Is a puppy's barking bad behavior or communication?
Barking is one of the means of communication a dog uses. The Seoul Metropolitan Government Animal Protection Division's guidance (The causes of dog barking and solutions) explains the several ways a dog expresses itself (facial expression, ears, and posture such as the height of the body), and explains that barking for a few seconds in response to an unfamiliar sound or when the dog feels something urgent is happening is included in normal behavior. The RSPCA in the UK also calls barking normal behavior while advising that when a dog barks excessively it may be a sign that something is wrong. The RSPCA Australia knowledge base likewise explains that some barking is normal and a way of communicating, and that the solution to problem barking differs from dog to dog.
So the conclusion of this article is simple. If barking is seen only as something to eliminate, the cause remains and tends to turn into other behavior, whereas finding the cause and responding to fit it lasts longer. The Canadian Veterinary Medical Association (CVMA) states that the key to dealing with undesirable barking is to understand and treat the underlying cause.
However, saying it is normal does not mean it is fine for the neighbors. The Seoul guidance also writes that in dense housing, barking can disturb other people. The owner has to put the dog's side (why it barks) and the neighbors' side (how much and when it is heard) together to find a way to reduce it.
This article covers general principles that apply to both puppies and adult dogs. Separation-related problems, in which a dog barks only when alone and destruction or toileting accidents appear together, are covered in detail in a separate article, and here only the way to tell them apart is touched on.
What types of reasons are there for barking?
Putting together the guidance of the ASPCA and the RSPCA, the causes of barking can be organized into seven broad groups. The table below groups the types these organizations described so that owners can tell them apart more easily, and it is common for one dog to bark for several reasons.
Compulsive barking, pain and age-related changes in the last row of the table belong to the side that needs a veterinarian's check rather than being solved by training alone. The ASPCA distinguishes barking that goes on for a long time, repeatedly and with no apparent target as compulsive barking, and advises finding an applied animal behaviorist or veterinary behavior specialist if repetitive behavior such as circling appears together with it. It also treats illness or injury separately as a possible cause of barking and recommends a veterinary checkup.
The easiest clues for telling the types apart are when, where and at what the dog barks, and its body language at the time. If it reacts to people outside the window or to the doorbell, it is seen as alerting or territorial; if it barks just before the owner feeds it or plays with it, as a demand; if it barks with a wagging tail when the owner comes home, as excitement or greeting. If it barks while crouching low with its tail tucked and backing away, fear is suspected first.
| Type | Typical clues | First direction of response |
|---|---|---|
| Alerting and territorial | Barks in almost any direction at people outside the window, sounds at the front door, and neighbors' sounds | Block the view from the window; teach waiting on a mat or in a spot at the front door |
| Demand (attention, food, play) | Barks looking at the owner and soon quiets when given what it wants | Do not give in while it is barking; give in once it has quieted |
| Excitement, greeting, frustration | Barks excitedly when the owner comes home, at visits and when getting ready for a walk. Barks more when kept from going | Practice impulse control such as sitting and waiting, then allow the enjoyable activity |
| Fear and anxiety | Barks while crouching and backing away. Starts with a particular sound or object | Keep distance and reduce exposure. Avoid punishment and consider consulting a professional |
| Boredom and lack of exercise | Barks for a long time in a quiet environment for most of the day. Decreases after play | Increase things to do, such as exercise, play and food puzzles |
| Separation-related | Barks only when the owner is absent, along with toileting accidents or destroying things | Start with short periods alone, check the guidance specific to separation anxiety, and consult a veterinarian |
| Compulsion, pain, old age | Barks repeatedly for no reason, has suddenly increased, or has newly started in old age | First have health checked at a veterinary clinic |
How can I find out why my dog is barking?
The first step in finding the cause is keeping notes. If you briefly write down, for a few days, each time the dog barks the time, the place, what happened just before (a sound, a person, another animal, the owner's actions), how long the barking lasted, the body language while barking, and what happened afterward, a pattern shows up. According to the RSPCA Australia knowledge base, a behavior specialist may ask many questions and visit the home to identify the triggers for barking in the dog's living environment (such as people passing on the street or the neighbor's dog). If the owner does that in advance, the consultation goes more smoothly. However, the RSPCA Australia document does not directly say to keep a barking diary, so this part is proposed as a way for the owner to prepare for a consultation.
The items to check when taking notes are as follows.
- When it barks: the time of day, such as morning, daytime, night, or after the owner goes out
- Where it barks: the place, such as by the window, the front door, the yard, the balcony or inside a kennel
- What came first: the doorbell, a delivery, the elevator sound, another dog's sound, the owner preparing a meal, and so on
- What the body language is: the position of the tail and ears, the height of the body, whether the dog is calm, excited or backing away
- What the owner did after the barking: whether the owner held the dog, gave a treat, shouted or ignored it
- Whether it barks when alone: check by video if possible
The Seoul guidance says that when barking becomes frequent, check whether the dog is sleeping enough, whether it is hungry or uncomfortable, and whether it gets enough exercise. The same guidance explains that a healthy adult dog sleeps 14 to 17 hours a day including naps, and recommends asking a veterinarian for the right amount of exercise because it differs from dog to dog.
The RSPCA in the UK advises that if barking increases suddenly or noticeably, health problems such as reduced hearing should be ruled out first, and the ASPCA also says to have a veterinary checkup to see whether illness or injury is the cause before dealing with the barking. It helps to show the notes along with it when visiting the hospital.
How does barking decrease when approached by cause?
The basic framework has four parts: reduce the stimuli that make the dog bark, reward quiet, teach something to do instead of barking, and give enough exercise and play. What follows is the guidance of the ASPCA, the RSPCA and the CVMA set out by cause, and the same method does not work at the same speed for every puppy.
For alerting and territorial barking, blocking the stimulus comes first. The ASPCA advises blocking the dog's view with removable film or an opaque screen on the window, and not letting the dog greet guests at the door as it pleases. The RSPCA in the UK also says that for a dog that barks at passers-by, access to the window or the yard should be limited. Teaching the dog to wait calmly on a mat or in a kennel at the door becomes the behavior to do instead of barking.
For demand barking, the key is not to give the dog what it wants while it is barking. The ASPCA says to ignore the dog, turn away or leave the room, and give what it wants when it sits quietly, and to teach substitute behavior such as ringing a bell to say it wants to go out or bringing a toy. The RSPCA in the UK explains that setting regular times for meals, play and exercise can reduce barking for attention at other times.
For excitement and greeting barking, practicing waiting helps. The ASPCA advises teaching the dog to sit and wait at the door, placing a toy by the door for the dog to hold, and keeping the dog calm with treats during walks. It also advises impulse control practice, in which waiting and sitting come before an enjoyable thing such as play or a walk.
For boredom, exercise, play and things to do are the answer. The RSPCA in the UK explains that dogs are active and social animals that need exercise, things to do and time together, and that a bored dog may bark more. As a way of reinforcing quiet, the ASPCA introduces letting the dog bark a few times, then giving a cue word calmly and rewarding with a treat once it quiets. The RSPCA Australia recommends reward-based training that gives tasty treats for quiet behavior and does not respond to barking.
Fear barking is handled differently. If the focus is on stopping the barking, fear can grow, so it is safer to increase the distance from the feared object, reduce exposure, and talk to a veterinarian or veterinary behavior specialist. Separation-related barking is an area that needs separate guidance, so please refer to the article on separation anxiety.
What should not be done when a dog barks?
First, shouting. The ASPCA advises avoiding shouting and using calm, clear cues in quiet training. It also explains that scolding can be taken by the dog as attention and may reinforce the barking, and that a dog that barks territorially may ignore the scolding.
Second, punishment. The RSPCA Australia advises that training must not include punishment and that punishment tends to make barking problems worse. The ASPCA also says not to use punishment for barking that comes from fear or anxiety unless a behavior specialist recommends it. Inconsistency, scolding the same sound at one time and praising it at another, should also be avoided. The ASPCA says to avoid inconsistent responses that punish some sounds and reward others.
Third, aversive anti-bark devices. The ASPCA classifies anti-bark collars as devices that punish and advises that they are not a first choice, especially for fear, anxiety and compulsive barking. It explains that methods using sound are ineffective for most dogs and that nearly all dogs learn to stop barking only while wearing the collar and bark again when it is taken off. The CVMA states that aversive tools such as electronic collars can worsen barking caused by anxiety. This article does not introduce or recommend any product.
Fourth, encouraging barking. The ASPCA advises that asking who is there when a sound is heard, or looking out the window together, can encourage barking. It also says to avoid devices that hold the mouth shut for a long time and leaving them on without supervision.
Regarding vocal cord surgery (devocalization), only the position stated in the source is briefly given. The CVMA states that it opposes vocal cord surgery that is not for therapeutic purposes, and explains that surgery without addressing the cause often leads to other behavior arising from fear or anxiety.
How is a noise problem with neighbors handled in multi-family housing in South Korea?
In South Korea, many people live in multi-family housing such as apartments, so barking easily turns into neighbor conflict. The Seoul Metropolitan Government Animal Protection Division's guidance also wrote that in dense housing, barking can cause discomfort to others. However, the scope of Korean public materials this article checked is as below, and other legal judgments could not be confirmed.
The guidance of the Neighbor Center for Floor Noise (층간소음 이웃사이센터) (Frequently asked questions) describes floor noise as noise produced by the activity of residents or users of multi-family housing that harms other residents, and divides it into direct impact noise and airborne noise. It lists animal activity noise as one of the noises excluded from the floor-noise scope, and in that case advises checking the management regulations and contacting the management office. So if barking causes conflict with a neighbor, it is hard to see it as leading straight to the Neighbor Center's visit consultation or noise measurement, and the first point of contact is the complex's management regulations and management office.
What the owner can do is as follows.
- Let the neighbors know the situation first and ask when the barking was heard. The RSPCA in the UK also explains that it is better for a neighbor to talk to the owner first about a dog's barking, because the owner may not know whether the dog barks while out.
- Check by video or recording whether the dog barks while the owner is out.
- Tell the neighbors and the management office that you are making an effort to find the cause and reduce the barking in the way described in this article.
- Check whether the complex's management regulations have any provision on animals.
The RSPCA in the UK advises that when talking does not resolve it, a neighbor can ask the local council about the noise. The specific dispute procedures and legal liability in South Korea are not covered by this article, so please check directly with the management office or the competent authority.
What are the common misunderstandings about barking?
One misunderstanding is the idea that a dog understands only if it is scolded loudly. As seen earlier, the ASPCA says scolding can act as attention and keep the barking going, and the RSPCA Australia advises that punishment tends to make barking problems worse.
Another misunderstanding is the belief that holding a barking dog or giving it a treat to calm it makes the barking go away. Rewarding at the moment of barking can teach the dog that barking gets it what it wants, so, as the ASPCA advises, it is right to give it after the dog has quieted and sat. This does not mean, however, that reassuring a dog that is trembling with fear should be prevented. If fear is the cause, this article's sources did not confirm any basis for asserting that comforting increases barking, so for fear situations please consult a veterinarian or behavior specialist.
The third misunderstanding is the idea that the problem is solved if only the barking sound is removed. The CVMA explains that when only the sound is removed without addressing the cause, as with vocal cord surgery, other behavior arising from fear or anxiety often appears. Reducing the sound and the dog's condition getting better are not the same thing.
The fourth misunderstanding is the idea that suddenly increased barking is simply a habit. The ASPCA sees illness or injury as possible causes of barking and recommends a veterinary checkup, and the RSPCA in the UK advises checking for health problems such as reduced hearing if barking suddenly increases. It is safer to check a newly appearing change first as a health problem.
Lastly, a misunderstanding about how long reducing it takes. It is hard to promise that barking will be resolved in a few days, and one should keep in mind that finding the cause and approaching it consistently takes time. This article does not promise a time frame for the same reason.
When should I see a veterinarian or a veterinary behavior specialist?
There are cases in which a veterinarian should be seen first regardless of the cause. These are when barking has suddenly increased or changed noticeably, when the dog shows pain while barking or dislikes being touched, when an older dog has started barking newly, and when circling or repetition of the same movement is present together. The RSPCA Australia advises consulting a veterinarian first, and says the veterinarian can refer an animal behavior specialist who works with reward-based methods. The RSPCA in the UK also points to clinical animal behaviorists who identify the cause and set up a treatment plan.
Consider a behavior consultation as well in the following cases.
- When barking has not decreased even though the owner has tried the approach for each cause consistently for several weeks
- When aggressive behavior is seen along with fear toward strangers or other animals (the Seoul guidance gives this as an example of abnormal behavior that needs treatment)
- When the dog barks for hours when the owner is absent (the Seoul guidance also describes this as abnormal behavior that needs treatment)
- When barking leads to conflict with neighbors and the owner feels burdened
In a consultation, the notes and videos made earlier are the biggest help. The RSPCA Australia explains that treatment usually includes behavior modification training and, in very rare cases, veterinary medication is used together, and the CVMA also states that when medication is considered, a qualified veterinarian should be consulted. Whether to use medication is not for the owner to decide, and this article gives no guidance on medicines or doses.
One more thing. If the effort to reduce barking becomes stressful for both the owner and the puppy, it is better not to struggle alone and to get a professional's help early.
Frequently asked questions
Q Does ignoring a puppy when it barks really reduce it?
It can help with demand barking. For barking to get attention, the ASPCA advises ignoring the dog while it barks and giving what it wants when it sits quietly. However, if the dog is barking because of fear, alerting or pain, ignoring alone does not remove the cause, so the cause must be told apart first.
Q Is it enough to note only the time of day when barking is worst?
The time of day alone is not enough. The sound or event just before barking, the place, the body language and the owner's reaction afterward should also be written down to make it easier to tell the cause type. If possible, please also check video from while the owner is out.
Q Should anti-bark collars not be used?
The ASPCA regards anti-bark collars as devices that punish and advises that they are not a first choice, especially for fear, anxiety and compulsive barking, and the CVMA states that aversive tools such as electronic collars can worsen anxiety barking. This article does not recommend products; if you are considering use, please first consult a veterinarian or veterinary behavior specialist.
Q Does vocal cord surgery solve the barking problem?
The CVMA opposes vocal cord surgery that is not for therapeutic purposes, and explains that surgery without addressing the cause often leads to other behavior arising from fear or anxiety. This article does not recommend surgery and only relays the position that identifying the cause of barking and behavior modification come first.
Q What should I do first if a neighbor complains about barking?
Listen to the complaint, check when the dog barks, then find the cause through video or notes and let the neighbor know you are working to reduce it. The Neighbor Center for Floor Noise (층간소음 이웃사이센터) guidance excludes animal activity noise from the floor-noise scope and refers to checking the management regulations and contacting the management office, so please also consult the complex's management office.
Q If an older dog suddenly starts barking, can training solve it?
A veterinary clinic check is needed before training. The ASPCA names illness or injury, and the RSPCA in the UK names health problems such as reduced hearing, as possible causes of increased barking. Take a behavioral approach after the health problem has been checked.
Q Will barking disappear if I only increase exercise?
Barking caused by boredom or energy can decrease with exercise and play. The RSPCA in the UK also advises that dogs need exercise and things to do. However, fear, alerting and separation-related barking are hard to resolve with exercise alone, so an approach by cause is needed as well.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article is general information and is not a diagnosis or prescription for an individual puppy. The original texts of Korean laws and regulations (such as the rules on the scope and standards of floor noise in multi-family housing) and the dispute procedures could not be opened and checked directly, so only the scope written in the Neighbor Center for Floor Noise guidance is covered. Guidance from overseas organizations may differ from housing and systems in South Korea. Fear-, compulsion- or separation-related barking, or sudden changes, need veterinary care and a veterinary behavior consultation.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- The causes of dog barking and solutions (개 짖음의 원인과 해결책) ↗
Checked as the basis for barking being communication, the distinction between normal barking and barking that needs treatment, checking sleep and exercise, and the discomfort in dense housing (posted 2018-07-13).
- Frequently asked questions of the Neighbor Center for Floor Noise (층간소음 이웃사이센터 자주 묻는 질문) ↗
Basis for the definition of floor noise, for animal activity noise being excluded from the scope and referred to the management regulations and management office, and for the mediating role of the managing body.
- My dog is barking excessively, what should I do? ↗
Basis for the list of causes of barking, seeing a veterinarian first and a reward-based behavior specialist, the tendency of punishment to worsen barking, and rewarding quiet.
- Stopping excessive dog barking ↗
Basis for barking being communication, exercise, routine and reducing visual stimuli, checking for reduced hearing, and guidance on communicating with neighbors.
- Barking ↗
Basis for responses by barking type, what not to do (shouting, punishment, anti-bark devices), and the guidance on a veterinary checkup.
- Ventriculocordectomy (Devocalization) of Dogs ↗
Basis for the position against vocal cord surgery (2022-02-22), for addressing the underlying cause being the key, and for the caution about aversive tools.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
