What is separation anxiety, and how do you tell it apart?
Separation anxiety refers to the fear and anxiety a dog feels when separated from a particular person or when it expects to be. The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) describes separation anxiety as distress from being apart from the owner, and explains that behaviors such as chewing, escaping and pacing do not usually appear when the owner is nearby. The Merck Veterinary Manual treats this condition under the name separation distress disorder, explaining that some dogs are distressed only when left alone and some when separated from a particular owner.
So the starting point for telling it apart is not the type of behavior but its timing. Barking, chewing and toileting anywhere are common behaviors even without separation anxiety. You need to look at when the behavior happens, that is, whether it starts right after the owner leaves or also happens when the owner is at home. VCA, a US animal hospital information site, also explains that if the same behavior occurs when the owner is at home, you should first think of causes other than separation anxiety.
This article is not a diagnosis; it introduces criteria an owner can observe and organize at home. The final decision on whether it is separation anxiety is for a veterinarian or a veterinary behavior specialist. The Merck Veterinary Manual also states that a diagnosis of separation distress disorder is made only after other common causes that show similar signs are excluded. So the article looks in turn at what signals there are, what similar-looking causes exist and how to keep records, and then summarizes the practice you can try at home and the point at which to seek a professional.
One misunderstanding is cleared up first. The Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA) in the UK advises that such problem behavior is usually not revenge or spite but distress from being separated. Not seeing the dog as deliberately destroying things to annoy the owner is the starting point of this whole article.
What signs are seen with separation anxiety?
The typical signs the ASPCA introduces are as follows: barking or howling that continues only when alone, toileting and urinating only when alone, chewing and digging around door frames, windows and entrances, escape attempts, pacing back and forth along the same path, and eating its own stool after defecating. It also lists heavy drooling and signs of anxiety from the moment the owner starts getting ready to leave as clues.
- Barking, crying or howling that continues only when alone
- Scratching or chewing around the front door or windows, and injuring teeth, nails or paws while trying to escape
- Toileting and urinating only when alone, although the dog does not usually have accidents
- Drooling, panting, trembling, restless pacing, and refusing food or treats
- Anxiety seen from the moment the owner picks up keys or puts on shoes
- A greeting on return that is so excited the dog does not calm down easily
Timing is also a reference. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that symptoms usually start between 15 and 30 minutes after the owner leaves, but that some dogs already start at the stage of getting ready to leave, such as putting on shoes or picking up keys. The same source adds that vocalization tends to be strongest early on and pacing tends to become more prominent later. The ASPCA also says that symptoms often start within a few minutes of the owner leaving.
There are also signs that are hard to notice. Citing research, the RSPCA advises that many dogs find being alone difficult but half of them show no obvious signs, and explains that hidden signs such as trembling, pacing and whining can be known only by filming. This is why you cannot assume a dog was comfortable just because the house is quiet and nothing is broken.
A habit of following the owner around is not in itself evidence of separation anxiety. The Merck Veterinary Manual explains that dogs that follow family members around the house are not at greater risk of separation distress disorder than other dogs. Rather than worrying about following behavior alone, it comes first to check how the dog looks when alone.
How do you tell it apart from other causes that look similar?
Not all problem behavior that occurs when a dog is alone is separation anxiety. The ASPCA lists physical problems such as incontinence, submissive urination or excitement urination, incomplete house training, territorial marking, chewing by young puppies, boredom, and barking in response to sounds outside as problems to be distinguished from separation anxiety. The Merck Veterinary Manual summarizes that incomplete house training, exploratory play and foraging, excitement from outside stimuli, noise aversion and confinement anxiety must be excluded.
The table below rewrites the explanations in these sources as questions that are easy for owners to observe. Rather than telling causes apart by one criterion, it is safer to look at several rows together and, if unsure, show a veterinarian along with video. The Merck Veterinary Manual also explains that separation anxiety and noise fear often occur together, so one possibility applying does not remove the others.
It is also worth knowing why each distinction is difficult. Toileting problems can come from the body, as with muscle weakness or bladder problems in older dogs, and a young puppy may not have finished house training yet. Noise fear occurs even when the owner is nearby when there is thunder or construction noise. So you need to check separately whether the same behavior appears while you are at home and whether it matches the moment of the sound.
| Suspected cause | Question for the owner to check | How it differs from separation anxiety |
|---|---|---|
| Separation anxiety | Does it start right after the owner leaves, or from the moment the owner gets ready to leave? | It does not usually appear when the owner is nearby, and anxiety signs such as panting, trembling and drooling are often seen together |
| Boredom or excess energy | Does the dog play with objects while alone without looking anxious? | The ASPCA attributes destruction that occurs without anxiety signs to boredom |
| Incomplete house training | Does the dog sometimes have accidents even when the owner is at home? | It happens at any time, not only when alone |
| Noise fear | Does the timing match thunder, fireworks or construction noise? | The dog trembles or hides at the sound even when the owner is nearby |
| Confinement or space anxiety | Does it get worse only when the dog is in a crate or a small room? | The same behavior can appear if the dog is confined even when the owner is at home |
| Physical problem | Are there other changes, such as urine leaking during sleep or drinking a lot of water? | Pain, urinary problems, medication effects and the like need a veterinary check |
How do you check by recording video?
Because an owner cannot see directly what the dog does while the house is empty, video or audio recording is the most reliable way to check. The Merck Veterinary Manual lists video recording as a very useful diagnostic tool, explaining that it shows the behavior itself, other signs of anxiety, and whether there are stimuli pointing to other diagnoses. The same source advises that even after treatment starts, video can show whether the dog stays below the threshold at which it feels anxiety and how it is progressing. VCA recommends recording how the dog looks when alone on video or audio, and the RSPCA recommends filming it.
When recording, also writing down the following information helps when consulting a veterinarian.
- The time you left and the time you returned, and the walk and meal times that day
- The point at which the behavior started, that is, right after leaving or when getting ready to leave, and how many minutes later
- What behavior continued and for how long, such as barking, pacing, scratching, toileting, drooling or panting
- Whether the behavior overlaps with moments of outside stimuli such as sounds from outside the window, the doorbell or a parcel delivery
- The point the RSPCA makes that, when there is no video, a neighbor's complaint about barking is also a clue
Several days of records are better than one video. Comparing whether the reaction differs on workdays when you leave for work and on days off, and whether it changes when you leave in a different way, makes it easier to gauge the cause. VCA explains that some dogs show symptoms on every departure and some only on particular departures, such as workdays.
Seeing the dog struggling on video weighs heavily on the owner too. At such a time, it is better to use the footage as material to grasp the current state objectively rather than to blame yourself. The camera can keep being used during practice as well. In that case you can check the point where the dog's anxiety signs first appear and use it as a standard for setting the time of the next practice.
What can you try first at home? Gradual practice of being alone
Two principles underlie the practice. Desensitization is repeating time alone at a level so mild that the dog feels no anxiety until it gets used to it, and counterconditioning is changing the feeling by pairing the being-alone situation with something the dog likes, for example a long-lasting treat. The ASPCA describes a step-by-step program combining the two, explaining that with several practice sessions a day it may be possible within a few weeks, but that moderate or worse cases need a more complex program and it is better to get professional help.
First, have a veterinary clinic check that there is no physical problem, and during the practice period adjust the schedule so the dog is not left alone for long outside practice time. The ASPCA and VCA describe using family, friends, a pet sitter or a dog care facility during practice. This is because if anxiety repeats even while practicing, progress slows by that much.
The steps are generally described as follows.
- Step 1, desensitize the leaving cues: repeat several times a day, only when the dog is calm, picking up keys or putting on shoes without going out. VCA describes this practice as about 3 to 4 times a day.
- Step 2, stay out of sight: start with staying behind an inner door for 1 to 2 seconds and coming back, then 5 to 10 seconds, and then extend a little at a time. This follows ASPCA guidance.
- Step 3, open the door, go out and come back: widen from the room door to the bedroom door to the front door, adding only a few seconds at a time.
- Step 4, extend the time: the ASPCA explains that most anxiety reactions appear within the first 40 minutes alone, and advises that once the dog passes 40 minutes comfortably, you extend in 5-minute steps and then in 15-minute steps. It says that if the dog calmly endures 90 minutes, several hours may become possible.
- Leave an interval of a few minutes in between, and do the next practice only after confirming the dog is calm enough.
The key is to match the speed to the dog's reaction. The ASPCA advises that if signs such as dilated pupils, panting, yawning, drooling, trembling, pacing or an overexcited greeting appear, you should shorten the time and proceed more slowly. The RSPCA also explains that if the dog moves or reacts, you should not reward it and should go back one step. The Merck Veterinary Manual warns that for moderate or worse cases this kind of graduated departure practice can take months, so steadiness matters more than expecting to finish in a short period.
There are also helps you can add in daily life. Let the dog use its body enough with a walk or play before you leave (the RSPCA gives as an example a walk that ends about 30 minutes before going out), and give a special puzzle toy or chew only just before leaving and remove it when you return, as the ASPCA and the RSPCA advise. Such treats should be counted within the daily feeding amount to avoid obesity. However, the ASPCA explains that this method suits mild cases and that dogs with severe anxiety often will not eat when alone.
What should you not do, and what are common misconceptions?
The first thing to avoid is punishment. The ASPCA says separation anxiety behavior is a response to distress, not disobedience or spite, and advises that scolding or punishing can increase anxiety and make the problem worse. The RSPCA explains that shouting on return or correcting physically makes the dog fail to connect it with the earlier behavior and only increases anxiety, and recommends only reward-based methods. The RSPCA also advises that if you see a mess, you should first let the dog outside and then clean up.
- Scolding, shouting and physical punishment: can increase anxiety.
- Long, emotional goodbyes and excited greetings on return: VCA advises that goodbyes only draw attention to the departure and that you should ignore the dog until it calms down.
- Letting the dog out while it is crying or barking: VCA advises that the dog should be let out when it has settled calmly, so as not to reinforce crying and barking.
- Suddenly leaving the dog alone for a long time without practice: going from a short absence to a long one all at once can trigger anxiety.
- Relying only on a crate: the ASPCA advises that a crate can add to anxiety in some dogs, and VCA that it can strongly provoke escape attempts and must be used with care.
- Expecting to solve it with sedative-type medication alone: VCA explains that sedation alone does not reduce the underlying anxiety.
Common misconceptions are also pointed out. First, the idea that a dog destroys things out of revenge is not correct. Second, the expectation that getting another dog will solve it also had no basis that could be confirmed. In the sources examined for this article, such a method was not introduced as a general solution. Third, if you repeatedly go out without practice, thinking two hours will be fine for an anxious dog, the experience can instead accumulate and deepen the anxiety. The Merck Veterinary Manual advises reducing the dog's time alone as much as possible during treatment to keep it from becoming more sensitive.
Finally, this article does not cover medication in detail. The ASPCA advises that most dogs need medication used together with behavior modification and to consult a veterinarian before use, and the Merck Veterinary Manual explains that there is a drug approved by the US FDA for treating separation anxiety in dogs to be used with a behavior modification plan, and that it is particularly effective when used together with behavior modification. Which drug to use and how much is for a veterinarian who knows the dog's health to decide. Owners should not give medication on their own based on internet reviews or other dogs' experiences.
When should you seek a veterinarian and a behavior consultation specialist?
It is better to see a veterinarian before starting behavior practice. The ASPCA advises ruling out physical causes before starting behavior modification, and consulting a veterinarian before using medication. Urinary problems, pain and age-related changes can look like separation anxiety, and VCA explains that reduced hearing and vision, pain and changes in cognitive function in older dogs can increase anxiety and dependence. Changes in older dogs are covered in detail in a separate article, so they are mentioned only briefly here.
In the following cases it is better to hurry to get professional help.
- The dog has injured its teeth, nails or paws while trying to escape, or has tried to break through a window or door
- The dog barks or cries almost continuously when alone, drools heavily, or refuses food altogether
- The time does not increase, or even gets worse, after several weeks of step-by-step practice
- The owner's schedule leaves no way to avoid leaving the dog alone during the practice period
- Other problems such as aggression or noise fear are present along with anxiety
- The owner is badly worn out and daily life is disrupted by neighbor complaints or housing problems
It is also good to know the kinds of professionals. The ASPCA advises that it is ideal for an applied animal behaviorist or a veterinary behavior specialist to draw up and lead the plan, and explains that a general trainer is acceptable only when they have specific education and experience in handling fear with desensitization and counterconditioning. The RSPCA advises that if unsettled behavior is seen you should tell a veterinarian first, and that the veterinarian can refer you to a clinical behaviorist. The point is that separation anxiety is a complex problem, so do not struggle to solve it alone and get help.
When going for a consultation, bringing the videos and records made earlier, the usual meal and walk times, and the methods tried so far and the dog's responses to them can save time. If you show the practice you have done at home as it is, it is also easier for the professional to adjust the pace.
How can you get help in Korea?
In Korea too, the order is the same. First have a nearby veterinary clinic check for physical problems, and if behavior consultation is needed, ask a veterinarian. Among the official Korean materials this article checked, none dealt with how to manage separation anxiety itself. So the specific practice methods are based on the overseas animal welfare and veterinary sources above, and for Korea the article focuses on systems and consultation channels.
The Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (MAFRA) explains that as the number of pet-owning households has grown, demand for specialized behavior correction and training has increased, so it introduced a national qualification system for pet behavior instructors. This qualification is obtained when a person with specialized knowledge in analyzing and evaluating pet behavior, training, and educating owners passes an exam administered by MAFRA, and it is said to operate as a grade system with levels 1 and 2. However, this qualification does not replace a veterinarian's diagnosis or treatment. Whether there is a physical problem and whether medication is needed are the veterinarian's domain, and when getting behavior consultation, checking whether the person is qualified and whether they instruct with reward-based methods is recommended as an opinion.
The housing environment is also something to consider. In an environment with many multi-family dwellings, a dog's barking when alone easily reaches the neighbors. This point is not something confirmed by statistics but an explanation of general living conditions. Asking neighbors for understanding and asking them to tell you when the barking starts gives a clue that supplements video records. The RSPCA also advises that neighbor complaints can be a clue for noticing the problem.
There are also differences from overseas standards. For the use of crates, dog care facilities and professional pet sitters mentioned in overseas sources, access and cost in Korea may differ by region and household. This article could not confirm such differences with figures, so for avoiding leaving the dog alone during the practice period, it is realistic to look within what each household can do, such as help from family, friends and neighbors or adjusting vacation days.
Frequently asked questions
Q Is all barking when a dog is alone separation anxiety?
No. The ASPCA advises that barking in response to sounds or sights outside the window, boredom and incomplete house training can also look similar. The clue is whether it is fine when the owner is there but continues, together with anxiety signs, only when the dog is alone, and it is better to check by video.
Q How long should the video be?
There is no set time, but the Merck Veterinary Manual explains that symptoms usually start between 15 and 30 minutes after the owner leaves, so it is better to record from the moment you leave and beyond that point. Comparing records from several days helps more.
Q How many times a day should I practice being alone?
The ASPCA describes it as a process of several weeks with repeated practice sessions, giving about twice a day on weekdays as an example. More important than the number of times is that the dog starts calm and that you end before anxiety signs appear. Adjust it to your household's circumstances and the dog's reactions.
Q Wouldn't scolding when I come back make the dog understand?
The ASPCA and the RSPCA advise that scolding does not help. The dog does not connect the mess with its earlier behavior, and punishment can increase anxiety. It is better to clean up quietly and focus on practice that makes the dog's time alone comfortable from now on.
Q Will medication fix it?
The ASPCA and the Merck Veterinary Manual advise that medication helps in some cases, but they say it is most effective when used together with behavior modification, and VCA also explains that sedation alone does not reduce the underlying anxiety. Whether to use it, which kind and how much are for a veterinarian to decide based on the dog's health, so owners must not give it on their own.
Q Will getting another dog make it better?
The sources checked for this article contain nothing introducing getting another dog as a solution to separation anxiety. The Merck Veterinary Manual instead explains that in some cases the issue is which person the dog is separated from. Make the decision to bring in a new pet separately and carefully, and it is better not to expect it to be a remedy for separation anxiety.
Q Is a young puppy crying the first time it is alone also separation anxiety?
Crying while adapting to a new environment is common, and it cannot be judged to be separation anxiety on that alone. The Merck Veterinary Manual advises letting a puppy regularly have time alone comfortably in a safe place during the day. Start with a short time, and if it goes on for a long time, talk to a veterinarian.
Limits and scope of this guide
This article is general information based on healthy adult dogs and is not a diagnosis or treatment instruction. The practice times and numbers of sessions are examples from overseas animal welfare and veterinary sources, and each dog responds differently, so they should not be matched exactly. Medication is for veterinarians and is not covered. No Korean public material directly addressing the management of separation anxiety could be confirmed, so the Korean part stops at system guidance, and the latest schedule and requirements of the qualification exam were not checked. For severe symptoms, consult a veterinarian.
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.
Sources and check dates
- Separation Anxiety ↗
Used as the basis for the signs of separation anxiety, distinguishing similar problems, the desensitization and counterconditioning steps, not punishing, and criteria for professional consultation.
- Separation Distress Disorder in Dogs (Behavior Problems of Dogs) ↗
Used as the basis for when symptoms start, the diagnostic value of video recording, excluding other causes, graduated departure practice, and the point that medication is used together with behavior modification.
- Training your dog to be left alone ↗
Used as the basis for hidden signs and checking by video, reward-based step practice, not punishing, and consulting a clinical behaviorist.
- Separation Anxiety in Dogs ↗
Used as the basis for what to distinguish in diagnosis, the number of times to desensitize departure cues, behaviors to avoid, and the mention of changes in older dogs.
- Changes to pet-related systems in 2024 (guide to the introduction of the national qualification for pet behavior instructors) (2024년 달라지는 반려동물 관련 제도(반려동물행동지도사 국가자격 도입 안내)) ↗
Used as the basis for introducing, as Korean guidance, the purpose of the national qualification for pet behavior instructors and its level 1 and level 2 grade system.
Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.
