What is the bottom line on crate training?
To begin with the conclusion, the goal of crate training a puppy is not to confine the puppy but to give it a safe space of its own that it goes into and rests in comfortably by itself. The Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA, UK) says that a crate can be used, with the door left open, as a den-like space in which some dogs feel secure. The UK animal charity PDSA says that everyone in the family should know that the crate must be a safe space and not a play area.
The method is short and gradual. The American Kennel Club (AKC) describes crate training in six stages (awareness, exploration, getting used to it, becoming familiar, training, and maintaining positive associations), and advises that at first the dog should get used to the crate with the door tied open. PDSA stresses not rushing, and advises that if the puppy shows signs of anxiety, you should go back to the previous step and rebuild its confidence.
How long it takes differs from puppy to puppy. The AKC says it can take anywhere from a day to several months, and RSPCA says that the first stage can take anywhere from a few minutes to a few days. In other words, the principle is to match the pace to your own puppy's reaction rather than follow a fixed schedule.
This article covers the principles of using a crate and the order of adjustment. Comparisons of crate product types, toilet training, and telling apart and responding to separation anxiety are covered in other articles, so here they are mentioned only briefly, as far as crate training requires.
In what situations are crates used?
The situations in which crates are used fall roughly into five groups. Among the sources, RSPCA and PDSA directly describe several of them.
- Rest and sleep: RSPCA says that some dogs feel secure in a den-like space with the door left open, and PDSA also lists sleeping among the uses. VCA, a US animal hospital chain, says that a crate can be used as a bed, for set rest and sleep times.
- Transport: PDSA describes travel use, and RSPCA describes use as a safe space during transport. For transport, it is important that a size that fits the puppy is safer.
- Vet visits and unfamiliar places: PDSA says it can also be used in new environments. However, the PDSA guidance page does not specifically mention visits to the animal hospital, so the idea that being used to the carrier helps when taking the dog to the hospital is this article's author's interpretation.
- Evacuation in a disaster: the companion animal disaster guide posted by a Korean local government (Gunsan City) advises moving the animal into a carrier when a disaster happens and taking the disaster kit, and says that training the animal to accept the carrier comfortably is a necessary process.
- Recovery after surgery: RSPCA and PDSA say that it can be used during recovery after surgery when a veterinarian recommends it. Whether to use a crate during recovery, and for how long, should not be decided by the owner alone but must follow the instructions of the veterinarian at the animal hospital that performed the surgery.
RSPCA also describes a use for keeping the puppy safely in one place for a short time when the owner cannot watch it, and a training-aid use that helps with learning to be alone and with toilet training. A crate is, in this way, just one tool and is not necessarily needed by every puppy. VCA says that for some puppies a pen, a small room or a gated-off area suits better than a crate.
What size crate is right?
The sources use almost the same wording for the size standard. RSPCA says it should be roomy enough for the puppy to stand, turn around, lie down and stretch out. PDSA says the height must be such that the puppy's head does not touch the top when it stands and sits, and the length and width must be enough to turn around, lie down and stretch out. VCA also gives a size that lets the dog stand, turn around and stretch out as the standard.
The sources do not give numbers here (in centimeters or kilograms), so this article does not say how many centimeters are right either. Owners can simply watch and check directly whether the puppy can stand, turn around and lie down inside the crate. The pros and cons of each crate product type (folding metal, plastic carrier, fabric and so on) are covered in another article. For reference, VCA gives as an example a folding metal crate with a tray in the floor, and says that some puppies feel more secure if part of it is covered with a blanket.
For growing puppies, the sources differ slightly. PDSA advises choosing for the size the puppy will grow to, or expanding the size as it grows, and says that too large is better than too small. RSPCA, on the other hand, advises choosing a crate with the puppy's growth in mind, but not putting the puppy in a large adult-sized crate for transport, because a smaller space protects the puppy better from impact. In sum, it is safer to think of the size standards for resting at home and for transport in a vehicle separately.
| Source | Standard given | Note |
|---|---|---|
| RSPCA (UK) | Size in which the dog can stand, turn around, lie down and stretch out | For transport, do not use a large adult-sized crate for a young puppy |
| PDSA (UK) | Height at which the head does not touch the top when standing and sitting; length and width to turn around, lie down and stretch out | Also allow room for bedding, a water bowl and toys |
| VCA (US) | Size in which the dog can stand, turn around and stretch out | Gives a folding metal crate with a tray in the floor as an example |
How do you introduce the crate step by step?
Putting together the order common to several sources gives the following five steps. The key is to move on to the next step only when the puppy looks comfortable at each step. RSPCA advises that if the puppy whines, pants, cowers or shows aggression, the time may have been lengthened too fast, so go back a step.
In the first stage, place the crate where the family spends a lot of time and fix the door open so that it does not swing shut and startle the puppy. RSPCA advises fixing the door open because a door that swings and closes can startle the puppy, and the AKC also advises not latching the door and avoiding the sound of slamming until the puppy is used to the door closing gently. The AKC also advises taking the collar off while the puppy is inside, because it can catch on the bars of the crate.
Not forcing the puppy in is also a principle. The AKC advises not forcing the puppy into the crate but luring it with treats. PDSA advises that if the puppy explores and comes out, you should not pull it back in, but reward calm behavior when it goes in. What the owner should watch is not how fast the time at each step lengthens but the puppy's body language. Reading body language is covered in detail in a separate article (body-language signs of stress in dogs and cats).
| Step | What to do | Sign to move on to the next step | If the puppy looks anxious |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Leave the door open | Place the crate where the family is and fix the door open | The puppy approaches on its own and sniffs it | Keep your distance and just put treats near the crate |
| 2. Meals and treats | Put treats in front of and inside the crate and give meals in the open crate too (RSPCA advises putting the bowl toward the back) | The puppy goes in comfortably, eats and comes out | Put the bowl outside the crate and start again, moving it a little further in each time |
| 3. Close the door briefly | Close the door during the meal and, after eating, lengthen the time gradually up to about ten minutes by RSPCA's standard | The puppy eats and stays calm with the door closed | Go back to the step of feeding with the door open |
| 4. With the owner nearby | Give a long-lasting chew and stay beside the crate with the door closed | The puppy chews and then lies down to rest | Open the door sooner and keep it short |
| 5. Step away briefly | Go out of sight first for a few seconds, then for a few minutes, and come back | The puppy stays quiet and not excited when you return | Go back to the previous step and reduce the distance |
How long a day can a dog stay in a crate?
There is no single number for time in the crate per day that suits every puppy. This article passes on the numbers exactly as written in the sources, and also notes that the limit varies with the individual and age.
- PDSA: advises not to leave a dog in a crate for more than 3 hours, and says some dogs cannot manage 3 hours.
- RSPCA: says an adult dog can usually manage about 3 hours, and says that putting a dog in a crate all day while you are at work is not acceptable.
- VCA (a US animal hospital chain): says not to keep a dog in a crate longer than it can hold its bladder and bowels, and as a rough guide for how long a dog can hold it after a daytime toilet break, gives up to 3 hours at 2 months of age, 4 hours at 3 months and 5 hours at 4 months.
- AKC: does not give a fixed maximum time, says not to keep a dog longer than it can hold its bowels and bladder, and says a toilet-trained adult dog should not be kept in a crate all day every day.
The numbers differ by source because the standards differ. This article does not say that any one number is the right answer; please read it only as meaning that shorter is the safer side. PDSA, RSPCA and VCA also advise together that the dog should finish exercise, play and toileting before going into the crate. A young puppy cannot hold its bowels as long as an adult dog, so the time in the crate should be planned around the toilet interval. The AKC also advises that if a puppy whines at night it may need to go to the toilet, so let it out. The principles of toilet training are covered in a separate article.
What should you do when the puppy whines in the crate?
The guidance on whining has two strands, and both are based on the sources. One is that if the sound is mild, you wait until it goes quiet. VCA advises ignoring brief or mild whining until it stops, and letting the puppy out after it has gone quiet so that quiet behavior is rewarded. The AKC also advises not letting the puppy out while it is whining, waiting for a few seconds of quiet, then rewarding and opening the door. RSPCA likewise advises letting the dog out in a pause in the barking, so that it does not learn that barking brings the owner.
The other is when the signal is not simple fussing but anxiety. RSPCA advises that if whining, panting, cowering, excessive barking or aggression appear, the time has been lengthened too fast, so go back a step. PDSA advises that if there are signs of anxiety such as whining or scratching, you should go back to the previous step and rebuild confidence. The AKC advises that whining usually means you have asked too much at once, so go back to the previous step, and that if the puppy seems panicked or cannot stop crying it may be separation anxiety, so stop and consult a professional trainer or behavior consultant.
In sum, the criterion for judging is not how loud the sound is but the puppy's state. If it is mild grumbling that settles, wait; if it is close to panic or keeps getting worse, stop waiting and go back a step. For reference, VCA describes a startle stimulus (making a noise by throwing something, or spraying water) to divert the attention of a puppy that keeps crying, but this article does not recommend it because it can increase anxiety. The principle this article follows is that a reward-based approach is safer than one centered on punishment.
What should you not do in crate training?
The prohibitions that the sources warn about in common are as follows.
- Do not put the puppy in as a punishment: RSPCA says a crate must not be used as a place for punishment or time-out. PDSA, AKC and VCA say the same. The AKC advises that if you need a time-out, you should calmly call the puppy and reward it for going in. If you put the puppy in while scolding it, the crate becomes linked to bad memories and later steps become difficult.
- Do not let the puppy out immediately every time it whines: RSPCA and the AKC advise that if you open the door when it makes noise, the noise becomes the way to get the door opened. However, if anxiety signs or panic appear, do not wait; go back to the previous step. This standard is set out in the earlier section.
- Do not force the puppy in: the AKC advises luring it with treats.
- Do not keep a dog with separation anxiety confined for long periods: PDSA advises that separation anxiety must not be managed with a crate without professional guidance, and that a dog with separation anxiety needs a broader approach, so you should consult a veterinarian or a certified behavior specialist. VCA also says that continuing anxiety, destruction or vocalizing in the crate may be separation anxiety and a behavior specialist may be needed. Telling apart separation anxiety and the first response to it are covered in a separate article.
- Do not confine the puppy for the whole working day: RSPCA says that keeping a dog in a crate all day is not acceptable.
- Do not leave a collar on inside the crate: the AKC says it can catch on the bars.
- Do not place the crate in direct sunlight: RSPCA advises this.
What guidance exists in Korea, and what are common misconceptions?
What this article confirmed in Korea is the disaster evacuation part. The disaster guide for companion animals posted by the Safety Management Division of Gunsan City Hall (last modified 2023-11-09, Korea Open Government License Type 4) advises keeping a disaster kit, which collects equipment such as a leash, harness and carrier along with companion animal supplies, near the entrance or within easy reach in preparation for disasters. When a disaster occurs, it says to move the animal into the carrier and take the kit, and during evacuation it advises not to leave the animal alone, take it out of the carrier, or tie it to a pillar. It also says that training the companion animal to perceive the carrier as comfortable is a necessary process. It further advises making a list of evacuation facilities that admit companion animals in advance and contacting the facility before moving to check that there is spare space. In that sense, everyday crate training is part of this preparation.
Correcting some common misconceptions gives the following.
- A crate is cruel: the sources say that some dogs feel secure when a crate is not used for punishment or long confinement and good memories are built up step by step. Conversely, the problem is keeping a dog confined for long periods without preparation.
- It is done in a few days: the AKC says it takes from a day to several months, and PDSA says it usually takes at least a few weeks.
- If the puppy cries in the crate, the training has failed: mild whining can pass, but if the signals are strong, read it as the pace having been too fast and go back to the previous step.
- A crate treats separation anxiety: PDSA advises not to manage separation anxiety with a crate without professional guidance.
- Every puppy needs a crate: VCA says that for some puppies a pen or a small room suits better.
When should you consult a veterinarian or a veterinary behavior specialist?
Crate training is training an owner can do at home, but in the following cases, please do not keep going alone and consult a veterinarian at an animal hospital or a veterinary behavior specialist. This article does not diagnose or prescribe; what follows are the consultation criteria the sources give and interpretations based on them.
- When whining, scratching, panting, drooling or cowering continue even after going back to an earlier step. RSPCA advises contacting a veterinarian if you have concerns about behavior and asking to be referred to a clinical animal behaviorist.
- When the puppy seems panicked or cannot stop crying. The AKC says this may be separation anxiety and advises consulting a professional trainer or behavior consultant.
- When there is destructive behavior or continuous vocalizing in the crate. VCA says a behavior specialist may be needed.
- When separation anxiety is suspected. PDSA advises consulting a veterinarian or a certified behavior specialist.
- When the puppy must stay in a crate for recovery after surgery. Follow the instructions of the veterinarian at the animal hospital that performed the surgery on how long and how.
- When there are frequent toilet accidents (soiling or urinating) in the crate during crate training, or the puppy seems unwell. This may be a health problem before it is a training problem, so have the puppy seen at an animal hospital.
When you consult, it helps the veterinarian understand the situation if you bring the time the puppy was put in the crate, when the whining began, the exercise and meals just before, and a short video of the sounds and body language. This is a practical suggestion of this article and is not something the sources require.
Frequently asked questions
Q Isn't a crate harsh on a puppy?
RSPCA and PDSA advise using a crate as a safe space and not as a punishment, and say that confining a dog all day is not acceptable. The key is to build good memories step by step and keep the time short.
Q How many hours a day can a puppy be in a crate?
It differs by source. PDSA says not to exceed 3 hours, and RSPCA says an adult dog can usually manage about 3 hours. VCA gives a standard by age in months for how long a young puppy can hold its bowels, and the AKC does not give a maximum time and says not to exceed the time the dog can hold its bowels.
Q Should I let the puppy out right away if it whines?
VCA and the AKC advise waiting for quiet and then letting the puppy out when the whining is mild. However, if the whining, panting or cowering is severe or looks like panic, go back one step and consult a professional if needed.
Q Can I feed meals inside the crate?
RSPCA says that feeding meals in the crate is a good way to lengthen the time the puppy stays in it, and advises giving them with the door open at first and then gradually lengthening the time the door is closed. If the puppy hesitates, put the bowl outside the crate and move it a little further in each time.
Q Can I use a crate for a puppy with separation anxiety?
PDSA advises not to manage separation anxiety with a crate without professional guidance. If you suspect it, consult a veterinarian or a certified behavior specialist; separation anxiety is covered in detail in a separate article.
Q Do I have to get a crate?
It is not required. VCA says that for some puppies a pen, a small room or a gated-off area suits better. However, Korean local government guidance recommends getting the animal used to the carrier it would use for disaster evacuation or transport in everyday life.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article summarizes the principles of introducing a healthy ordinary puppy to a crate, based on guidance from overseas welfare organizations and animal hospitals and from a Korean local government's disaster guidance, and is not a diagnosis or prescription. The numbers for time in the crate differ by source and vary with the individual and age. Public transport carrier rules, size standards in centimeters, and comparison of crate products are not covered because there was no source opened and checked this time. For separation anxiety, severe anxious behavior, and crate use during recovery after surgery, follow the judgment of a veterinarian or veterinary behavior specialist.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- How to Crate Train a Puppy (RSPCA, 크레이트 안내) ↗
Basis for the uses of a crate, the size standard, step-by-step introduction, the 3-hour guidance, and the advice not to use it as a punishment.
- Crate training your dog ↗
Basis for the size standard, step-by-step introduction, the 3-hour limit, separation anxiety and crates, and the advice to go back to the previous step when anxiety signs appear.
- Crate Training Step by Step ↗
Basis for the six stages, responding to whining and consulting a professional for separation anxiety, not using it as a punishment, and how long it takes.
- How to Crate Train Your Dog (VCA guidance) ↗
Basis for the age-by-month bowel-holding time guide, responding to mild whining, alternatives such as pens, and the possibility of separation anxiety.
- Disaster response for companion animals (반려동물을 위한 재난대처법) ↗
Basis for using a carrier in a disaster, the disaster kit, checking evacuation facilities that admit companion animals, and the guidance that training to get comfortable with the carrier is necessary.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
