Skip to content
Grochi · Neutral pet information from South Korea · English edition한국어
Grochi.English edition
Pet supplies

How do dental chews, toothpaste and water additives differ, and what is the evidence?

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. This page is an English translation of the Korean edition as checked on 2026-11-19. If the two differ, the Korean edition is the reference. 한국어판 (Korean edition)

How do dental chews, toothpaste and water additives differ, and what is the evidence?
Short answer

Toothbrushing and pet toothpaste are the basics with the firmest evidence, while dental chews, dental diets and water additives are supplementary. No product replaces scaling under anesthesia.

Key takeaways

  • Products for pet dental care fall into toothbrushing, dental chews, dental diets, water additives, oral sprays and gels, and toys, and the Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine describes toothbrushing as the most effective of these to do at home.
  • Dental chews and water additives are supplementary means of reducing plaque and calculus when brushing is difficult, and because studies are done product by product, the result for one product cannot be carried over to another as is.
  • The VOHC seal of acceptance is a system in which a council reviews clinical data submitted by the manufacturer and accepts an effect on plaque or calculus control, so having the seal does not mean that disease below the gums is solved.
  • Human toothpaste may contain xylitol, which is toxic to dogs, so the US FDA advises using only toothpaste made for animals on pets.
  • Bones, antlers, hooves, rawhide and hard toys can wear down or fracture teeth, and no product replaces scaling under anesthesia, which looks below the gums as well.

Do dental chews, toothpaste and water additives play the same role?

The 3 products play different roles. Brushing with pet toothpaste cleans the tooth surface directly and physically removes plaque (the bacterial film that sticks to teeth), a dental chew is a treat meant to reduce plaque and calculus through the chewing action and the product's ingredients, and a water additive is a liquid mixed into drinking water to act on oral bacteria and deposits. Because the way they work is different, it is hard to regard any of them as replacing the others.

The Riney Canine Health Center at the Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine in the US explains that, among home care measures, toothbrushing is the most effective. In the same guidance, it lists dental diets, dental chews and treats, water additives, and oral gels and sprays as alternatives when brushing is difficult, and writes that such products may help reduce plaque and calculus (Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine). In other words, university-level guidance puts toothbrushing as the basis and classifies the rest as supplementary means.

Knowing the difference between plaque and calculus makes product wording easier to read. Plaque is a mass of bacteria that builds up like a film on the tooth surface, so it is relatively soft and comes off when brushed. Calculus is plaque that has hardened and is difficult to scrape off at home. A package that says "plaque reduction" and one that says "calculus reduction" target different things, so you need to check separately which one a product is aiming at.

The brushing method itself is covered in a separate article (the basics of pet toothbrushing), so this article concentrates on comparing product types. The table below sums up at a glance, by type, what each tries to reduce, how strong the evidence is, and what to be careful about.

Comparison of dental care product types (summary of general principles, not an evaluation of specific products)
TypeMain targetLevel of evidencePoints to watch
Toothbrushing + pet toothpastePlaque (cleans the surface directly)Described in university veterinary school guidance as the most effective home methodDo not use human toothpaste; it may be hard to keep up every day
Dental chews and dental treatsPlaque or calculus (varies by product)Some products have test data, but results are per product and the product company pays for the testingCalories, risk of swallowing or obstruction, and an opinion that they are less effective on the incisors and canines
Dental dietsPlaque or calculus (varies by diet)Mentioned as an alternative by the Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine; per-product test data needs to be checkedNutritional balance of the regular diet needs separate checking
Water additivesOral bacteria, plaque, some calculusThe evidence this article found is 1 single-product 30-day trial (manufacturer-sponsored)Water intake and palatability, and checking the product's ingredients
Oral sprays and gelsPlaque and bad breath (varies by product)Mentioned as a supplementary means by the Cornell University College of Veterinary MedicineApplication method and the pet's resistance
Calculus-removal toysSome surface deposits through chewing frictionSee the last paragraph of the section on checking products for the level of evidenceIf too hard, tooth wear or fracture, and swallowing broken pieces

Why is toothbrushing called the basis and the rest supplementary?

Toothbrushing is named as the basis because it directly cleans the bacterial film off the tooth surface. The Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine describes toothbrushing as the most effective method to do at home, and says that when this is difficult, dental diets, chews, water additives, gels and sprays can be used (Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine). This guidance is framed with toothbrushing as the basis and presents other products as options when brushing is difficult.

The evidence for dental chews builds up product by product. VOHC explains that it does not test products itself but reviews data submitted by the manufacturer and gives its seal of acceptance when an effect on plaque or calculus control has been shown (VOHC). A Maeil Shinmun article of October 16, 2026 reported that VOHC gives its seal only to products whose effect has been shown in two independent clinical trials, and said that most commercially sold dental chews have not gone through such verification (Maeil Shinmun). This article is a news report, so it does not directly confirm the proportion across all products on the market.

The evidence for water additives is thinner. A randomized controlled study published in Frontiers in Veterinary Science in 2023 tested one water additive containing pomegranate in 40 dogs for 30 days, and reported that plaque and calculus scores were lower in the additive group, used after professional scaling, than in the control group. The same paper disclosed that the manufacturer funded the study, that one of the authors was an employee of the manufacturer and that another author received financial support from the manufacturer. It also wrote that not assessing each dog's rate of plaque accumulation before the start and reflecting it in the random assignment may be a bias or limitation. The authors concluded that this additive can be recommended after professional scaling. This article's judgment is that, as 1 trial that looked at one product from one manufacturer for 30 days, it is hard to extend to other products or to long-term effects (Frontiers study).

To sum up, the level of evidence can be read roughly in the following order. Toothbrushing is placed first in the university guidance. Dental chews and diets sometimes have per-product clinical data, but the structure is that the product company pays for the testing (VOHC). For water additives, the only evidence this article saw is 1 single-product 30-day trial. For sprays, gels and toys, this article did not find independent comparative evidence.

What does the VOHC acceptance system mean, and what are its limits?

The VOHC (Veterinary Oral Health Council, 수의구강건강위원회) is a system that reviews the effect of products on plaque and calculus control in pets and gives a seal of acceptance. According to VOHC's own explanation, the council does not test products itself but reviews test data that the product company ran and submitted under the VOHC protocol. Two trials are required, and animals used in one trial cannot be used in the other. The accepted category may be plaque, calculus or both, and there are separate categories for dogs and for cats (VOHC).

The meaning of this system lies in the fact that "the manufacturer's claim has gone through a certain review." The VOHC leadership page explains that the council consists of 9 veterinary dental specialists and dental scientists and a non-voting officer, and that the members are appointed by the president and board of the American Veterinary Dental College (AVDC). So a product with the seal gives you at least a basis for checking what data was submitted. Reading the seal's category (plaque or calculus) together also tells you what the product aims to reduce.

The limits are also clear. First, the categories VOHC accepts are the two of "plaque control" and "calculus control," and it does not review the treatment of disease below the gums that has already developed (VOHC). The Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine describes the treatment of dental disease that has already developed as professional treatment under anesthesia that removes plaque and calculus above and below the gums and checks with X-rays, and explains that the veterinarian examines the mouth at regular visits (Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine). Second, the seal is awarded on the manufacturer's application, so the absence of a seal is not evidence that a product has no effect. It may simply be a product that did not apply for review. Third, according to the VOHC protocol page, the trial period is at least 28 days, and for chewed products there is a standard that the test group must be reduced by at least 15% compared with the control group in one trial and by at least 20% on average across the two trials (VOHC). However, the size of the effect of a product with the seal cannot be stated.

Finally, VOHC is a US system. When this seal is used in the description of a product sold in Korea, it is safer to check directly, from the list of that body, whether the accepted category and the target animal (for dogs or for cats) match the product. This article does not address whether any specific product is accepted.

What should you know about the situation in Korea?

The situation around these products in Korea can be summed up in two points. One is that it has not been confirmed whether a common mark proving a product's effect has become widely established, and the other is that the boundary between care at home and treatment at the hospital often becomes blurred.

In a Maeil Shinmun article of October 16, 2026, a veterinarian in the pet nutrition field said that hard chews can remove only hard calculus and that soft, pliable dental chews help more with plaque removal, adding that dental chews are a supplementary means and that the most effective method is regular brushing. A director of an animal dental hospital is also reported to have explained that dental chews help somewhat with the molars but have no effect on the incisors and canines. In the same article, the Korean Veterinary Dental Association (한국수의치과협회) warned that overly hard chews and bone treats can break teeth and block the digestive tract (Maeil Shinmun). These are the opinions of individual experts, so in terms of level of evidence they count as expert opinion.

On scaling without anesthesia done at home, there is a Dailyvet article introducing the pet section of the September 2024 issue of the Korean Veterinary Medical Association (대한수의사회) monthly magazine, Animal Medicine (동물의료). According to this article, a director of an animal hospital warned that the vibration frequency of a self-use ultrasonic scaler is in fact at the level of sound waves that fall short of ultrasound, that pressing hard without anesthesia can injure the gums and teeth, and that it cannot reach calculus on the molars, the inner surfaces and below the gums, so periodontal disease can worsen. The article also urged that licensed veterinarians should avoid giving the impression that scaling without anesthesia is the same as proper scaling under anesthesia (Dailyvet).

Summed up from the owner's point of view, in Korea it is hard to judge the effect from a product's advertising wording alone, and it is good to remember that scaling is treatment carried out by a veterinarian. Other topics, such as feed and labeling systems, are covered in the relevant articles.

How does it differ from overseas standards?

The biggest difference between overseas standards and the situation in Korea is how well known a third-party mark that sorts out product effects is. In the US, the seal of acceptance from VOHC, a private council, is cited as a reference for choosing products, and the Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine also notes that the VOHC website has a list of accepted products (Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine). In Korea, by contrast, it is hard to assert that this mark has become established as a mark in common use across the industry, and Maeil Shinmun reports that most commercially sold dental chews have not gone through verification at the level the mark indicates.

On safety standards, the similarities are greater than the differences. The US FDA advises not using human toothpaste and using only toothpaste made for pets. This is because some human toothpastes may contain xylitol, which is toxic to dogs (FDA). The same ingredient problem applies equally in Korea, but this article could not directly confirm the xylitol content of human toothpaste in Korea or the related regulations. So the habit of reading the ingredient list yourself is the most realistic line of defense.

On the position on scaling under anesthesia, overseas professional bodies have stated it clearly. The FelineVMA, a body of cat veterinarians, and the Feline Oral Care Guidelines Task Force said that they oppose anesthesia-free dental procedures and support the position statements already issued. This page cited the 2019 AAHA dental care guidelines and the American Veterinary Dental College (AVDC) position statement on scaling without anesthesia as references (FelineVMA). The specific wording of the two bodies is not quoted.

To sum up, Korea and overseas share the same broad framework: toothbrushing as the basis, products as supplements, and scaling as veterinary care. What differs is how easily a consumer can find out which products have gone through what verification. So when owners in Korea choose a product, it helps to check whether an overseas certification mark is used, which category it is if so, and what trial the manufacturer presents.

What should you check before choosing a product?

What to check before choosing a product can be organized into the list below. None of the items recommends a specific product; they are criteria to use when reading a product description.

  • Target to reduce: read the wording and the accepted category to tell whether the product targets plaque or calculus.
  • Test data: check whether it is stated who tested it, on how many animals and for how long, and whether it is a manufacturer-sponsored study. If it is not stated, treat it as a product with unclear evidence.
  • Seal of acceptance: if there is a mark such as VOHC, check whether it is for dogs or cats and for plaque or calculus, and remember that even with the mark it does not replace scaling.
  • Ingredient list: for toothpaste and oral products, read whether there are ingredients dangerous to dogs, such as xylitol. Do not use products made for people.
  • Size and shape: check that chews and chewable items suit the pet's body weight, and avoid sizes that are easy to swallow. The VOHC news page introduces material dealing with the risk of the esophagus or digestive tract becoming blocked after swallowing a dental chew (VOHC). For that reason, this article recommends choosing a size suited to body weight and giving it only when the owner is watching.
  • Calories: a dental chew is also a treat, so count it in the total daily treat amount. Specific calorie figures must be checked on the product label, and this article does not give figures. Weight management is covered in a separate article.
  • Hardness: hard materials such as bones, antlers, hooves and rawhide are the kinds the Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine warns carry a risk of tooth wear and fracture.
  • The pet's habits: for a pet that swallows whole without chewing, products that work by chewing may be less effective and may be risky.

Even a product that passes this whole list does not replace toothbrushing or professional veterinary care. It is safest to keep products only as one part of care at home.

What this article could not confirm is as follows.

  • The actual reduction rates of individual VOHC-accepted products
  • Whether the word "independent" in the Maeil Shinmun article means the same as in VOHC's explanation (the product company pays for the testing and submits the data, with two trials on different animals)
  • The approval and labeling systems for pet oral products in Korea, and the xylitol content of human toothpaste in Korea
  • Independent comparative evidence for oral sprays and gels and for calculus-removal toys
  • The exact hardness criteria for hard materials such as bones, antlers and hooves

These items did not come out of the material this article opened, so they are not asserted in the text.

What are the common misunderstandings about human toothpaste and hard chews?

The first misunderstanding is the idea that "it's fine to use human toothpaste for a short time." The US FDA explains that xylitol is found in gum, candy, mouthwash, some human toothpastes and so on, and that although in people it does not stimulate insulin release from the pancreas, in dogs it can greatly increase insulin release and can cause dangerous low blood sugar within 10 to 60 minutes. The symptoms include vomiting, lethargy, staggering, collapse and seizures, and it advises that they can appear 12 to 24 hours later, so hospital observation may be needed even if the dog looks fine. For that reason, it recommends using only toothpaste made for animals on pets (FDA). This does not mean that all human toothpastes use xylitol, only that some do. The FDA wrote that xylitol does not appear to be as dangerous to other pets such as cats as it is to dogs, but that is not a basis for recommending human toothpaste for cats.

The second misunderstanding is the idea that "the harder it is, the better it cleans off calculus." The Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine advises that chewing helps with dental health and satisfying the urge to be active, but that bones, antlers, hooves, rawhide and hard artificial toys can wear down or fracture teeth and can also cause digestive tract injury or blockage (Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine). In the Maeil Shinmun article too, the Korean Veterinary Dental Association warned of the risk of tooth fracture and digestive tract blockage from overly hard chews and bone treats.

The third misunderstanding is the idea that "a dental chew is not a treat but a treatment tool." A dental chew is also a treat, so it has calories, and it can cause a blockage if swallowed. This is why you should choose a size suited to body weight and watch while the pet eats it.

The fourth misunderstanding is the idea that "if you use a calculus-removal product, you don't need scaling." The Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine explains that in professional treatment, anesthesia is needed for a complete oral examination and dental X-rays, and that plaque and calculus above and below the gums are removed with a scaler. Products do not replace this process.

In what situations should you see a veterinarian?

Even while managing with products at home, if any of the following signs appear, having the mouth checked at an animal hospital comes before changing products. They are when bad breath suddenly gets much worse, when the gums are red or bleed, when the pet drools more than usual, when it chews on only one side or hesitates while eating, when one side of the face is swollen or it dislikes having the area around the mouth touched, and when a tooth is broken or loose. These are general criteria for owners to check, and this article does not diagnose any specific disease.

If a tooth has broken while chewing on a hard chewable item, it is good to have a veterinarian check it even if it does not yet seem to hurt. This is because a broken tooth may have problems that cannot be seen from the outside. Also, if after swallowing a piece of a chew or toy there is vomiting, reduced appetite, dislike of having the belly touched, or difficulty breathing, you should contact an animal hospital immediately.

If a pet has eaten human toothpaste or a product containing xylitol, the FDA's guidance is to contact a veterinarian, an emergency animal hospital or an animal poison helpline immediately even if there are no symptoms. Because symptoms can appear late, the key is not to wait.

Regular checkups are also important. The Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine advises that the veterinarian examines the mouth of the awake animal at each annual visit and may recommend it more often depending on age, breed, tooth condition and history. Whether to have scaling under anesthesia, at what interval, and what to do with senior pets or pets with existing illness at high anesthetic risk are individual judgments, so they should be discussed with the veterinarian in charge. This article does not give intervals or figures for anesthetic risk.

Frequently asked questions

Q If I give dental chews, can I skip brushing?

It is hard to regard it that way. The Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine describes toothbrushing as the most effective home method and treats chews as an alternative when brushing is difficult. A veterinarian introduced in Maeil Shinmun also said that dental chews are a supplementary means. There is also an opinion that chews help with the molars but are less effective on the incisors and canines.

Q Do water additives remove calculus?

It is hard to say so on the evidence confirmed. The 2023 randomized controlled study this article read tested one product in 40 dogs for 30 days, and the group that used it after professional scaling had lower deposit scores, but the period was short, it was a manufacturer-sponsored study and the result was for a single product. No evidence was found that it removes calculus that has already formed.

Q Can I feel safe if there is a VOHC mark?

The mark means that the council reviewed data submitted by the manufacturer and accepted an effect on plaque or calculus control. It does not mean that safety and nutrition are guaranteed, nor that disease below the gums is solved. Check the category too, whether it is for dogs or cats and for plaque or calculus, and it is good to give a size suited to body weight while the owner is watching.

Q Isn't it fine to use just a tiny bit of human toothpaste?

The FDA advises using only toothpaste made for animals on pets. Some human toothpastes may contain xylitol, which can cause low blood sugar and seizures in dogs. No standard can be given for 'a little is fine.' If you suspect the pet has eaten some, contact a veterinarian even if there are no symptoms.

Q If my pet chews bones or antlers, do the teeth get clean?

The Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine advises that bones, antlers, hooves, rawhide and hard artificial toys can wear down or fracture teeth and can also cause digestive tract problems. The Korean Veterinary Dental Association was also reported to have warned of the risks of overly hard chews and bone treats. The risk should be weighed before how clean they get.

Q Isn't scaling without anesthesia enough?

In a contribution to the Korean Veterinary Medical Association monthly magazine introduced by a Korean professional outlet, it was warned that scaling without anesthesia cannot reach calculus on the molars, the inner surfaces and below the gums and can injure the gums and teeth. Overseas veterinary bodies have also stated their opposition to anesthesia-free procedures. The Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine explains that anesthesia is needed for a complete oral examination and X-rays.

Limits and scope of this guide

Much of the material for this article is dog-centered, so it is hard to apply as is to cats and other pets, and for senior animals or animals with existing illness at high anesthetic risk, and for animals whose oral disease has already progressed, a veterinarian's diagnosis comes before choosing a product. The original pages of the AVMA and AAHA did not open, so the wording of those two bodies could not be quoted directly, and the other items that could not be confirmed are gathered in the last paragraph of the section on checking products. The two Korean sources are a professional outlet and a daily newspaper report, so they should not be given the same weight as guidance from a public body. This article does not evaluate specific products and does not replace diagnosis or prescription.

Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean edition is an explainer newly written from public sources; it is not a full translation of those sources. Veterinary expert review has not been completed. For decisions about your pet's health, talk to a veterinarian who knows your pet.

Sources and check dates

  1. About the VOHC ↗

    Used as the basis for the explanation that VOHC does not test products itself and gives its seal of acceptance after reviewing test data under its protocol.

  2. Protocols & Submissions ↗

    Used as the basis for the two accepted categories of plaque and calculus, the two-trial requirement, and the structure in which the product company bears the cost of testing.

  3. Trial Protocol Requirements ↗

    Used as the basis for the 28-day minimum trial period and the effect standard (at least 15%, 20% on average reduction).

  4. Leadership ↗

    Used as the basis for the council's composition (9 members, appointed by the board of the American Veterinary Dental College).

  5. News & Publications ↗

    Used as the basis for the fact that VOHC introduced material dealing with the risk of obstruction after a dental chew is swallowed.

  6. Dental Disease and Home Dental Care ↗

    Used as the basis for the explanation that toothbrushing is the most effective, the supplementary position of dental diets, chews, water additives, gels and sprays, the risk of tooth fracture from hard chewable items, and the explanation of professional treatment under anesthesia.

  7. Paws Off Xylitol; It's Dangerous for Dogs ↗

    Used as the basis for the xylitol risk in some human toothpastes, the guidance to use only toothpaste made for animals, and the symptoms and the advice to make immediate contact.

  8. A water additive with pomegranate can reduce dental plaque and calculus accumulation in dogs ↗

    Used as the basis for the results of a small randomized controlled study of a single water additive product and the limits on duration, sponsorship and generalization.

  9. Introductory article on the Korean Veterinary Medical Association monthly magazine Animal Medicine (동물의료): a warning about the dangers of self-scaling a dog without anesthesia (대한수의사회 월간지 「동물의료」 소개 기사: 반려견 무마취 셀프 스케일링의 위험성 경고) ↗

    Used as the basis for introducing a Korean veterinarian's warning about the limits of self-scaling without anesthesia (calculus on the molars, inner surfaces and below the gums not reached, risk of injury).

  10. News report on veterinarians' opinions about dental chews (덴탈껌 관련 수의사 의견 보도) ↗

    Used as the basis for a Korean veterinarian's opinion that dental chews are a supplementary means, the report that most commercially sold chews have not gone through VOHC-level verification, and the Korean Veterinary Dental Association's warning about hard chews and bone treats.

  11. 2025 Opposition of Anesthesia-free Dentistry ↗

    Used as the basis for the fact that an overseas veterinary body stated its opposition to anesthesia-free dental procedures and cited the 2019 AAHA guidelines and the AVDC position statement as references.

Korean edition checked · translated · each source may have a different check date. No paid partnerships.