About Modified Atwater factors
Atwater factors are coefficients for a method that fixes the energy produced by 1 g of a nutrient separately for protein, fat, and carbohydrate, and multiplies them by the component content to estimate calories. The name comes from Atwater, a researcher of the late 19th century. The Wikipedia entry on the Atwater system explains that the practice of using about 4 kcal per gram for carbohydrate and protein and about 9 kcal for fat in human food comes from this research.
Because digestive and metabolic losses differ in pet food, a calculation method using "modified" factors, which lower these coefficients to suit dogs and cats, is known. However, the specific factor numbers could not be confirmed in the sources opened this time (AAFCO, the Merck Veterinary Manual, and the Tufts University article). So this explanation does not give numbers. If specific values are needed, they must be checked directly in original texts such as official AAFCO publications.
In its consumer guidance, the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) explains that manufacturers may determine calorie content by their own calculation or by an AAFCO test method, and must state which method was used. A factor-based calculation may be one such method, but this page does not mention factors directly.
The registered components set by Appendix 13 of the Korean notice Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격) do not include calories, and no rule requiring modified Atwater factors for calorie calculation was found within the scope checked this time. When a calorie labeling is present, the method by which it was obtained often cannot be confirmed from the label.
Calories obtained with factors are only an estimate. The Wikipedia entry presents as limitations the criticism that values derived from an average diet may not fit individual foods, and the uncertainty of fiber's energy contribution. Even feeds with the same component labeling can have different actual energy depending on ingredients and digestibility.
How it appears on labels
| On Korean labels | 포장에 계수 자체는 적히지 않으며, 열량(kcal/kg) 표시의 계산 근거로 쓰였는지도 보통 표시에서 확인할 수 없다. (The factors themselves are not written on the package, and whether they were used as the basis for the calorie (kcal/kg) labeling usually cannot be confirmed from the label.) |
|---|---|
| On English labels | The calculation or test method may be stated with the Calorie Content item, and the factors are usually not written. |
| Unit / basis | kcal/g (estimated energy per 1 g of nutrient) |
Which standard is it?
- Korea: calories are not among the registered components in Appendix 13 of Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격), and a rule on using modified Atwater factors was not found.
- US AAFCO: calorie content is determined by own calculation or an AAFCO test method and the method is stated. Specific factors are not on the pages opened.
- Specific factor numbers were not confirmed in the sources opened and are not given.
Common misconceptions
- A calculated calorie value is an actual measured value → Calories obtained with factors are values estimated from the component labeling and do not reflect digestibility or ingredient differences.
- Every feed uses the same factors, so calorie labels can be compared as they are → The method may differ, calculation or testing, behind the calorie labeling.
What to check on the label
- Check whether the calculation or test method is written next to the calorie labeling.
- If the method cannot be confirmed from the label, read the calories as an approximate value.
- You can ask the manufacturer whether the labeled calorie value is based on minimum and maximum values or on average analyzed values.
Related guides
Where was this checked?
- InternationalAssociation of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) · Calories ↗
Basis for calories being determined by own calculation or an AAFCO test method with the method stated (no factor numbers). (checked 2026-11-19)
- InternationalWikipedia · Atwater system ↗
Basis for the origin of Atwater factors (about 4 kcal/g for carbohydrate and protein, about 9 for fat) and their limitations. (checked 2026-11-19)
- KoreaMinistry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (농림축산식품부) · National Law Information Center (law.go.kr) · Standards and Specifications for Feeds (사료 등의 기준 및 규격), MAFRA Notice No. 2024-27, Appendix 13 ↗
Basis for confirming that calories are not included in the Korean registered components. (checked 2026-11-19)
Translated from the Korean edition · Editorial draft, not professionally reviewed. The Korean entry is an explainer newly written from these sources, not a full translation of them. Not a diagnosis, prescription or feeding instruction. Korean edition checked 2026-11-19 · no paid partnerships.