In a word, how do the five litters differ?
The biggest difference among the five cat litters is how they handle urine. Bentonite is a name classed as a clay-type litter. Cats Protection explains that this clay and mineral group includes clumping litter, which binds urine into lumps, and non-clumping litter, which does not. Tofu litter is grouped as a plant-based litter together with tofu, corn and others, and Cats Protection advises that plant-based litters are generally biodegradable and relatively soft and low in dust. Silica litter is a litter that uses highly absorbent crystal granules, and wood litter comes as wood pellets that tend to stick less to the paws, though large, hard pellets may be uncomfortable, according to the guidance. For cassava litter, this article's sources have no explanation.
Cats Protection, a UK cat welfare charity, advises that it describes commercial litters by dividing them into mineral and clay, wood pellet, paper, silica, and plant-based types such as tofu and corn. The same charity explains that among clay types, clumping litter binds urine into lumps so that only that part can be scooped out, while non-clumping litter does not clump and absorbs moisture. The overseas guidance checked for this article did not deal with cassava litter separately. So cassava litter should be examined on the basis of the general characteristics of plant-based litter and the product label, and this point is stated again in the limits at the end of the article.
This article does not rank which litter is better. What the guidance checked says in common is that the litter a cat uses comfortably is the good litter. Below, the differences by type are first viewed in a table, and then why such differences arise is examined together with the level of evidence.
How do they compare type by type at a glance?
The table below organizes only what appeared in the guidance of the public institutions and animal welfare organizations checked, and cells with nothing in the guidance are marked "source not confirmed". The contents of the table are only tendencies that may differ by product, not product performance test results. Weight and dust in particular can differ by product, so when choosing it is better to check the weight and manufacturer's label printed on the package.
The parts of the table with a higher level of evidence are Cats Protection's explanation by material and the local governments' disposal guidance. For items often used in product marketing, such as clumping strength or odor control, I could not find independent comparison tests this time. So those items are not compared in this article.
| Type | How moisture is handled | Dust | Odor | Weight and disposal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bentonite | Clay and mineral types include clumping and non-clumping (Cats Protection) | Clay types are described as able to be fairly dusty | Depends on cleaning interval | Standards differ by local government (Paju City directs non-tofu litter to non-combustible waste bags) |
| Tofu | Classed as plant-based litter. Whether it clumps: source not confirmed | Plant-based litter is described as low in dust | Depends on cleaning interval | Standards differ by local government; for flushing, the risk of pipe blockage needs to be checked |
| Cassava | Source not confirmed | Check the product label | Check the product label | Check the standards of your local government |
| Silica | Described as highly absorbent | Check the product label for dust information | Described as strong at controlling moisture and odor | Check the standards of your local government |
| Wood | Pellet form tends to stick less to the paws, but large, hard pellets are described as possibly uncomfortable | Source not confirmed | Source not confirmed | Check the standards of your local government |
Why do these differences arise?
Because each litter handles moisture differently, dust, odor and the cleaning method differ. Clumping litter binds only the part touched by urine into a lump, so it is managed by scooping out those lumps and the stool every day and topping up with new litter as much as is missing. The Cornell Feline Health Center in the US advises removing stool and lumps every day when using clumping litter. Cats Protection advises that non-clumping litter makes it hard to remove the urine, so it may need to be changed more often.
On dust, Cats Protection advises that some mineral and clay products can produce considerable dust, so if the cat has a respiratory illness the product should be checked. In contrast, it explains that paper and plant-based litters tend to be low in dust. However, this is a tendency by material, and it should also be kept in mind that there are differences between products within the same material.
Odor is not only a matter of litter material. Humane World for Animals in the US advises avoiding scented litter and changing the litter earlier if you see odor or wet clumped areas. Cats Protection likewise explains that a strong scent can make a cat reluctant to use the box, so it recommends unscented litter and regular cleaning. This means that a scent that is pleasant to the owner can be repellent to the cat.
To sum up, the clumping method largely determines the cleaning method, the properties of the granules determine dust, and the cleaning interval determines odor. In terms of the level of evidence, these explanations are general guidance from public institutions and animal welfare organizations, and I could not find a randomized controlled trial or systematic review that directly compares the five types of litter this time.
How do I dispose of and choose litter in Korea?
In Korea, the method of disposing of cat litter is not a single nationwide standard but differs by local government. Even the local government guidance checked this time was divided. The bulky waste guide table of Paju City says to put tofu litter in a volume-based waste bag and put it out at the front door, and for litter other than tofu to put it in a non-combustible waste bag (KRW 2,070 per the guide table) and request disposal and collection. The waste disposal guide of Gangnam-gu, Seoul says to put cat litter in a PP bag for waste that must not be incinerated, together with items such as broken glass and shoes.
The Resource Circulation Division of Sejong Special Self-Governing City, in a September 2025 notice, asks that when large amounts of cat litter are thrown into the automated Cleannet inlets in dong areas, it be put out with a bulky waste sticker attached, because it can cause pipe blockages. In eup and myeon areas, it is put out in a regular volume-based waste bag. The same notice also explains that if a blockage occurs, the whole area's automated Cleannet operation stops. This is a case where the method differs within the same city by area and disposal facility.
Flushing down the toilet needs particular care. Among the public institution guidance checked this time, there was no document that directly allowed flushing by material. Some sales pages and personal posts explain that tofu litter dissolves in water, but this is at the level of industry claims or personal opinion, and does not guarantee anything about the structure of an apartment's pipes, the amount flushed or how the waste mixed into the litter is handled. If litter hardens in pipes and blocks them, it can lead to repair costs and harm to neighbors, so it is safer to decide on flushing only after checking the guidance of your local government and building management office. If it is not confirmed, disposing of it by the method the local government has announced, such as a volume-based waste bag, is the better course.
When choosing a product, you can check the material, weight and disposal method labeling printed on the package. However, label wording is information the manufacturer writes, so when it differs from your local government's standard, follow the local government's standard.
How do overseas guidance and the situation in Korea differ?
Guidance from overseas animal welfare and veterinary organizations generally focuses on creating an environment the cat accepts rather than deciding which material is better. The Cornell Feline Health Center advises that most cats prefer unscented, fine-grained litter laid 1 to 2 inches deep. Humane World for Animals also advises that cats usually prefer a fine, sand-like texture, and that once you settle on one and it works well, you should keep using it. The UK RSPCA explains that in its own test wood pellets performed strongest, but some cats prefer fine-grained litter.
The differences from the situation in Korea show up mainly in disposal and housing type. Overseas cat organizations' guidance says almost nothing about litter disposal. The Cats Protection article checked this time also did not deal with weight or disposal and flushing methods, as was confirmed. In Korea, as seen above, disposal standards differ by local government, so the disposal method becomes a practical variable in choosing litter. For this reason, choosing a material from overseas guidance alone may not match disposal standards in Korea.
Another point is the nature of the evidence. The general principles of overseas guidance, such as the number of boxes and cleaning frequency, are described similarly by several organizations. In contrast, on the ranking of materials, the individual cat's preference plays a large part, so the conclusions differ by organization. The RSPCA's test result that wood was good also cannot be applied directly to wood litter products in Korea as a whole. This is because the test conditions and subjects differ.
So the way to read domestic and overseas guidance together is simple. For the texture the cat accepts and cleaning habits, refer to overseas guidance, and for disposal and pipe problems, give priority to the standards of Korean local governments.
What owners should check: number of litter boxes, cleaning frequency, changing litter
Even after the litter material is decided, whether the cat uses the box depends on how the box is run. The Cornell Feline Health Center advises having as many litter boxes as there are cats in the home plus one. Humane World for Animals and the UK RSPCA also advise one box per cat plus one spare, and Humane World for Animals advises placing at least one on each floor in a home with several floors. The Cornell guidance and the Humane World for Animals guidance also explain placing boxes in several places around the home.
Cleaning frequency is summarized as follows. Humane World for Animals advises scooping waste every day, and as examples gives replacing clumping litter every 2 to 3 weeks on the premise that it is scooped daily, and clay litter twice a week. The RSPCA advises partial cleaning every day and replacing the litter at least once a week. Since the numbers differ by organization, rather than accepting one as the single right answer, it fits better to read it as meaning that the litter should be changed earlier when it gets wet or starts to smell. The Cornell guidance explains that the more cats there are, the shorter the replacement interval.
When changing litter, Cats Protection and the RSPCA advise doing it gradually. Cats Protection advises not changing overnight but mixing a little new litter into the existing litter and raising the proportion over a week or more. If there are several boxes, it also suggests putting the new litter in only one and keeping the usual litter in the rest so the cat can choose. The RSPCA also explains mixing over about a week or putting new litter in a separate box. Not changing the litter, the box and the location all at once is also recommended together.
When cleaning the box, there is guidance to wipe with a mild detergent, dry it and then fill it with new litter, and Humane World for Animals advises avoiding harsh cleaners such as ammonia or citrus oil. The Cornell guidance states that covered boxes can trap odor and that most cats prefer an uncovered box.
Common misunderstandings
The first misunderstanding is the idea that the price of litter or its advertising wording is quality itself. The guidance of the public institutions and animal welfare organizations checked this time did not conclude that any material is superior, and took the litter the cat accepts as the standard. Wording on product packages such as "dust-free" or "powerful odor control" is at the level of industry claims, and without independent test results it is hard to believe as it stands.
The second misunderstanding is the idea that litter that dissolves in the toilet can be flushed in any amount. Even plant-based litter described as dissolving in water can cause blockages if a large amount goes in at once or if it meets old pipes. The Resource Circulation Division of Sejong City advises that disposing of large amounts of cat litter can cause pipe blockages, and that when a blockage occurs the whole area's automated Cleannet operation is stopped. Flushing is something to decide only after checking the standards of your local government and building management office.
The third misunderstanding is the idea that nicely scented litter solves odor. The Cornell Feline Health Center, Humane World for Animals and Cats Protection all lean toward avoiding strong scents, and advise that a strong scent can make the cat reluctant to use the box. The core of the guidance is to reduce odor not by covering it with scent but through management: scooping every day and replacing the litter on time.
The fourth misunderstanding is the idea that if a cat does not use the box, it is a habit problem. The Cornell Feline Health Center advises that illnesses such as urinary tract inflammation, kidney disease, thyroid disease and diabetes can cause box avoidance, and that a cat may not look sick even when it is ill. Before blaming the litter or the cat's personality, a health check comes first.
When to ask a veterinarian
If a cat suddenly stops using a box it used to use well, or repeatedly eliminates outside the box, it is best to contact an animal hospital. The Cornell Feline Health Center advises that when elimination outside the box is confirmed, the cat should have a thorough examination by a veterinarian and any necessary tests. Humane World for Animals also advises that if a cat suddenly stops using the box, you should see a veterinarian first to rule out medical causes such as a urinary tract infection or arthritis. The RSPCA likewise advises consulting a veterinarian if elimination outside the box is regular, since it may be a health problem.
If the pattern of defecation or urination changes after changing litter, it is best not to assume it is because of the litter. It helps to observe and record, so that you can explain it at the hospital, whether the size of urine lumps has suddenly become larger or smaller than usual, whether the number of visits to the box has changed, and whether the posture or sounds while eliminating differ from usual. Some silica products use granules that signal a change in urine color, but Cats Protection explains that such a feature does not replace a veterinarian's diagnosis.
This article does not diagnose or prescribe. Even when a cat tries to eat litter, shows coughing and breathing changes after inhaling litter dust, or when a young kitten swallows litter, it is safer to consult a veterinarian rather than try to solve it by choice of litter alone. That a cat with a respiratory illness can be given a low-dust product to consider is as far as the guidance checked this time goes.
Frequently asked questions
Q Which is better, clumping or absorbent litter?
I could not find a comparison study confirming that either is better this time. Clumping litter is managed by scooping urine lumps and stool every day, and absorbent litter by changing it when the whole is wet. Choose according to your cleaning habits and the cat's preference.
Q Can tofu litter be flushed down the toilet?
In the local government guidance checked this time, there was guidance to dispose of tofu litter in a volume-based waste bag, and no public document directly allowed flushing. The risk of blockage differs depending on the pipes and the building management office's standards, so check your residence's guidance before flushing.
Q How do I dispose of bentonite litter?
It differs by local government. Paju City says to put litter other than tofu in a non-combustible waste bag, and Gangnam-gu says to put it in a PP bag for waste that must not be incinerated. Sejong City directs disposal in a regular bag or with a bulky waste sticker depending on the area. Follow your local government's guidance.
Q How many litter boxes should I have?
The Cornell Feline Health Center, Humane World for Animals and the RSPCA advise the number of cats plus one. There is also guidance to spread them in several places, and on every floor in a home with several floors.
Q How often should I change the litter?
The guidance differs by organization. Humane World for Animals gives as an example replacing clumping litter every 2 to 3 weeks if it is scooped daily, and the RSPCA advises replacing at least once a week. It should be changed earlier if it smells or gets wet and clumped.
Q I want to change my cat's litter. How should I do it?
Cats Protection advises mixing a little new litter into the existing litter and raising the proportion over a week or more. If there are several boxes, you can also put the new litter in only one so the cat can choose.
Q What should I do if my cat will not use the box after I change the litter?
You can try mixing it with the litter it used before, or putting it in a separate box so the cat can choose. If it repeatedly eliminates outside the box, it may be a health problem, so contact an animal hospital.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article organizes the tendencies by material and the general management principles of cat litter, and does not judge the performance or ranking of any specific product. The overseas guidance checked this time had no explanation of cassava litter, and I could not find tests that independently compared weight, clumping strength and odor control. I also could not confirm a litter comparison from the Korea Consumer Agency. The local government guidance opened this time also contained no public document that directly allows flushing tofu litter. For local government disposal standards I opened only three places, Paju City, Gangnam-gu and Sejong City; they differ by area and may change at any time, so your residence's guidance takes priority. For cats with a respiratory illness, kittens, senior cats and cats with changes in elimination, the general guidance in this article may not apply, so consult a veterinarian.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- House Soiling (집 안 배변 문제) ↗
Basis for the number of boxes (cats + 1), the preference for unscented fine-grained litter, daily cleaning of clumping litter, gradual replacement, and the relation between box avoidance and illness.
- Solving Litter Box Problems ↗
Basis for the examples of litter types, unscented litter, examples of cleaning and replacement intervals, and the guidance to see a veterinarian when a cat suddenly stops using the box.
- Litter (고양이 환경: 모래) ↗
Basis for one box per cat plus a spare, daily partial cleaning and replacement at least once a week, changing litter over about a week, and the wood pellet test result.
- How to choose the best cat litter for your cat ↗
Basis for the characteristics of mineral, wood, paper, silica and plant-based litter by material, dust, scent, and the guidance to change litter over a week or more.
- Bulky waste disposal guide (cat litter item) (대형폐기물 배출 안내(고양이 모래 항목)) ↗
Basis for the local government guidance that tofu litter goes in a volume-based waste bag and litter other than tofu is put out by requesting collection in a non-combustible waste bag.
- Guide to disposing of cat litter (고양이 화장실 모래 배출 안내) ↗
Basis for the guidance of a regular bag in eup and myeon areas and a bulky waste sticker in dong areas because of the risk of automated Cleannet pipe blockage when large amounts are disposed of.
- Waste disposal guide (쓰레기 배출 안내) ↗
Basis for the guidance to put cat litter in a PP bag for waste that must not be incinerated.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
This guide relies on 1 Korean law or notice. Current effective dates and upcoming amendments are listed on Korean law check status. This is not legal advice.
