Dry and wet food: what should be matched first to make the basis the same?
You can compare dry and wet food on the same basis by going through moisture adjustment, matching calorie units, calculating daily cost, and splitting calories when mixing, in that order, and the first thing to match is moisture. Even when they hold the same weight, the water in dry and wet food differs greatly, so comparing the protein or fat percentages printed on the package directly always makes wet food look disadvantaged. This article is not about weighing the pros and cons of the two types. It sets out the order in which an owner who is already deciding between the two can read the numbers on the same yardstick.
The order has four steps. First, adjust for the moisture difference so that the nutrient percentages are on the same conditions. Second, check calorie units (calories per kilogram, calories per can) instead of nutrient percentages. Third, calculate the amount and cost needed to meet the day's calorie requirement. Fourth, decide how to divide the daily calories when feeding both.
Following this order changes what the same package numbers mean. For example, a wet food with 9 percent protein and a dry food with 30 percent protein look more than 3 times apart on the surface, but once moisture is put on the same conditions, that gap shrinks considerably. Conversely, a can price that makes wet food look cheaper than dry food can give a completely different result when converted to daily calories.
One caution. The numbers and prices in this article are hypothetical examples made up to show the calculation method. They are not real values for any product, and they do not mean how much to feed per day. An owner can run the same calculation with the package numbers of the product their pet eats.
Why does comparing package numbers directly go wrong?
Most nutrient figures on a package are measured on the product as it comes. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) says that the guaranteed analysis must include the maximum percentage of moisture, and that calories are also stated on an as-fed basis, meaning the food as it is fed. In other words, the package numbers include the moisture as it is.
Cats Protection, a UK cat welfare charity, explains that the moisture in wet food is about 70 percent. Dry food has far less moisture than wet food, so even 100 grams of each holds a very different share of nutrients. In 100 grams of wet food most of it is water, and in 100 grams of dry food there is almost no water.
For this reason, the protein percentage on a package looks smaller the more moisture there is. A smaller percentage does not mean the protein quality is low or that nutrition is lacking. It only means there is a lot of water in the denominator. To compare dry and wet food directly, you need to remove that share of water and look at them with the same denominator.
For the same reason, feeding amounts are also hard to compare simply. A handful of dry food and a can of wet food can have similar energy even though their weights differ, and conversely, even when the weights are similar the energy can differ greatly. So converting to a calorie basis rather than weight or volume is the simplest method.
In short, moisture creates two kinds of mismatch. One is a mismatch in nutrient percentages, and the other is a mismatch between feeding weight and energy. The former is solved by converting to a dry matter basis, and the latter by converting to a calorie basis.
How do I calculate to adjust for moisture?
The way to adjust for moisture is the dry matter basis conversion. It assumes all the water has been removed from the product and finds the share a nutrient takes up within the remaining solids. The formula is simple: divide the nutrient percentage on the package by the value of 100 minus the moisture percentage, then multiply by 100. The detailed calculation steps and cautions are explained in a separate article on the dry matter basis calculation, so here we only take a short look at the concept and an example.
A hypothetical example. Say a dry food has 10 percent moisture and 30 percent protein. Solids are 90 percent, so protein is 30 divided by 90, or about 33 percent. If a wet food has 80 percent moisture and 9 percent protein, solids are 20 percent, so it is 9 divided by 20, or 45 percent. By the package numbers the dry food looked more than 3 times higher, but when put on the same conditions the wet food actually comes out higher.
This example is meant to show how numbers can flip, and it is not a conclusion that wet food is better. The dry matter percentage is only a tool for making the comparison fair, and it does not tell you the quality of the nutrition or digestibility. A higher protein percentage does not immediately make a food more suitable for a pet.
For the moisture value you need in the calculation, you can use the maximum moisture percentage on the package. However, this value is often printed as a maximum and may differ slightly from the actual figure, and in Korea the items shown can differ by product type, so if the package has no moisture figure you may need to ask the manufacturer. If the number is missing, it is better not to force in a guess.
What changes when I look at it in calories?
A calorie-based comparison is more intuitive than a dry matter one. What an owner really cares about is how much energy the pet eats in a day, more than nutrient percentages. AAFCO says that calorie statements are given in kilocalories per kilogram and also per familiar unit such as can, cup or biscuit. So you can look up both units.
Check the units first. Dry food is commonly printed in calories per kilogram (kcal/kg), and wet food in calories for one can (kcal/can). To compare the two, you have to convert them to the same unit. If a dry food has 3,600 kilocalories per kilogram, that is 3.6 kilocalories per gram. If one 85-gram can has 75 kilocalories, that is about 0.88 kilocalories per gram, or about 880 kilocalories per kilogram. All of these are hypothetical values.
With these hypothetical values, calories per weight for the dry food are nearly 4 times those of the wet food. If the same weight is eaten, the dry food provides far more energy, so setting amounts by weight alone can lead to feeding too much dry food and too little wet food. This is the feeding-amount mismatch caused by moisture.
Find the calorie statement in the calorie item on the label. According to guidance from the National Institute of Animal Science (국립축산과학원), Korean feed labeling items include the ingredient registration number, name, guaranteed analysis (registered), ingredient list, actual weight and manufacture date, among others, and the details are to be checked in Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격). This guidance page alone does not show whether a calorie statement is a mandatory item, so if calories are not on the package, you need to contact the manufacturer.
The World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) introduces a one-page chart of calorie requirements for adult cats and dogs as a starting point. Converting to a calorie basis only makes the calculation simpler, and the target calories themselves should be adjusted to the pet's condition.
How do I compare daily feeding cost on the same yardstick?
Cost is looked at the same way. The price per kilogram, which divides the package price by weight, and the price of one can are different units and cannot be compared. The basis is the amount needed to meet the day's calorie requirement and its price.
The calculation goes as follows. Decide the daily target calories. Dividing those calories by the product's calories per gram (or per can) gives the daily feeding amount. Multiplying that amount by the unit price gives the daily cost.
Below is an example calculated entirely with hypothetical numbers. Assume a daily target of 200 kilocalories. Dry food has 3.6 kilocalories per gram, so about 56 grams are needed, and if a 2 kg bag costs KRW 20,000, that is KRW 10 per gram, so about KRW 560 per day. Wet food has 75 kilocalories per can, so about 2.7 cans are needed, and if a can costs KRW 1,500, that is about KRW 4,000 per day. Scaled down to the same 100 kilocalories, dry food is about KRW 280 and wet food about KRW 2,000.
These results use hypothetical prices, so they should not be taken at face value. In reality calorie density and price differ greatly by product, and they also change with large packs or sale prices. What you should take from this example is not a conclusion but a calculation framework. The key point is that a can that looks cheaper than a handful of dry food can flip when converted to calories, and the reverse is also possible.
There are items that are easy to miss in a cost comparison. These include a container to store an opened can, the amount left uneaten and thrown away, and a separate cost for providing water. They are hard to pin down exactly in numbers, but simply listing them in the comparison table makes judgment easier. The reason price comes at the last step of the comparison is that you should match nutrition, preference and health condition first and only then compare cost.
When feeding dry and wet food together, how are the daily calories divided?
When feeding both, decide the daily calories as a single figure first and let the two types share it. If you calculate a set amount for each separately and simply add them, it is easy to end up with double feeding, eating nearly twice as much.
The order is as follows. Decide the daily target calories. Decide the calories to be filled with wet food first and calculate the wet food amount. Divide the remaining calories by the dry food's calories per gram to set the dry food amount. Cans often come in whole units, so it is convenient to fix the wet food first and fit the dry food around it.
A hypothetical example. If the daily target is 200 kilocalories and wet food has 75 kilocalories per can, 1 can of wet food fills 75 kilocalories, and the remaining 125 kilocalories divided by 3.6 kilocalories per gram of dry food gives about 35 grams to feed. For cost, at the same hypothetical unit prices, wet food is KRW 1,500 and dry food about KRW 350, for about KRW 1,850 per day. If you want to split in half, 100 kilocalories of wet food and 100 kilocalories of dry food, calculate each by dividing by the respective calories.
A press release from the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) says that products labeled as pet complete feed, which meet the nutrient requirements for each life stage, are distinguished from other pet feed, which do not. Rural Development Administration (RDA) material explains that a product labeled as complete feed can meet the needed nutrition when fed on its own. So when feeding both, it helps to check whether this distinction is shown on both products.
Treats and toppings should also be included in the daily calories. Even when wet food is added in a small amount like a treat, it has calories, so write them in the same table to check that the total does not exceed the target. The usual approach is not to change everything at once but to adjust over several weeks while watching body weight and stool condition.
What labeling can an owner check in Korea?
In Korea, labeling of pet food follows the Control of Livestock and Fish Feed Act (사료관리법) and Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격). According to National Institute of Animal Science guidance, labeling items include the ingredient registration number, the name and form of the feed, the guaranteed analysis (registered), the ingredient names used, precautions and purpose, actual weight, manufacture date and sell-by date, and manufacturer information. Of these, an owner will use actual weight and the guaranteed analysis in the calculation.
MAFRA has said it newly introduced nutritional standards for pet food so that products meeting the requirements for each life stage are labeled as pet complete feed, and that the National Institute of Animal Science prepares the nutrition standard. The RDA says this nutrition standard will be fully enforced from 2028 after a 3-year grace period starting in 2025. So the products seen on the market now may have a mix of labeling styles.
From this article's point of view, there are two problems commonly met in Korean labeling when putting dry and wet food on the same yardstick. One is that moisture or calories are not always on the package in the same form. The other is that whether a wet food is complete feed or other feed (of a complementary nature) differs by product, so whether it can be fed on its own differs. The second is a condition to check before comparing.
The detailed provisions of Korean labeling rules could not be checked directly for this article. The text of the provisions did not open on the law website, and the guidance pages above did not contain content on moisture or calorie labeling. So this article does not assert whether calories or moisture are mandatory to show, and if they are not on the package, it is safer to ask the manufacturer or the competent authority.
How is this different from standards overseas?
When reading overseas material, take into account that the way of labeling differs. The US AAFCO standard requires the maximum moisture percentage in the guaranteed analysis, and also requires calorie statements as a separate item, per kilogram and per unit such as can or cup. When moisture and calories are gathered in one place like this, the calculations in this article become easy. However, AAFCO guidance is for the US market and is not the same as Korea's statutory labeling standards.
There are also standards for calorie-related terms such as lite, as used in overseas material. AAFCO says that the calories of a lite dry dog food cannot exceed 3,100 kilocalories per kilogram, and that a claim of reduced calories must be accompanied by the product being compared, the percentage of reduction and the feeding method. This is a US labeling rule and does not apply as is in Korea.
Overseas guidance on moisture is also general. Cats Protection says that wet food is about 70 percent water, so a cat eating dry food may need to drink more, that fresh water should always be available whatever the diet, and that a sudden change in how much a cat drinks needs a veterinary check. It is worth noting in the comparison that the moisture difference between dry and wet food can lead to a difference in daily water intake.
WSAVA provides a starting-point chart of calorie requirements for adult cats and dogs and a body condition score tool, but it does not provide content that directly compares dry and wet food. Overseas material can be used as a basis for calculation methods, but the labeling items of Korean products and the complete feed distinction have to be checked separately against Korean material.
How does the comparison order look all in one place?
The table below gathers the order covered above on one page. The numerical examples in the table are all hypothetical values, and it is a framework for an owner to fill in with the numbers of their own pet's product. Do not change the order; follow it from top to bottom.
In step 1 you confirm why moisture makes such a big difference, in step 2 you match calorie units, in step 3 you calculate daily cost, and in step 4 you decide the split when feeding both. There should be no skipping between steps, and in particular deciding the target calories is the premise of steps 3 and 4.
After filling in the table, also be careful when interpreting the result. The numbers only make comparison easier and do not tell you which side is better. Palatability, the way of chewing, ease of storage and the pet's health condition are variables that do not go into this table. It is better to look at the pros and cons of each type separately in the articles on each type.
| Step | What to check | Calculation | Hypothetical example |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Moisture adjustment | Moisture and nutrient percentages on the package | Nutrient ÷ (100 − moisture) × 100 | Dry food protein 30%, moisture 10% → about 33%; wet food 9%, moisture 80% → 45% |
| 2 Calorie units | Whether kcal/kg or kcal/can | Convert to the same unit (per gram) | Dry food 3.6 kcal/g; wet food 85 g can at 75 kcal → about 0.88 kcal/g |
| 3 Daily cost | Daily target calories and unit price | Target ÷ calories per gram × unit price | At 200 kcal, dry food about KRW 560, wet food about KRW 4,000 |
| 4 Mixing | Fix one food's calories first | Remaining calories ÷ other food's calories per gram | 1 can of wet food 75 kcal + about 35 g of dry food 125 kcal |
What are common misunderstandings, and what should I check?
The first misunderstanding is the idea that wet food lacks nutrition because its protein percentage is low. That may just be the percentage looking small because of moisture, and it can change when converted to a dry matter basis. Conversely, it is also a misunderstanding to conclude that a food is better because the converted result is high.
The second is the idea that a can is about the same as a handful of dry food, so it is the same amount. Even if weight and volume look similar, calories can differ greatly, so you must convert to calorie units.
The third is the assertion that wet food is always expensive or that dry food is always cheap. Calorie density and price differ by product, so you can only find out by calculating directly on a daily calorie basis.
The fourth is the idea that when feeding both you only need to give half of each set amount. Half and half is right in some cases, but not when the two products differ in calorie density. You have to divide based on the daily calories.
The things an owner should check, as a list, are as follows.
- Whether the moisture percentage and calories of both products are on the package
- Whether the calorie unit is per kilogram or per can
- The label distinguishing complete feed from other feed
- The basis used to decide the daily target calories, and whether it was discussed with a veterinarian
- Whether calories from treats and toppings are included in the daily total
- Whether you are recording changes in body weight, stool condition and water intake
This list is a set of check items for comparison and is not a recommendation to feed any particular food to a pet.
Talk to a veterinarian in these cases
If you see changes like the following while changing or mixing the diet, it is better to talk to a veterinarian. These include continued diarrhea or vomiting, days of not eating, a noticeable gain or loss of weight, and a sudden change in how much the pet drinks. Cats Protection also says that a sudden change in how much a cat drinks needs a veterinary check.
If your pet has already been diagnosed with a condition that needs diet management, such as kidney, urinary tract, diabetes, allergy, obesity or gastrointestinal disease, do not decide the diet by this article's calculations alone. Daily target calories, water intake, and the adjustment of nutrients such as protein, phosphorus and carbohydrates differ by condition, so the instructions of the attending veterinarian must come first.
Growing puppies and kittens, pets that are pregnant or nursing, and older pets have calorie needs different from adult cats and dogs. Do not apply this article's hypothetical numbers as they are; take the body condition score and weight records to the hospital and set the target calories together. The WSAVA calorie chart is also material that gives a starting point, so adjustment to the pet's condition should be done with a veterinarian.
Finally, the calculations in this article rest on the premise that the package labeling is accurate. Labeled values and actual values can differ, and the calories needed also change with the pet's activity level, spay or neuter status and the season. You need to try the calculated amount for a few weeks and adjust according to changes in weight and body shape, and it is safer to do that adjustment with a veterinarian.
Frequently asked questions
Q Can I compare the protein figures of dry and wet food directly?
Comparing them directly gives a mismatch. Wet food has a lot of moisture, so the protein percentage on its package looks small. Converting to a dry matter basis that removes moisture, or putting both on a calorie basis, gets closer to the same conditions.
Q How do I convert to a dry matter basis?
Divide the nutrient percentage on the package by the value of 100 minus the moisture percentage, then multiply by 100. For example, hypothetically, with 80 percent moisture and 9 percent protein, 9 divided by 20 gives 45 percent. The detailed calculation is covered in a separate article.
Q Should I look at calories per kilogram or per can?
Check both, then convert to the same unit to compare. AAFCO says calories are stated per kilogram and per familiar unit such as can or cup. Once converted to per gram, dry and wet food can be placed on one line.
Q Should I compare cost by can price or by bag price?
Neither. Work out the amount needed to meet the day's calorie requirement, then multiply by the unit price and compare as daily cost. The prices in this article are all hypothetical values for illustration, so substitute real product prices in the calculation.
Q When feeding dry and wet food together, can I just give half of each?
There is no fixed answer. Deciding the daily target calories first and calculating the other food for what remains after subtracting one food's calories helps prevent double feeding. It is better to set the target calories with a veterinarian according to the pet's condition.
Q If wet food has more moisture, can my pet drink less water?
It is hard to say for certain. Cats Protection says wet food is about 70 percent water so a cat eating dry food may need to drink more, while also saying fresh water should always be available whatever the diet. A sudden change in how much a pet drinks needs a veterinary check.
Limits and scope of this guide
The moisture, calorie and price numbers in this article are hypothetical examples to show the calculation method, not a specific product or an actual feeding amount. Daily target calories differ by age, weight, activity level and condition, so they cannot be set from this article, and it does not suit pets that are growing, pregnant, nursing or senior, or that are under management for a condition. The provisions of Korean law could not be checked directly, and whether calorie and moisture labeling is mandatory was not asserted.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- Reading Pet Food Labels ↗
Used as the basis for the explanation that the guaranteed analysis includes maximum moisture and that calories are stated per kilogram and per can or cup on an as-fed basis, and for the standards on calorie comparison claims.
- Cats and drinking ↗
Used as the basis for the guidance that moisture in wet food is about 70 percent, that fresh water is needed whatever the diet, and that a sudden change in water intake needs a veterinary check.
- Guide to Pet Food Labeling (반려동물 사료 표시 안내) ↗
Used as the basis for the Korean feed labeling items (guaranteed analysis (registered), actual weight and others) and for the guidance to check the details in Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격).
- Press release on the distinction between complete feed and other feed for pets (반려동물 완전사료·기타사료 구분 관련 보도자료) ↗
Used as the basis for the explanation of the system that classifies a product as pet complete feed if it meets nutrition standards and as other pet feed if it does not.
- Press release on the notice of pet nutrition standards (반려동물 영양표준 고시 관련 보도자료) ↗
Used as the basis for the explanation that a product labeled as complete feed can meet nutrition needs when fed on its own, and for the schedule of full enforcement in 2028 after a 3-year grace period from 2025.
- Global Nutrition Guidelines ↗
Used as the basis for the explanation that the calorie requirement chart for adult cats and dogs (updated July 2020) is a starting-point resource and that a body condition score tool is also provided.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 2 Korean laws or notices. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
