far it can go without anesthesia and radiography, and also refer to the explanations of the professional bodies introduced in this article. If you are curious about legal issues, contact MAFRA or your local government.

Frequently asked questions

Q Why is general anesthesia used for scaling?

The AVDC statement explains that anesthesia replaces the patient's cooperation, removes pain and protects the airway and lungs with an endotracheal tube. It also holds that cleaning the tooth surfaces below the gum line and a complete oral examination are impossible in a dog or cat that is not anesthetized.

Q How do professional bodies view anesthesia-free scaling?

The AVDC stated that non-professional dental scaling of an animal that is not anesthetized is not appropriate, and the abstract of the WSAVA guidelines describes it as ineffective or even damaging. The CVMA considers dental procedures without anesthesia or sedation inappropriate. This article does not quote any sentence from the original AAHA text, which it could not open.

Q Is anesthesia completely free of risk?

No. The AVDC also acknowledges that anesthesia is never completely risk-free, and explains that modern anesthetic techniques and patient evaluation in hospitals minimize the risks. So it is a good idea to ask the clinic about evaluation before anesthesia, monitoring and recovery care.

Q What can I ask the clinic before anesthesia?

You can ask about the pre-anesthesia health evaluation and tests, who monitors during anesthesia and how, the endotracheal tube and airway protection, whether dental radiography is included, how you will be contacted and what the cost will be if the plan changes, and the recovery instructions after discharge.

Q Is scaling without anesthesia by a grooming shop or business illegal in South Korea?

Article 10 of the Veterinarians Act (수의사법) provides that only veterinarians may treat animals, but this article did not confirm the original text of any official decision that scaling counts as treatment. It confirmed only that a 2015 trade-press report relayed a reply from the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, and it does not judge whether any individual business is legal.

Q How much does scaling cost?

The descriptions of the 20 items in the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs' 2025 fee survey do not mention scaling or anesthesia, so this article gives no public-data figures. Asking the clinic for the expected cost of each item in writing is the way to go.

Limits and scope of this guide

This article is an editorial draft, has had no professional review by a veterinarian or a lawyer, and is not legal advice. It summarizes the public positions of overseas professional bodies on scaling in dogs and cats and does not judge whether an individual animal can be anesthetized or needs a procedure. The original text of the 2019 AAHA guidelines, the body of the WSAVA guidelines and the policy of the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) could not be opened, and statements of those bodies were written only within what was confirmed through abstracts or other materials. This article could not confirm the original text of any official judgment by the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, the courts or the Korean Veterinary Medical Association that scaling counts as a treatment act under the Korean Veterinarians Act, and it also did not open the list of exceptional treatments in the Enforcement Decree of the Veterinarians Act. Legal interpretation and whether an individual business is lawful should be confirmed with the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, the local government with jurisdiction or a legal professional. Scaling costs could not be confirmed from public data and are not given. The content of this article does not apply to animals other than dogs and cats, such as rabbits and rodents.

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.

Sources and check dates

  1. Companion Animal Dental Scaling Without Anesthesia (position statement, adopted by the board 2004-04-10) ↗

    Basis for the reasons for scaling under anesthesia (cleaning below the gum line, oral examination, airway protection), the position on scaling without anesthesia, and the explanation of anesthesia risk.

  2. World Small Animal Veterinary Association Global Dental Guidelines (JSAP 2026;67(10), abstract) ↗

    Basis for the abstract sentence that the WSAVA guidelines describe dentistry without anesthesia as ineffective or even damaging (the body could not be opened).

  3. 2019 AAHA Dental Care Guidelines for Dogs and Cats (abstract) ↗

    Basis for the abstract's description that the AAHA guidelines include a 12-step protocol and recommendations on general anesthesia and pain management (the original on the AAHA website could not be opened).

  4. Periodontal Disease in Small Animals (Veterinary Manual) ↗

    Basis for the explanation that cleaning an awake animal improves only the cosmetic appearance of the crowns, diagnosis and treatment under anesthesia, and the introduction of the 2019 AAHA recommendation for dental radiography.

  5. Veterinary Dentistry (position statement, 2022-10-21) ↗

    Basis for the CVMA position on dental procedures without anesthesia or sedation (including non-professional dental scaling).

  6. Veterinarians Act (수의사법) (in force 2026-11-13, Act No. 21623), Articles 2, 10, 16-5 and 39 ↗

    Basis for the original text of the prohibition of unlicensed treatment, the definition of the animal veterinary business, the work of animal health technicians, and the penalty provision.

  7. Announcement of results of the nationwide animal hospital fee survey (전국 동물병원 진료비 현황조사 결과 발표) (2025-12-22) ↗

    Basis for confirming the 3,950 clinics surveyed and the composition of the 20 survey items, and that scaling and anesthesia are not in the item descriptions.

  8. "Anesthesia-free scaling pet shop, violation of the Veterinarians Act" (무마취 스케일링 애견샵, 수의사법 위반) (article, 2015-07-13) ↗

    Basis for the 2015 report that a reply from the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs existed (secondary information; the original reply could not be opened).

Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.

This guide relies on 2 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.