Skip to content
Grochi · Neutral pet information from South Korea · English edition한국어
Grochi.English edition
Food & nutrition

Can a cooked or homemade cat diet be nutritionally balanced?

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. This page is an English translation of the Korean edition as checked on 2026-11-19. If the two differ, the Korean edition is the reference. 한국어판 (Korean edition)

Can a cooked or homemade cat diet be nutritionally balanced?
Short answer

It can be done, but it is not easy. A study that analyzed 114 internet and book recipes found nutrition problems in every recipe, and a recipe from a veterinary nutrition specialist with regular check-ups is the safer route.

Key takeaways

  • When US researchers analyzed 114 homemade cat diet recipes collected from books and the internet, nutritional adequacy problems were found in every recipe evaluated.
  • The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that a diet of only boiled lean meat such as chicken breast can cause calcium deficiency and nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism.
  • Cats must get nutrients such as taurine, vitamin A and arachidonic acid directly from food, so a diet put together with human food sense easily develops gaps.
  • To feed a homemade diet, the basic principle is to get a recipe made for the individual cat by a veterinary nutrition specialist (ACVN, ECVCN and so on) and not to change the ingredients, cooking method or amounts.
  • In Korea there is a home-cooking calculator program based on the nutrition standard made by the Rural Development Administration, but it has not been confirmed that this replaces a custom prescription from a veterinary nutrition specialist.

Cooked and homemade diets: what is the direct answer?

Feeding a cat food made at home is not itself forbidden. However, making a nutritionally balanced homemade diet is much harder than it seems, and the conclusion that research has shown so far is that simply following a recipe seen on the internet or in a book does not guarantee balance.

In this article, a cooked diet means a home-prepared main meal made from cooked ingredients. The infection risk of raw feeding, where raw meat is given as it is, is outside the scope of this article and is covered in a separate article. Here the focus is on whether a cooked homemade diet can become nutritionally complete, and under what conditions.

Readers often ask three questions: whether it is all right to make and feed a cat a cooked diet, whether it is all right to follow an internet recipe, and whether it is all right to give only boiled chicken breast. In short:

  • If it is a treat, a topping or a small amount to whet the appetite, the nutritional balance burden is not large. The burden grows when a homemade diet becomes most of the day's meals, that is, the main food.
  • Even following an internet or book recipe exactly, it is hard to say that the balance is right. The basis is the research in the sections below.
  • A diet of only boiled chicken breast is not suitable as a main food. Even if protein is sufficient, calcium, vitamins, minerals and essential fatty acids are easily lacking.

If you really want to feed a homemade diet, the safest route is to get a recipe suited to your cat's age, weight and health condition from a veterinary nutrition specialist and follow that recipe without changing it. The later sections explain the reasons and the method in turn.

Why are nutrients easily short even when following a recipe? The research evidence

The most direct evidence is a study published in 2019 in the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association (JAVMA). US researchers collected 114 recipes for homemade maintenance diets for cats from books and online and compared them with the essential nutrient levels that the US National Research Council (NRC) recommends for adult cats (PubMed abstract checked).

According to the abstract, 113 of the 114 recipes gave cooking methods vaguely, and 46 had no feeding instructions at all. Ninety-four recipes were detailed enough for computer nutrient analysis, and among them 93 required the analyst to make assumptions about ingredients, cooking or supplements. As a result, no recipe met all of the NRC recommended amounts. Recipes written by veterinarians and recipes that included a product of the supplement type had relatively fewer nutrients below the standard, but they were not free of problems either. With assumptions made, 5 recipes written by veterinarians met all items except choline, and for 2 of them it could not be confirmed whether taurine was sufficient.

The nutrients that most often fell short of the standard were choline (89.7%), iron (76.6%), thiamin (62.8%), zinc (61.7%), manganese (57.4%), vitamin E (57.4%) and copper (45.7%), in that order. Recipes short of protein were fewer, at 6 of 94 (6.4%). That is, the problem was not too little meat but holes in nutrients other than meat. The researchers concluded that nutritional adequacy problems were found in every recipe evaluated, and that appropriate design requires professional knowledge and a computer program.

Other research points in the same direction. In 2021, researchers at the University of Sao Paulo in Brazil chemically analyzed diets actually prepared from website recipes. There were 75 dog diets and 25 cat diets, and they reported that none of the cat diets met the iron requirement. Dog and cat diets made without supplements had calcium and calcium:phosphorus ratios lower than the recommended level (PubMed abstract checked). The two studies differ in sample size and method and dealt with US and Brazilian recipes respectively, so they cannot be applied as they are to all the recipes that Korean owners see. Even so, the two studies together point to the fact that internet recipes are hard to trust.

Which nutrients are cats especially likely to miss?

Unlike dogs and people, cats cannot make some nutrients sufficiently in their bodies. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that cats must take in taurine from food, and that a shortage can cause dilated cardiomyopathy and retinal degeneration. Plant protein has no taurine, so animal protein or synthetic taurine supplementation is needed. This article could not confirm whether taurine can decrease during cooking and storage, or by how much, so it gives no figures.

The same goes for vitamin A. According to the same source, cats cannot convert beta-carotene into vitamin A, so they need an already formed source such as liver, fish oil or synthetic vitamin A. Conversely, it says that feeding a growing kitten a lot of liver can cause vitamin A excess and abnormal overgrowth of the neck bones. A shortage is a problem and so is an excess, so it is hard to get right by eye.

Essential fatty acids also differ from human intuition. Cats cannot sufficiently convert linoleic acid into arachidonic acid, so they are advised to get it from an animal source such as the fat of meat, poultry and eggs rather than from plant oil (Merck Veterinary Manual). So a low-fat diet of trimmed lean meat or a diet filled out with plant oil can develop a gap on this point.

The balance of calcium and phosphorus is the part that goes wrong in the least noticeable way. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that a meat-based diet can lead to calcium deficiency, and that too much phosphorus reduces calcium absorption. If a calcium source is not considered separately, the balance of calcium and phosphorus can be thrown off. In the Brazilian study above too, diets without supplements showed low calcium and calcium:phosphorus ratios. Beyond these, there are nutrients that are hard to supply from everyday ingredients alone, such as vitamins D and E, iron, zinc, copper and iodine. The required amounts and allowable ranges differ with age and condition, so this article gives no figures, and this is a part that an expert has to calculate at the recipe design stage.

Nutrients easily missed in homemade cat diets and the reasons (general guidance)
NutrientWhy it easily becomes a problemBasis
TaurineMust be taken in from food, and a shortage can cause heart and eye problemsMerck Veterinary Manual
Vitamin AMust be taken in as a formed vitamin, and both too little and too much can cause problemsMerck Veterinary Manual
Arachidonic acid (essential fatty acid)Absent from plant oil and obtained from animal fatMerck Veterinary Manual
Calcium and phosphorus balanceA meat-based diet can lead to calcium deficiencyMerck Veterinary Manual, 2021 Brazilian study
Iron, zinc, vitamin E, choline and othersOften fell short of the standard in the recipe analysis2019 JAVMA study

What imbalances arise if you give only lean meat?

"Is it all right to give only boiled chicken breast?" is the most common question. It comes from the idea that cats are carnivores so meat alone should be enough. It is true that animal protein is important for cats. But lean meat itself has a nutrient composition that is lopsided to one side.

The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that a meat-based diet can cause calcium deficiency and nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism. As the name says, this condition refers to a state in which a nutritional imbalance in the diet throws off hormonal regulation and calcium leaves the bones. The manual describes signs such as irritability, muscle weakness or paralysis, bone demineralization and fractures. Before the signs become this serious, there may be few noticeable changes, so the fact that a cat eats well and looks lively is not proof that the balance is right.

The Merck Veterinary Manual also explains that a homemade diet built from only a few limited ingredients easily becomes nutritionally deficient, and how to add other ingredients depends on the individual's condition. This article does not make a table of what each ingredient contains and how much, and does not direct how to supplement, because that is the territory of recipe design.

In summary, boiling chicken breast can be used as a treat but is not suitable as a main food. For a cat that has lost its appetite, the order is to contact an animal hospital first rather than change what you feed. Not adding human seasoning, especially salt or soy sauce, is also written as a caution in a homemade pet food experience article by a policy reporter team member published in Policy Briefing (정책브리핑). This is not an official standard but a mention in a personal contribution.

What is the situation in Korea? Domestic standards and tools

In Korea, in October 2024 the National Institute of Animal Science of the Rural Development Administration announced a pet food nutrition standard suited to Korean conditions. It is said to present 41 recommended nutrients for adult cats and 43 for kittens and breeding female cats (Policy Briefing report). This standard is a guideline that organizes the minimum recommended levels a food needs for healthy living, and it was later incorporated into the Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) as Annex 15-2.

According to an April 2026 press release from the Rural Development Administration, food that meets this standard can carry a complete feed label for each life stage, a label that indicates the product can be fed on its own without supplements. A 3-year preparation period from 2025 is provided, and full implementation is scheduled from 2028. This labeling system concerns commercial pet food and is not a system that applies to diets made at home. Still, the existence of the nutrition standard also means that a Korean-language standard now exists for comparing the nutrition of homemade diets. The schedule may change, so the implementation date must be checked directly in the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs notice.

There is also a domestic tool for owners who want to put together a homemade diet themselves. According to an August 2025 Policy Briefing article, the pet home-cooking program on the Nongsaro website run by the Rural Development Administration calculates the mixing ratio and daily feeding amount when you enter breed, life stage, sex, purpose and activity level, and tells you the nutrients that are lacking. It has been in operation since 2017 and is said to use the Korean nutrition standard. This article could not confirm whether this tool reflects an individual cat's illness or constitution, or whether it is at the same level as a custom prescription from a veterinary nutrition specialist. Please treat it as a reference that helps design the diet of a healthy adult cat, and if there is an illness, consult an animal hospital.

This article could not confirm from authoritative sources how many hospitals in Korea offer consultation with a veterinary nutrition specialist, or roughly what it costs. So this article makes no definitive statement about consultation conditions in Korea, and as a first step recommends telling the animal hospital you visit that you intend to feed a homemade diet and asking where a recipe design can be obtained.

How does this differ from overseas standards, and how do I get an expert recipe?

Overseas, leaving the design of a homemade diet to a veterinary nutrition specialist is spoken of as the safe route. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that nutritional diseases are rare when a commercial complete and balanced food or a homemade diet designed by a board certified veterinary nutrition specialist is fed, and that nutrition problems are most common with unbalanced homemade diets. In the United States, specialists in the nutrition specialty (ACVN) under the ACVIM play this role, and in Europe specialists certified by the European College of Veterinary and Comparative Nutrition (ECVCN) do. The ECVCN was founded in 1998 and is a specialist body recognized by the European Board of Veterinary Specialisation, and it is said that specialists who have completed training are re-evaluated every 5 years (ECVCN website checked).

These two are organization websites and are not places that sell recipes or guide owners directly. The ECVCN website we looked at had no list of specialists, and for the ACVIM website we only confirmed that it has a link to search for specialists. We could not confirm any basis that a specialist with such a qualification can be found right away in Korea. So rather than applying overseas examples to Korea as they are, this article suggests first consulting a veterinarian.

What appeared in overseas research is that the presence of supplements and whether the author is a veterinarian affect the number of deficient nutrients (2019 JAVMA study). However, even in that study, not all recipes written by veterinarians were complete. This means that even a well-known book or a piece of writing bearing a veterinarian's name is hard to rely on unless it has been confirmed by nutrient analysis.

Even when you receive an expert's recipe, there are points to observe. A recipe is the result of a nutrient analysis program calculating on the premise of set ingredients, amounts and cooking method, so if even one changes, the calculation changes. The most common deviations are below.

  • Swapping an ingredient for a similar one: replacing chicken with another meat, or changing the cut, changes the fat and nutrient composition.
  • Changing the cooking method: boiling, grilling or long simmering can change moisture and some nutrients.
  • Measuring amounts by eye: without weighing on a scale, the balance of small-quantity components such as calcium is easily thrown off.
  • Leaving out the supplement: if skipping for several days repeats, deficiencies can build up.
  • Spoilage from storage and thawing: when food is made in bulk and kept, hygiene and spoilage management are needed.

The 2019 study too named vague cooking and feeding instructions in recipes as a problem. The better the recipe, the more specifically it states the kind of ingredients, weights, cooking method and how to use supplements. This article does not give those specific values.

What owners should check, common misunderstandings, and when to go to the hospital

The items to check before starting a homemade diet and while continuing it are organized in a table. This table is not a diagnosis or prescription but a checking standard.

Common misunderstandings are also pointed out. First, the idea that fresh ingredients that people can eat are enough for a cat too. Cats need different nutrients from people, and in the studies above too, minerals and vitamins were short rather than protein. Second, the idea that adding a few supplements solves it. There are results that the presence of supplements has an effect, but there were recipes that fell short of the standard even with supplements, and there are nutrients for which excess is a problem. Third, the idea that it is fine because the cat is not sick. Nutritional imbalance progresses slowly and can take time to show on the outside. Fourth, the idea that the names natural food or homemade food mean balance. In Korea too, the complete feed labeling system concerns commercial food, and a name does not guarantee balance.

In the following cases, an animal hospital visit comes before changing the diet: when the cat has not eaten well for several days or loses weight rapidly, when its way of walking looks odd or it feels pain when touched and lacks strength, when its eyes look cloudy or its eyesight seems to have declined, when it is breathing hard or lacks energy, and when it has repeated vomiting or diarrhea. Cats that need dietary management for kidney disease, allergies and the like, kittens, pregnant or nursing cats and senior cats need different nutrition from a general diet, so it is best not to start a homemade diet without consulting a veterinarian. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that nutrition problems are most common with unbalanced homemade diets. If there is an illness, consultation is needed all the more.

Checklist before starting and while continuing a homemade diet
Item to checkHow to checkReason
Recipe sourceCheck whether it is a recipe from a veterinary nutrition specialist or one with a confirmed nutrient analysisNutrition problems were common in the analysis of internet and book recipes
Ingredients, amounts, cooking methodWeigh on a scale and make it exactly as written, and consult first if you want to change anythingIf even one thing changes, the nutrient calculation changes
Supplement useUse only the kinds the recipe specifies, in the specified wayBoth shortage and excess can be problems
Weight, body shape, coat, energyRecord them and tell the hospital about changesNutrition problems appear slowly
Regular check-upsSet a check-up schedule with a veterinarian and have check-upsTo confirm deficiencies that cannot be seen from the outside
Storage and hygieneMark the date made and check refrigerator and freezer storage methodsSpoilage and hygiene problems are possible with bulk cooking

Frequently asked questions

Q Is it all right to make and feed my cat a cooked diet?

As a small topping or treat, the nutritional balance burden is not large. To make it most of the day's meals, a recipe from a veterinary nutrition specialist and regular check-ups are needed, because research has confirmed that balancing it is difficult.

Q Is it all right to follow an internet recipe?

It is hard to recommend. In a 2019 study that analyzed 114 cat recipes collected from books and online, every recipe evaluated had nutrition problems, and in most cases the cooking and feeding methods were vague.

Q Is it all right to give only boiled chicken breast?

It is not suitable as a main food. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that a lean-meat-based diet can cause problems such as calcium deficiency and nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism. Limit boiled chicken to a treat or something to whet the appetite.

Q Where do I find a veterinary nutrition specialist?

There are specialists certified by bodies such as the ACVN in the United States and the ECVCN in Europe. We could not confirm how many places in Korea can offer consultation, so tell the animal hospital you already visit that you want to feed a homemade diet and ask how to be connected.

Q Is it safe if I make it with the Nongsaro home-cooking program?

It is a tool by which the National Institute of Animal Science of the Rural Development Administration calculates the mixing ratio and feeding amount with the Korean nutrition standard and tells you the nutrients that are lacking. However, we could not confirm whether it reflects illness or individual differences and replaces a specialist's prescription. Use it as a reference, and consult a veterinarian if you have concerns.

Q If I just add supplements, will the missing nutrients be filled in?

It is not that simple. There is a result that recipes without supplements had more nutrients below the standard, but recipes with supplements also did not meet every standard. The kind and amount must be decided by an expert within the recipe.

Q What changes during a homemade diet mean I should go to the hospital?

When appetite drops or weight falls, when the way of walking or energy seems odd or eyesight is a concern, or when vomiting or diarrhea repeats, get an examination at an animal hospital before fixing the diet.

Limits and scope of this guide

This article is general guidance based on healthy adult cats and does not suit cats with illness, kittens, pregnant or nursing cats, or senior cats. No diagnosis, recipe or supplement dose is given. The studies cited analyzed 2019 US recipes and 2021 Brazilian website recipes, so they do not represent every recipe encountered in Korea. The conditions for domestic veterinary nutrition consultation and the range of illness-specific application of the home-cooking program could not be confirmed. This article is an editorial draft and has not been reviewed by veterinary professionals.

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.

Sources and check dates

  1. Evaluation of the nutritional adequacy of recipes for home-prepared maintenance diets for cats (Wilson et al., JAVMA 2019, PMID 31039096) ↗

    Basis for the results of the analysis of 114 homemade cat diet recipes (nutritional adequacy problems, proportions of deficient nutrients).

  2. Influence of number of ingredients, use of supplement and vegetarian or vegan preparation on the composition of homemade diets for dogs and cats (Pedrinelli et al., BMC Vet Res 2021) ↗

    Basis for the finding that cat diets prepared from website recipes and chemically analyzed were short in iron, calcium and the calcium:phosphorus ratio.

  3. Nutritional Requirements and Related Diseases of Small Animals ↗

    Basis for the explanations of taurine, vitamin A, arachidonic acid, nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism from meat-based diets, and homemade diets and specialist design.

  4. European College of Veterinary and Comparative Nutrition (ECVCN) website (누리집) ↗

    Basis for describing the nature of the European veterinary nutrition specialist body (founded in 1998, re-evaluated every 5 years).

  5. Nutritionally complete homemade food, shall we try making it ourselves? (영양 만점 수제 사료, 직접 만들어볼까?) ↗

    Basis for the functions of the pet home-cooking program on the Rural Development Administration's Nongsaro and for the caution about salt seasoning.

  6. Establishing a pet food nutrition standard suited to Korean conditions (국내 실정 맞는 반려동물 사료 영양표준 마련) ↗

    Basis for the number of recommended nutrient items in the cat nutrition standard (41 for adults, 43 for kittens and breeding female cats).

  7. Pet food will also be managed under a national standard (press release, 2026-04-10) (반려동물 사료도 국가 기준으로 관리한다) ↗

    Basis for the addition of Annex 15-2 to the Standards and Specifications for Feeds, the complete feed label, and the schedule of full implementation from 2028.

Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.

This guide relies on 1 Korean law or notice. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.